72ND Eatery

This great fast casual spot features the BEST rotisserie chicken. They also have great smoothies and nice desserts. Extremely warm customer service (shoutout to Johnny). They have self serve drinks. I haven’t tried the pizza but it looks good. Can’t wait to have the chicken again

Stopped in for a meal and was pleasantly surprised by how much this place offers. It’s conveniently located with a warm, relaxed atmosphere and friendly, attentive service. The menu has something for everyone, fresh pizzas, burgers, rotisserie chicken, salads, sandwiches, and a full bakery and coffee corner. Prices are very affordable, a solid, satisfying meal runs around sixteen dollars plus tax, which makes it an easy choice for a casual lunch or dinner. Generous portions, great quality, and a cozy vibe make this a spot I’d definitely visit again.

Great little deli style option for sandwiches, breakfast, and coffee. I stopped by here with a few friends for brunch. We all got different omelettes, which came with home/regular fries, buttered toast, and the omelette itself. I wasn't the biggest fan of the lox omelette, but the Florentine omelette tasted great. They do have a restroom in the back, and adequate seating.

This place feels like home. Yummy food. Such kind service and a cozy little eating area. I eat gf and they hooked me up with chicken and tht yummiest vegetables. We all loved it here.

72ND Eatery is a great local spot, particularly thanks to the service which I’ve rated at 4 stars. The staff was friendly and efficient, which really added to the visit. Both the food and the atmosphere were good, standard 3-star experiences that met my expectations for a casual meal. Overall, I’m giving it 4 stars as the welcoming service makes it a place worth visiting again.

Love the rotisserie chicken. Moist, flavourful without too much salt. Good cappuccino.

Loved it as it's closest to central park. They have multiple options to order, dine -in or pick up. It has a small place to dine-in there.

This is my first time ordering a cream cheese with salmon lox everything bagel. I also added to sunny side up eggs. The food quality is great!!! It tasted awesome and it was more food than I thought. The quantity was worth the price. The service was a little confusing, but I appreciate the cook helping me order because that is my first time there as a traveler. I recommend them. Fresh food and it’s made in front of you. No surprises. I would come again if I ever come back! 😎

Great corned beef sandwich. Solid pizza, solid black & white cookie. Nice staff. Basic New York deli fare done well.

Service is horrible! I very obviously ordered a lox omelette and they sent me three pieces of salmon in a container! When I called, the women who answered said I "was wrong" and denied any responsibility.

Emerging from the space formerly occupied by Columbus Gourmet Foods is 72nd Eatery which opened a coupe of weeks ago. This fast casual restaurant is owned by the same people. The interior has been wonderfully renovated to a bright spacious space. There are plenty of seating inside and out with great views of Columbus Avenue. Staff is so very friendly; I was greeted as soon as I walked through the doors. Head chef, Chef Hollywood, was behind the counter the day I went for a visit and was busy chatting visitors up. While not a lot of the food is out on display, the menu is somewhat extensive. It boasts the usual American comfort food of burgers, sandwiches, soup, salad and heavily promotes their organic Rotisserie Chicken. Initially, I was going to try their rotisserie chicken but saw that they had some nice salmon on display. I ordered their Baked Salmon with 2 sides ($15.95). For the sides, I got Sweet Corn and Mashed Potatoes with gravy. The sides were good but clearly the salmon was the star. It was nice and flaky with a hint of citrus. It was cooked a little bit more well done that I usually like but I think that is because it was under the heating lamp for a while. A pretty good dish that is filling but light. Glad I tried it. Will definitely be back to try their Rotisserie Chicken and other items on the menu.

Had a very nice southwest chicken salad and a black and white cookie at this deli! Very affordable lunch considering the prices elsewhere. Chicken salad was a bit basic; could have used some onions or celery for crunch. Would happily come back here as they have a big selection and it all seems quality.

Friendly service, there is a bathroom, extensive menu. Seats on the inside and outside.

Great place. This was my family's breakfast spot last Spring for a week. Quick, delicious eggs, toast, potatoes, and coffee. The cashier lady is friendly, and the cook is attentive and tries to make exactly what you want customized-style. I noticed they looked good for lunch too with soups, salads, and sandwiches. We weren't going to break the bank for eggs and bread so this was perfect.

ordered a hamburger via uber eats the hamburger was overcooked, cheeps not tasty last time order from that place!

6/10/24, Had lunch here today with our god daughter and I highly recommend eating there!!! They had fresh, great sandwiches and I would definitely go back!! If you're near Central Park and need a great place for lunch, GO THERE!!

Food is AMAZING! Cheeseburgers, turkey burgers, fries were perfect. BUT THE PANCAKES ARE THE BEST!! The place is a little small and busy, but they really keep thinks moving. Super nice staff who wants your experience to be the best. We came once just walking in, than made sure to come again later in our trip. I just wish they had Splenda for my coffee. They only had equal.

I love going into this place for just a coffee and bagel or sandwich! Their food is VERY good, and the prices are amazing! You can get an "everything bagel with veg cream cheese for $3.25. Additionally, the employees (as well as the owner!) are very friendly. You can eat inside or, in good weather, at tables outside the eatery.

Went in there because of the bad storm today, I work near by. Asked for a hot toasted Sandwich. Toasted roll with melted mozzarella Cheese with fried bacon and ham. (plain monte Christo with melted Mozzarella cheese . Instead, the roll was on toasted only on the outside. and the ham cheese was microwaved to melt. had them do it twice. Basically, I Paid 13 dollars for a rubber Sandwitch. The Correct way. Put roll with the cheese on top of the bread in a toaster oven till cooked. then fry ham and bacon on the grill. then add between the melted grill cheese. It is not rocket science.

Fresh, average priced, variety. Carrot, ginger soup to die for. Fresh real guacamole on paninis Nice servers! Clean bathroom 5 stars for sure

I received a gift card valid for 90 days for this Eatery at 261 Columbus Avenue. It was dated July. I went there is August, but the place refused to accept it. The response was: "We discontinued it".