Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street

Jesse took my order over phone and remembered me when I got there for curbside! Excellent customer service and provided extra cheese and peppers without asking. First time trying pizza and it was fire. I would highly recommend this place. We got the half and half, half Peppa pig and half meatball and fried jalapenos. Pizza slices are huge, quality ingredients and excellent taste. We also got their homemade ranch and it's great, you can taste the fresh dill.

UPDATED review After sharing my initial feedback expressing disappointment with my recent dining experience, I was pleasantly surprised to be contacted by the restaurant’s management team. I truly appreciated their prompt response and willingness to engage. The team invited me to visit again, and this time I had the opportunity to choose the location. What stood out to me the most was the genuine effort they made to listen to customer feedback and identify areas for improvement. This kind of responsiveness is exactly what customers look for, as it shows a commitment to ensuring a better experience in the future. Ultimately, this thoughtful approach reinforced the importance of customer satisfaction. ——/////—- FIRST REVIEW I've given this place multiple chances, visiting four times, but each experience has left me disappointed. While many people rave about the pizza here, I just don’t understand the hype. One issue is the excessive amount of salt in the dough, which overpowers the rest of the flavors. Additionally, the pizza often arrives undercooked or soggy, making it hard to enjoy. The combination of too many toppings and heavy seasoning masks the taste of the actual pizza itself, leaving it feeling more like a mix of ingredients rather than a balanced, flavorful dish. Having tried several other local spots, I’ve found a few that do pizza much better, with more attention to balance and quality. I hope this place can refine its approach, but for now, I can’t recommend it.

The garlic knots was fresh and delicious with warm marinara sauce. We did a half and half pizza pepper pig and pepperoni jam fest. Each was equally delicious and fresh! The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable about the food. Our order was running behind so the manager came over to apologize and say our food was coming in just a few more minutes. Great pizza place.

Talk about a great vibe! The music is fun and eclectic. The place was warm and wel owing, and our waiter was funny and helpful. We lived the bruchetta, which was a new take on a classic. The pizza was excellent and we appreciated the writer's suggestions!

Excellent! I recommend the Garlic Knots and the DeMarco of Brooklyn. It was busy when we went. If you go and it's busy, don't let that stop you. We were estimated a 45-minute wait time but only ended up waiting 20 minutes. Well worth the wait! I'll also note that they have a texting feature so you can hang out at a store or two next door while you wait, and they'll text when your table is ready.

My girlfriend and I are always looking for new places to eat or travel. We decided to drive to Tulsa for a change of scenery and to try new place for lunch. Andolini’s was a suggested destination for a good pizza. We ordered the pizza genco(vegan) of course we added the fresh mozz that we were told it was made in-house. I’ve worked in this industry too long when you can say,” how can someone mess up a pizza with the simple ingredients it takes to make pizza dough.?” Well it is possible. Our pizza was not what we expected! The pizza dough was wet and when I was trying to pick it up, it completely came apart. A good pizza does not have to be over prepped( too many heavy toppings). Less is more. The eggplant was very tough and dry. I liked that it had a heavy hand of basil but couldn’t catch a bite of basil flavor. I grow all my own herbs to use so the flavor profile was definitely absent. The best part of the pizza was the crust which I enjoyed with the marinara sauce which at tasting it you can taste it had a can flavor. $2 for a 4oz side of ranch and the same for marinara. A bit over priced. The Arancini was good but small. Which at $12 definitely not worth the price. One good thing we did have was very detailed service and Kaylee B. Went above and beyond. Thank you Kaylee. We will unfortunately not be returning we paid $49+ for one 14” pizza, one Dr. pepper and an appetizer arancini. We don’t care about prices, but this was one time just saying the money was definitely not worth the food. Still tipped decent because it was not the servers fault. We will be sticking to Dado’s in OKC.

Picked this up to go tonight and it's ridiculously good. Service is always amazing here as well. The staff is fun and they enjoy getting to know the customers.

