170 John St

What's not to love about an Aussie pub! This is a true ny-take on an Aussie classic which is perfect if you're feeling like a taste of down under. Memorabilia on the walls will remind you of Aussie classics from movies TV and books or media. The TVs are always playing the footy. And you're guaranteed to hear an Aussie accent. The menu features some great classics. Including Bourke St bakery pies and sausage rolls. They also have an Aussie burger with "the lot" - i.e . Beetroot, pineapple and a fried egg. Chicken schnitzel and Parma, bangers and mash, and hot chips with chicken salt and wedges with sour cream and chilli. They have recently introduced a Sunday Roast with lamb, chicken or squash, served with crispy potatoes, veggies and a Yorkshire pudding. Trivia on Tuesdays is also a fun event! When they first opened it was really packed so you would often have to wait in line. It's settled back into a nice rhythm now.

Destination authentic Aussie Bar for 30 somethings is as good of a time as you can have. We were 7 people on a Tuesday night and it was pretty damn fun. The food and service we had was excellent. Chicken Parma Calamari burger was good buffalo cauliflower was stupid All in all it was a great time.

Absolutely fantastic in every way. Huge bar. Great beers. PERFECT food. The chicken salt on the fries...best I've ever had. A cracking good time all around. This place is loud, like can't hear your mates loud, and the crowd is young. But Old Mates definitely lives up to the title of best new bar in the city. Bartenders are hot.

Met up with a friend here and it was such a fun time! Devin G, a bartender there, was so sweet and was super lovely to talk to. Quiet but a very spacious pub that is the perfect HH meet up/early bites grab.

Bloody fantastic! Really enjoyed the authentic atmosphere and the familiar range of Australian pub meals. Service was very friendly and while there was a line to get in, we were able to get inside fairly quickly (20 minute wait) and even get a table in the dining room upstairs. There is an impressive list of Australian wines and spirits. It's the real deal.

I had a particularly bad experience here, where after commenting casually to another patron that the service was a bit slow I was kicked out. Other patrons (whom I did not know) actually intervened to tell staff that I'd done nothing wrong, but to no avail. I've had much more positive experiences at nearby pubs like Ulysses, TJ Byrnes, and Ryan Maguires which I would heartily recommend instead, and I will be telling my Australian friends not to come here if they visit.

I came here with a colleague for dinner. The menu posted outside piqued our interest, but the place was extremely lively upon entering. There are several floors, and we went to the second level. We went on a Friday, and it was around 7:00 pm. It was super crowded, so I was surprised that we were even able to snag a table. Once seated, we order cauliflower bites. These were tasty but really hot (temperature). For our entrees, I ordered the fish and chips, and she ordered the seafood linguine. We both enjoyed our meals. I know my fish was piping hot--I'm pretty sure I burnt my tongue. Old Mates definitely doesn't serve lukewarm food. It's a cool spot, but it can get very crowded. The service was good, no complaints there. Old Mates is worth checking out.

New, nicely setup authentic Aussie pub! Food was excellent. Meat pies were outstanding and the best deal on the menu ($14 each, super flavorful and filling). The fish tartare was beautiful, delicious, and great for a lighter pub option. Honey carrots were like candy. Showed up at 3pm for a late lunch, not realizing they were not open for lunch on weekdays. The staff was super nice to my daughters, offering them to use the bathroom and being very apologetic. Thankfully, there's a lovely little playground across the street, so we spent 45 minutes there and then returned. They sat us before 4pm opening time, which was above and beyond. Food came out fast for the hungry kiddos. It's right across from Pier 17, my favorite NYC summer concert venue. Will be back before shows and can't wait to try more of the menu.

I came here on a Thursday night to grab a drink. Wow, it was packed! Lots of finance bros. Nice bartenders, but not necessarily cheap.

This was not the vibe, IMO. Although the bar is massive, it was packed, loud, and full of people who looked wildly young. I came with a large group of people and we left pretty quickly.

I loved this place! It's way bigger than I expected--more than one floor and full of surprises. I didn't know what to expect from an "Australian pub," but I had a ton of fun. The oysters and burgers were both really unique and super tasty. Great vibes, good drinks, and a fun crowd. The place was absolutely packed when I went (way more than I expected), but somehow it was still easy to grab a table. Service was a bit confusing, but I went during their first week open, so I totally get they were still ironing things out. The staff was friendly, and the overall atmosphere made up for any hiccups. Can't wait for it to warm up so I can hang out on the outdoor seating!

