AMALFI Rooftop by Birreria

On a recent trip to New York City we decided to eat at Amalfi. What a wonderful experience and great food and wine. We especially loved our waitress Natalie. Thank you Natalie for your warm wonderful conversation and your attentiveness to our visit. You made us feel right at home and can't wait to visit you guys again. Happy holidays!

The folks at Eataly have created a unique and interesting greenhouse space on their roof that functions as a restaurant, called Amalfi and its current iteration. There are some lovely fake trees with lemons that decorate the space and create a welcoming vibe. Unfortunately, we felt that the prices were very high for what you get, which was mid quality pasta, and small portions. Drinks are fully priced, appetizers are fully priced and while the spaces unique, you are not getting any spectacular views. We had a small group of five people, and we each had one drink, it ended up costing us $75 per person with three shared appetizers among the table. I had low expectations going in, and those expectations were met.

Had gone for brunch for a birthday celebration. Appetizer and main course were mediocre, but dessert was absolutely delicious. The menu was very selective, so the choices were limited. The ambience was lively. The staff was sloppy with terrible service. Not worth the money. There is better food else where in NYC.

Went for a friend’s birthday celebration. I got a drink and a whole branzino. Both food and drink were nice. The pricing was a bit steep. The service was nice. Location was great. Overall a nice experience.

My wife and I enjoyed lunch here based upon a recommendation from our niece who lives in NYC. The atmosphere of this secret garden was a peaceful break from the city streets. Our server Cristiano (from Milan) did an excellent job recommending delicious pasta dishes and wines for us. The perfect ending to our lunch date was “the best tiramisu in the country.” It was definitely the best we had ever eaten. Thanks Cristiano!

Very charming atmosphere like dining in a garden but its actually indoor greenhouse space. Food is kinda tasty but its a little steep for the portions. Probably its just a one time experiences only. Great for group tho.

We had the best time and the best food! Cristiano was so kind to my parents (who also happen to be from Italy) and they enjoyed speaking to each other!! Thank you for everything!!!! We can’t wait to come back!

Quite literally the best tiramisu anyone at our table has ever had! And the strawberry sorbetto they gifted me for my birthday was also incredible! Loved my butternut squash ravioloi and we had an amazing server. Great place to share a meal with family or friends.