Wonderful place wonderful food! Angie was an amazing server and made us feel right at home; cute, friendly, and had us laughing! Thanks for such a good experience! Will definitely save this place. TRY THE CHICKEN PARM‼️‼️‼️🫶👌🤘🤤

Always the Best Pizza! Order all Company lunch meetings and training events. It is the Pizza that is quoted "You got the good pizza!"

Gave this another try and everything was just perfect. Service and pizza were fast, the meatball app was as good as ever. This is possiblity one of my favorite pizza joints of all time. The crust is so soft and chewy. Just wish they had some honey for them! The hot honey tastes more like a garlic sauce to me and isn't spicy, the kids liked it best. But the house ranch is absolutely amazing and a good runner up to honey for crusts. Also there is a spot for pizza pickups so don't worry about parking for to-go orders. This is a top pick for me in all of Tulsa.

There are many places to get pizza in Tulsa and I do have a few favorites. Andolini's is sometimes my favorite but not always. In other words sometimes their pizzas really hit the mark for me and other times miss the mark. This past Monday night they really hit the mark. The special that night was buy one pizza get a second pizza at half price. You have to mention that to the server when you order or you won't get the deal. We ordered the Demarco of Brooklyn with San Marzano tomatoes, house made fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, Pecorino Romano and first pressing extra virgin olive oil. The crust was thin and slightly charred around the edges. In other words it was perfect. The second pizza was the Triple Pepperoni Jamfest with cup and char pepperoni, hot honey, deli pepperoni, pepperoni jam and julienned basil. So delicious and again with that wonderful thin crust. Can't say enough positive things about how delicious both pizzas were.

We were in a bit of a rush and they were slammed! That being said they were extremely helpful, and prompt with our order in spite of the whole staff being in the weeds. The bar tender was kind, attentive and working at breakneck speed. She even took the time to ask why we were visiting even though she was obviously very busy. We were extremely impressed. Not to mention, the gluten free crust is some of the best I've ever had and the salad and pizza toppings were excellent as well. 10/10 experience. I wish they had this restaurant where I live, definitely worth a visit. I will be coming here every time I'm in Tulsa. What a treat!!

I order the Demarco of Brooklyn pizza and it is delicious, it was so good I forgot to take a picture before I devoured it. This has become one of my favorite . I also got the Greek salad and that was not that great. The lettuce felt kind of old and it was a bit brown also had only like 3 tomatoes. The other issue is the parking, they have a very small parking lot in the back of the restaurant and is always full specially during the most busy times. Is hard to find a spot open. This is why I don't dine in.

Treated ourselves to Friday Night Pizza! New to the Tulsa area and wanted something tasty to enjoy at home. This was by far one of the best pizzas we've had in a very long time. We ordered a 20" Triple Pepperoni Jamfest - (cup and char pepperoni, hot honey, deli pepperoni, pepperoni jam, julienned basil) Sauce, taste and flavor was excellent! Ordered online and did curb pick up. Attendant was attentive, professional and friendly. Quick and easy process. Beautiful nice easy to find building. We will definitely be going back to try other options.

Here visiting from California for a tournament. We came on Sunday afternoon for a late lunch. The place wasn't busy at all. We were seated right away. Host was friendly and welcoming. I love the rustic feel of the restaurant. It's more bar setting with a layback vibe. For drinks I ordered a bloody mary and it was great, but I wish it was a big stronger. Food we ordered half combo and half athenian on our pizza. Pizza was delicious and ingredients were fresh. Overall we enjoyed our food and the staffs were all great! Our waitress was delightful and she took great care of us.

Great service, our server was really friendly and honest with her recommendations, food was really good, my blackberry mint julep was amazing! Very laid back ambiance, I like it! Will definitely come back before we leave Tulsa.

I was looking for a way to order pizza before the football playoffs this afternoon when I thought all of the restaurants might be busy with carry out and just happen to call Angelini's and find out that they have "taken and bake" the pizzas are beautiful and I will have them hot and ready for Halftime when the game is on this afternoon. The food was available immediately when I got there and everyone was nice and friendly, and gave me a sheet of instructions since I tend to be a little bit impaired in the kitchen.

