Amara Cay Resort

Hotel · Islamorada, Village of Islands

Amara Cay Resort

Hotel · Islamorada, Village of Islands

80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036

Highlights

Tropical oceanfront resort with a private beach & heated pool, plus a rum bar and a restaurant. This upscale oceanfront resort is 2 miles from Indian Key Historic State Park, and 5 miles from aquatic shows at the Theater of the Sea marine park. The chic, island-themed rooms feature Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and coffeemakers; many have balconies with ocean views. Suites add sitting areas and kitchenettes. There's an Italian restaurant, and a poolside rum bar serves lunch and dinner. The private beach has hammocks and loungers, and the heated outdoor pool overlooks the ocean. A resort fee covers Wi-Fi, parking and a shuttle service.

80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036 Get directions

islamoradaresortcollection.com

@cntraveler

"Why did this hotel catch your attention? What's the vibe?The chic Amara Cay Resort oozes laidback luxury. Its lobby—with windows overlooking the beach and pool—immediately captures your attention. What's the backstory?Amara Cay is a member of the Islamorada Resort Company, a boutique resort collection that also includes the Postcard Inn, La Siesta, and Pelican Cove. Tell us all about the accommodations. What can we expect from our rooms?The rooms have an updated tropical look and feel, with rope and rattan furnishings, plants, earth tones, and pops of turquoise or green. Is there a charge for Wi-Fi?The Wi-Fi's included in the $35 daily resort fee. Drinking and dining—what are we looking at?The Dining Room serves breakfast, while Reelburger’s Tiki Bar serves lunch, dinner, and evening cocktails outside by the pool. Otherwise, venture off property to a wide variety of restaurants. How's the service?Friendly and competent. What type of travelers will you find here?Couples and families with college-age kids. What about the neighborhood? Does the hotel fit in, make itself part of the scene?The resort is right in the heart of Islamorada, making it especially convenient to dine, shop, and plan activities off property. The resort also has a Mercedes shuttle van within a four-mile radius, so you can have an extra sunset cocktail without worrying about the drive home. Is there anything you'd change?There's limited dining onsite, but there's lots nearby. Any other hotel features worth noting?Other than a nice beach and sexy-but-small pool, the resort has limited amenities (there's no spa, for instance). Snorkeling or fishing trips (Islamorada is the sportfishing capital of the world) also happen off property. There are, however, kayaks, paddle boards, and a fitness center rounding out the offerings at the resort. What's the bottom line?This resort delivers high style without any pretension." - Nancy DePalma

Amara Cay Resort

View Postcard for Amara Cay Resort

Lollie100

Google

The hotel is in a great location; the views are incredible and the grounds immaculate. The room is spacious, and the bed was comfortable. We had one meal at the hotel, and it was average but not unexpected at a hotel restaurant. Service at the bar and restaurant was great. We checked in on Monday and everything was going well until I asked for housekeeping on Wednesday about 9:30am. I was told by Christina via text that we weren't eligible for housekeeping since it was a 4-night stay. At this point, we were out of coffee, the bins were running over and we were using Kleenex as TP. I went to the lobby in search of coffee and the front desk staff said she could put me on the list for a "reset" of the room and not a full service. Perfect, I thought...We went on with our day returning to the room a few times and still no TP and tons of garbage. Finally, around 6pm we ran out of the Kleenex we were using as TP. I reached back out and someone brought us a single roll of toilet paper, and a plastic bag with 4 towels in it. We never received anything else. We ended up ordering room service coffee, and the garbage was piled up in a corner when we left. This was unexpected for the price point and certainly not the level of service expected from a resort property. We spent the last 3 days at the Cheeca resort and had daily housekeeping. This property has loads of potential but not even close to being a resort style property with the current "Motel 6" housekeeping policies.

Wilson Nariño Tapias

Google

Perfect Anniversary Stay! We stayed for one night on the fifth floor in an ocean view room to celebrate our anniversary, and it was truly unforgettable. The view was absolutely stunning, and the overall environment of the hotel was relaxing and beautiful. What really made our stay special was the thoughtful gesture from the manager, who surprised us with a bottle of champagne to help us celebrate – such a classy touch! The front desk staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming, making check-in smooth and pleasant. From start to finish, everything felt personal and warm. Highly recommend this hotel. We’ll definitely be back!

483amberlyl

Google

Everything was wonderful and better than we anticipated! But the best part was the cabana we rented for a day and Todd! He was assigned to us for the day and let me tell you...He is amazing!! So incredibly attentive, friendly and just simply awesome! From the moment he introduced himself it was like we were spending the day at a good friends house! He 100% made the day perfect, completly stress free and relaxing! Thank you Todd!!

Matt Hosford

Google

Our family had a great time at the Amara Cay resort. As many have posted, the resort itself is well kept and the staff does an amazing job. Having a dock, with a water shuttle along with paddle boards and kayaks is a great touch. My morning coffee out by the water was just perfect. We are certainly coming back.

John Gatt

Google

1st time staying at Amara Cay. As a Marriot Titanium level member, I was pleased with the level of service we received, and how nice the hotel was. During check-in, the hotel provides guests a re-usable water bottle instead of plastic bottles of water. Rooms are spacious and clean. Lots of included amenities and activities that you would need to pay extra for at a large name brand hotel or resort (Paddle boards, Kayaks, boat taxi, fishing poles, bicycles, etc.). I liked the wristband room key over having to carry around a key card. There are some nice restaurants with great food nearby overlooking the water. The Sea Lion and Dolphin show at The Theater of the Sea is a short drive away and nice for families. The pool is nice to hang out at and have drinks. Overall, our stay was great. I would definitely go again if I am planning a trip to the Florida Keys.

davidPtrav

Google

Experienced great service here from all the team with Todd being particularly helpful today. Enjoying our stay - well positioned for trips out up and down the Keys. Resort doesn't have a natural beach, but it's easy enough to drive to one. Restaurant here is good,but again, lots of interesting options to explore elsewhere, too.

Nichola Baye

Google

I’ve been coming to Amara Cay with my man for years. This time around, I had the pleasure of meeting Brittany at the front desk. She is one of the sweetest people. She gave us champagne for our anniversary with a handwritten card, and so many other accommodations to make us feel special and relaxed. Amara Cay is lucky to have her. She is a rare gem of a person.

Diana Dziuba-Wielga

Google

Service was good, but it looks like they could use more help. Todd by the pool was exceptional and was very attentive. Always smiling! Marcus, the bartender in the lobby bar was amazing! Funny and charming...and made awesome drinks! Rooms were clean and updated! Wish we could stay longer. Happy hour was great. Could use music by Isabella Stefania! Would fit perfectly into the tropical vibe!