All’Antico Vinaio

Visited this place for the first time and tried the La Broadway. It was filled with pistachio cream, stracciatella, and a few other delicious things - it was love at first bite. Gosh… everything tasted incredibly fresh, and the outer crunch paired perfectly with the soft, creamy filling. I ended up eating the whole sandwich without even realizing. The staff were also incredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Love, love, and only love! *Please consider opening a store in Chicago — we need this kind of magic here!*

One of the best sandwiches I’ve had and hit the right spot! Coffee could have been warmer and better though. Had the Diavola with salami, spicy Njuda, aged provolone, spiced zucchini and arugula. Twas beautiful!

Great place to eat. The servers were very friendly, and the menu was clearly labeled with green leaves for vegetarian sandwiches. Our food was made carefully and quickly, and we sat down to eat less than 15 minutes after ordering. Their peach tea was very good and cheap. We ordered the Fade Away and the Broadway, both of which were amazing. The flavors in the Broadway didn't agree with me though, but that's just personal preference. Overall amazing place to get an authentic Italian sandwich!

Absolutely worth the visit. The atmosphere balances professional with personal. The workers' efficient handling of our needs impressed. The entire group was happy with their food. This spot creates memorable differences!

Fast, friendly service and both sandwiches we ordered, Paradiso and Diavola, took us back to the first time we had All’antico Vianio in Florence. So good, though, the bread was more enjoyable here in NY. Highly recommended!

Always wanted to try this place. I gotta try all the other sandwiches but I got the special for 18 and it was delicious. It's hard to finish it all in one sitting but it was so worth it. No long line and the staff was very sweet and let me try a sample of the sandwich I order. Definitely will come here again for lunch❤️. Also recommended getting the limonata soda, SO GOOD!

Ordered my lunch on UberEats only to arrive at the designated pick up time and have to wait an extra 20 minutes in store. Halfway through my sandwich I found two hairs which I’m sure belong to the employee with long hair and no hair net.

A newly opened spot near Bryant Park, I decided to stop by for lunch and tried the ‘Venice Beach,’ a sandwich with turkey, mozzarella, and tomato. Despite being an authentic Italian eatery straight from Italy, the sandwich fell short of expectations. The bread was the highlight, but the turkey lacked flavor, and the tomato was unimpressive. Given the price, I anticipated a more flavorful combination.