Alida R.
Yelp
Hamilton Pool is truly gorgeous: I saw it and thought I wasn't in Texas any more, and must have found myself in the Caribbean. To just walk down to the pool and look at the water then turn back would be a very short visit. To maximize your enjoyment, I recommend also doing the river trail, which is a beautiful, shady walk, and much less crowded than the swimming hole/pool. The whole experience was lovely and peaceful and a real oasis in the hill country.
The actual swimming area isn't open right now (summer 2021), and often is closed for swimming because of bacteria levels. There's a ranger there, making sure people don't swim, so you won't be able to sneak in! Unfortunately, the 2021 winter freeze meant that there was structural damage to the area by the waterfall, so you can't walk near there.
What prevents this from being a 5 star rating is the fact that the admission fees are quite high, compared to other state or county parks (which are either free or $8 per person): you'll pay $12 per car to reserve a spot (think of it is a parking/reservation fee) and an additional $8 cash per person, meaning it winds up being a $14/person entry fee if you go as a couple. It was worth it to me, especially since we did the river trail, but might not be worth it to everyone.