The service is always fantastic . They have good pizzas and salads . The food is a bit pricy . Recommend .

Andolini's never fails to provide the freshest, hottest delicious dishes. I've never ordered anything that wasn't fantastic, no matter which location. My favorite location though is the Cherry Street location. Walking distance and always friendly servers. I love the quint feel and the bar tops are nice to sit and enjoy the lunch specials. 5 stars hands down

If you want the closest to a NY pizza slice, go here. It hits the spot and never misses.

Fantastic! Best pizza ever! We're from Oklahoma, but learned about this place while doing a Maine trip. We found a pizza place called Zeppa's in Ellsworth, ME and the proprietor said Mike was responsible for his pizza recipe! Road trip! We went to the beautiful flagship Cherry Street location and were there during lunch. We indulged in the all you can eat special. What a deal! Outstanding pizza, from the simple to the complex! Stop by if you are in the Tulsa area or make the trip! Well worth it

Andolini's is my favorite pizza joint in Tulsa! The atmosphere is fantastic, the food (everything I've ever had) is amazing, and the vibe is easy going, lively and classically reminiscent of an old pub. The servers are attentive and pleasant, the staff is always moving fast. My favorites are the Mozzarella Slices, Arancini and the Combination Pizza. They've got an amazing beverage selection as well. 20+ Beers on Tap 30+ Beers in bottle/cans Lots of Wine and Cocktails Check them out as soon as you can!

If you're in the mood for fresh and leveled-up pizza, this is your place. We came in for lunch, and while it was not empty inside, there was room for us to be seated quickly. Our server quickly got us menus and took drink orders. We ordered mozzarella slices and arancini. My word. What a delightful and crispy treat. The arancini is cheesy and has a lovely hint of basil, and the mozzarella was perfectly seasoned and fried crispy. We ordered the combination pizza, and we got a big one so we can have leftovers later. In my experience, Andolini's is the best fresh in- restaurant. Take out is also very good, but there's something about it coming right out of the oven that boosts the experience. The price is higher than your other chain pizza places, but it deserves to be. I highly recommend it.

My wife and I are not from Tulsa but were visiting family. Friday arrived and our granddaughters insisted that Friday is ALWAYS pizza night so the search began. I had some credits on door dash and find that Andolinis participated in that. We ordered a couple of pizzas and a salad. The pizza, in my opinion, was awesome. Their dough was referred to as a Roman Dough recipe that apparently takes 5 days to prepare. I don't typically eat the outside crust of most pizza but the dough used here was off such quality that I couldn't resist it. There was some leftovers which served as a breakfast appetizer for me if you know what I mean Price-wise it was a little on the high side for pizza but that won't keep me away the next time we visit. Worth it!

Food was fantastic and the service was just as good. Really enjoyed everything.. I highly recommend eating here. We got a wonderful salad with a mango vinaigrette dressing. It was fantastic. We did a half-and-half combination and barbecue chicken pizza. Both were excellent, I'll be at a bit filling.

excellent service, wonderful food and the location is cozy! I enjoy their lunch special where you pick two : pizza, pasta, salad. the mango vinaigrette dressing and the signature salad is the best.

I was so intrigued by the Roman dough that takes five days to prepare that I made my friends stray from their typical order of the DeMarco! I thought it was really good, but they are standing by the DeMarco as the better pizza so I'll have to return and try that. The Roman marg pizza had tomatoes and the olive oil drizzle and it was similar to a Detroit style thick crust. It was almost focaccia like! We also shared some garlic knots. I got a side of marinara but really didn't need anything besides the garlic butter it's swimming in! Will definitely be back next time I'm in Tulsa.

The best service I've had in quite a while. Great environment, and the food was absolutely delicious. I can see why this is place has such good reviews.

