Mike S.
Yelp
Was looking for a spot to have a cocktail or two and a light meal before a show at the nearby Gramercy Theater. Searched for a happy hour and came up with this place.
Upon walking in there is no host stand so I presumed you just seat yourself either at the bar or at the high tops all around the place. Regular tables are in the back, but they all were empty so we grabbed a high top table. Not sure about their drinks so we looked around for a menu and the bartender noticed so he handed us two right around the time a server brought us menus. She jokes that hers had better prices, but we should go with what we want. Cool, funny... digging the place so far.
Tried the Paloma and Dark and Stormy off the HH menu which knocks a few bucks off the usual price. D&S was well made with a great ginger kick, but my Paloma tasted a bit flat and sweet, still drinkable.
For food went with the cheese plate and the fish taco. Somehow we ordered Shishito peppers by mistake (perhaps because it was a bit loud inside and Paloma sounds like peppers when you read lips?), but it was a good one because they went well with what we ordered. Didn't try the cheese plate, but it looked like a good selection. Fish tacos were decent, but the shells were a little dry. I liked the pineapple salsa which had a bit of heat with this.
Service was efficient and quick. You could see our server was rushing around the place, but still took a moment to fill our water glasses from the bottle on our table. A bit too quick though when taking the bill when I left a credit card and $20 for a tip. For some reason the server deducted the $20 from the bill and put the rest on the card. Good thing I noticed and asked because she almost missed out on the tip due to the misunderstanding.
A good spot with a large selection of cocktails, good service with menu & decor that seems very on trend. A solid 3.5 stars due to food issues and stumbles, but upped it to 4 because I do like the trend.