The space just like when it was Trading Post is three floors. They put a bar on the second floor, which was a great idea so you have used through the window windows of the South Seaport. I wasn't overly crazy about the menu, but it was limited the bigger menu wasn't available when I was there so maybe it has a more interesting selection. I just had the prawns which were very good and fresh. Brock Quinn the entire staff was very friendly, which gave you a more of a local flavor which is what the south seaport area in general gives you I'll definitely be back.

Ladies, sons of ladies and everyone in between. Let me start this off by saying I'm my soul, and by my roommates permission I have been declared an honorary Aussie. If you disagree I mean no disrespect, I didn't choose this life it chose me. Old mates pub is exactly that. A family I didn't know I needed to be part of, a community of stunning humans and some FIRE FOOD! We sat upstairs where the vibes were chill but made our way down to the bar to be in the hustle and bustle of a TwoUp Tournament I chose the perfect day the Anzac Game day. Honoring all those who have served in the Australian and New Zealand army corps *slay*. I had a Rekotderlig to start my meal and finished it with Brussel Sprouts that GENUINELY MELTED IN MY MOUTH. I wasn't mad. But was sooooo disappointed when I looked down at my plate and my meal... was finished. I vacuumed that sucker down and I have no regrets. I think it's safe to say that this is going to be my local pub... and I live in Jersey so you know I mean it

Absolutely insane. The owner is an insecure manic with an ego problem. I was in the club. Having an OK time. Spent $300 on a few drinks and a burger, and then when I went down to their dance floor this ridiculous jerk runs out of the back and starts harassing me because I'm close to a TV that they had on the wall. He kicked me out of the club straight away "time to leave. Time to leave. You're slapping my TV time to leave." Completely Ludacris. There is absolutely no world in which I'm abusing this man's electronics. I tried to talk to him about it. I'm a technician and I work with electronics for a living. His ego issue completely ruined my night. They kicked me out of the club. After spending over $300 personally (and I was with a large group) They ruined my evening. He's an irrational behavior was completely inappropriate and embarrassing for both me and himself.

Was it the best parmi and Pavlova I've ever had? No, but it wasn't bad. The parmi, chicken salted chips, all the Aussies and kiwis, the triple j hottest 100 playing... it all had me craving home.

Easy seating and great location but the indifference (entitlement??) of our waitress (thin blonde) was noticeable. Response to every question was curt: Water- over there. Ranch? No. Lettuce on burger- No (actually there is). Bloody Mary? -No. Service starts with offering suggestions and guiding the customer, no but you could consider X. Food: burgers were quality, recommended! Kids pasta drenched in butter, gross. Yea, I still tipped solid but ya all still going to get the feedback. Cheers Mate!

Came here and sat at the bar, food and drinks were good but when the bill came they had the wrong drinks on it. Not a big deal but it was a pain for them to fix it, and then when I credit card bill came I noticed they doubled charged me as well. Overall, good food and drinks but watch your bill.

It is almost impossible to find a cold beer with good head in NYC. Old Mates finally fills the void. We went as a group of four on a Friday night and it was pumping. We managed to jump on to a high top with two other customers. Although super busy the food came our quick. New York prices but worth it if you like good beer and Parmis

Very scenery / nice folk / hot people but pretty annoying place to hang out / good Guinness

Went for the Knicks game last weekend and had a great time! Food was pretty good, it's def bar food but it was really good! Ambiance was 10/10 for what we wanted, and service / staff was great. It does get pretty backed for games, which could be great or not depending on what you're looking for!

An Aussie pub brought to life in the City - the vibes are fantastic, the drinks/beer menu/food are all great. The servers and bartenders are friendly and accommodating. It's worth a trek to check it out. Been once and will hopefully be back many times in the future.

Best Pub in New York. The service is top tier, will be back without a doubt. Shoutout Clippers legend Patty Mills who's part owner!

No Sunday roast green menu only I was duped I want the place to do well ............. Menu was suspect didn't even have fries

The Asian bartender is hot and makes the best cocktails. Please tip this is not Australia this is new York.

The music is terrible here and so is the staff. If you want bartenders to disrespect you come here