On the last leg of our 12 hour road trip yesterday, we stopped in Tulsa. I was not privy to the pizza scene here, but Andolini's was highly recommended by a colleague of my Husbands. I'm so glad we made time to stop! We ordered a 14" Demarco with olives and peppers on half. I was pleasantly surprised at the size- I always regret ordering too much or too little, but thanks to the helpful reviews I was able to gauge what we needed nicely. Typically I wouldn't care, but the size of the box mattered on this road trip! The pizza was cooked nicely, the flavors just right. Toppings plentiful and fresh. Just the right amount of everything! A lot of people will mention the price, so I will add to that. With additional toppings and tip ours was about $35 for a 14". Pricier than a chain of course, but a very good price for a delicious meal. I think people have the idea that a pizza should just be a quick and inexpensive solution for dinner. Sure, that exists at some places but those days are pretty much over. Pizza has become very elevated and I encourage anyone, regardless of price to try it! We pay $100 for a nice meal, what's so bad about $50 for an amazing pizza?!

Great atmosphere! Low lighting and well set tables. Low how you can see them making the pizzas. Wife and I visited for our anniversary dinner and didn't regret anything. The service was extremely friendly and fast. Riley went way above and beyond with everything for us! Our only thought was about the lighting between the kitchen and the diner. It would be awesome to have a blind between the fluorescent lights and the lights over the table. Otherwise, 10/10 experience. We will definitely be visiting again!

We stopped by here because of all of the good review. Got the popular pizza which was Demarco of Brooklyn. It was pretty good but honestly nothing too special about it. Caprese antipasto was really good though. Super light and delicious. Our server was AMAZING. She was super attentive and always checked up on us. We had a great experience overall. Can't complain.

for somebody who is obsessed with Brooklyn style, Pizza and considers it the best, this Tulsa pizzeria does it very well,! And has been doing so for so long! Definitely a must stop for foodies going through Tulsa! We also loved the fried cheese, but the best iconic Brooklyn style pizza with our little twist of adding crispy pepperoni...

The food here is good, but the woman working the register Becky, always has a bad attitude. I frequent this location as both a door dash delivery person and a customer - most of my issues come when I am working door dash. If I ask about sauce, she snaps it is already in the box. If I ask for napkins, it's a huff and puff "in a minute if I have one". I am disabled, and on a few occasions have asked if she could bring the door dash order to my car. She rudely informs me I have to come inside to pick it up, I understand if this is policy... But is it that difficult to explain nicely? A little empathy goes a long way. She is nicer when I come in to pick up food for my family, probably because she expects a tip. Wishing you would do better Andolini's. The manager Tyler is less than helpful.

The pizza here is amazing, I even chose them to cater my wedding. This place never disappoints and Ashley is sooooo amazing, she always goes over and beyond for the customers.

They have an extensive menu with lots of specialty pizza options including keto or gluten-free pizzas! Of course, you can always create your own and pick your toppings too. We enjoyed their most famous pizza, Demarco of Brooklyn. This delicious monster of a pizza is a 20-inch crust that has a tomato sauce base, and it's topped with housemade fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino romano, and EVOO. It is truly amazing and you can tell all of the ingredients are incredibly fresh! We also shared a white pizza, which comes in a few sizes, and we got the 14". It was garlicky, cheesy, and a perfect combo of flavors! To give you an idea of portion sizes, these TWO pizzas (and two caesar salads) were shared between 4 adults and 1 toddler, and we still had leftovers! The leftover pizza slices were great cold or heated up too, which is a huge bonus point in my book! This is a great spot, in a great location. I would definitely make a reservation even if you're going at an "off" time, just to be safe. It's sure to fill up quickly so people can get their favorite pizza fix!

Here visiting from California for a tournament. We came on Sunday afternoon for a late lunch. The place wasn't busy at all. We were seated right away. Host was friendly and welcoming. I love the rustic feel of the restaurant. It's more bar setting with a layback vibe. For drinks I ordered a bloody mary and it was great, but I wish it was a big stronger. Food we ordered half combo and half athenian on our pizza. Pizza was delicious and ingredients were fresh. Overall we enjoyed our food and the staffs were all great! Our waitress was delightful and she took great care of us.

Lots of buzz about this pizza place and heard they have a lunch special in which it's all you can eat for $12! This lunch special runs 11-3pm M-F. You can pick two from their salad, pizza and pasta options. I first tried the pepperoni with a Caesar salad. Both were just okay, the pepperoni crust lacked some seasoning and the Caesar salad was a bit wilted. The shining star was the de Marco slice which cost ($1) for every slice you have during the lunch special. Highly recommend this pizza, it was unique and flavorful. Love the drizzle of olive oil and basil on top! Overall a decent deal but beware if you have more than two slices they definitely start pushing you to pay and leave lol

We ordered takeout on Father's Day and as always the pizzas were delicious. Today we had the Del Marco and the BBQ Chicken Pizza. Both were exquisite.

Nicely and quickly, food tastes awesome, decorated beautifully for the holidays. Food was nicely done, service was easy and kind. Christmas decorations make the place really in the spirit. Love the signature salad, would recommend to anyone whose going to Andolinis anytime soon. The pick up services gave no hassles nor wait time.

After a night out sightseeing and drinking with my colleagues, we were craving pizza and decided to check this place out. This is a cute neighborhood pizza shop on Cherry Street in Tulsa, OK. What I noticed first besides the cute little pizza shop was the street that it resides on. Cute Midwestern type homes, most having porches with swings. Very quiet and quaint street. After eating we decided to take a walk down the street to check things out. It brought back memories for one of my coworkers of his hometown in Jersey where he grew up (added bonus). It seems like a fairly active area for restaurants and bars but still quiet enough to relax and enjoy. The pizza shop is really cute with that authentic pizzeria look & feel. We ordered ahead of time to pick up but once we got there we decided to sit and enjoy our pizza there. So glad we did. We ordered a large supreme pizza to share and we killed it. Very good pizza. We really enjoyed the whole experience, ambiance, service and surrounding area.

Fantastic pizza with lots of GF options. Great ambience. Great area. Highly Recommend

Absolutely the best pepperoni and sausage pizza you can buy in Tulsa. The pineapple Canadian bacon was just loaded with pineapple. It was an epic pizza party

Wow. We love. This pizza was amazing, really great crust, thin, soft, and airy. Huge zzaaa, only comes in 20" but also great the second day so you know it's a good one. Visiting from the west coast so wasn't expecting to find such awesome zzaaa on a random Tuesday night but we highly recommend.

Another perfect dinner on Andolini's patio. We tried the new Pizza Rustica dish and it was quite delicious. The ricotta in the crust was wonderful! Filled generously with sausage, cheese, and prosciutto, this is a satisfying dish and a fun alternative to "regular" pizza. I think adding some more vegetables like roasted red peppers would be a great addition and add some freshness to the dish. The strawberry lemonade was perfectly refreshing for a warm evening. And the caprese antipasto is just one of my favorite dishes, period. I can't get enough of the marinated mushrooms, the roasted red peppers, and the mozzarella. The balsamic is divine, and no trip to Andolini's is complete without this! Staff was friendly and attentive. The general manager was particularly attentive and took great care of us. Too bad we ate so much or we would have gone across the street to STG ;-)

I wasn't the happiest with this place. It could be the staff made our pizza wrong or we just didn't order the right item. We ordered the fried eggplant appetizer and the Andolini's signature salad. The eggplant was honestly cold so that was already not the best. The salad however was very good! The ingredients were fresh and the mango vinaigrette was tangy but sweet!! As for pizza, we got half marzano pesto pizza and half vegetarian with jalapeños. The marzano was very greasy. I kind of expected it as it was pesto based but it was really oily. The vegetarian was not good at all. There was barely any sauce! It was all just cheese. The pizza would have honestly been great if there was sauce. That's why I feel like the staff honestly made a mistake. Either way, the service was fantastic. They heard my complains and didn't charge us for the pizza! They gave us Demarco slices on the house as well and it was definitely better! There was definitely enough sauce on that one haha. My only recommendation is maybe hold off on the olive oil if you don't enjoy the grease! I'm usually okay with grease but it was just a little too much for me. Anyways, the service is what made this place good! I would definitely want to come back and give the pizza another shot. If you can get Angelica (I think that's her name) as your waiter, you will have a solid time!

Stopped in for a drink while in the area & had a GREAT experience! The vibe is chill, playlist was good, and drinks were even better. We appreciated the service provided by Corwin! He was friendly, funny, attentive, and made us feel welcome on our first visit here. Giving above and beyond service, while multitasking at the bar. The best bartender I've encountered since moving to Tulsa! While having a drink, we decided to share some pasta, just to get something in our tummy's after the drinks. The Chicken Alfredo entrée was delicious! Creamy, savory and satisfying.

Every bite I've had here has been good. Fantastic food with a great atmosphere. Pizza is amazing. Salads are fantastic. Garlic knots are the best I've ever had.

I been to this location several times now and keep coming back for the best pizza! They have such a great selection of different pizzas you wont find at a national chain. The ingredients are so fresh and good also. I have more pizzas here than i dare to count and have yet to have a bad one, even the plain cheese pizza is amazing! They also have a great selection of beers on tap, including Marshalls, that go great with pizza. The outdoor patio is also nice on a spring or summer day. The staff and bartenders are all so friendly here. It is true, its hard to find parking being on cherry street, but its worth the trouble for this pizza. Go check them out!

We got pizza delivered from here to the University of Tulsa after our volleyball match so I can't speak to the service or interior of the restaurant. I ordered the cinco de cuatro, which has pepperoni, Calabrian sausage, jalapeños and spicy honey. This was magical. Nice crispy undercarriage, good sauce to cheese ratio. The toppings were fresh and flavorful and the honey gave it the perfect kick of sweet/hot. Also, their ranch is FIRE. Some of the best ranch I've ever had

I'm a Chef and when it comes to Andolini's Pizza I get excited it has been absolutely fresh, tasty, and wonderful every single time I've gone over the past 3 years. I've been extremely satisfied with the overall experience. Please take the time to try there Combination Stromboli it will melt in your mouth. Also try out the strawberry salad with chicken it's scrumptious. They've definitely done it again as of tonight! I'm not sure if it's a good or bad thing but they've won a life long customer! I'm addicted!

Extensive and delicious menu, great service and nice atmosphere. Look forward to retuning.

The food and service is great. They accommodated my family when they ran out of a certain topping. Much appreciated!

There is not one Andolinis we have tried that we didn't like. Cherry St. and the BA location are tied for us. All these restaurants offer friendly service. The air playing sounds are awesome too. This is a very relaxing "meet your fam and friends joint." The Calabrese app is one of my favorites and a salad. I'm not picky with salad as long as it's enjoyable, with flavor. I did try the Lt. Aldo "The Apache" drank, it didn't disappoint either. The IPA lists are good too. It's always a good time when you can munch on a tasty pizza and wash it down with a chilled golden IPA. Good pizza. Great family time. Great music!!

Literally the best pizza ever. The employees are always so polite. Deffs a safe pick for a meal or snack.

Food was good. Service was fine after we sat for about 15 min waiting at the table because our server wasn't notified we were sat at her table. We were seated in the front by the kitchen, nothing special. Apparently the seating in the back is a little more of an Italian feel. The pizzas were good, but I cannot remember their names and they are not on their website. They were Neapolitan style pizzas. One had Chile flake, homemade sausage, and pistachio. Didn't care for the sausage texture (casing had the snap but the meat was paste when chewed). The other had prosciutto, basil, and parm. That one was the best out of the two. The salads were nothing to rave about. The Cesar was plain and dressing was not outstanding. The Satriale's salad was fine, but the balsamic dressing wasn't anything special. The mozzarella bites were also good. The gelato is also very good.

I visited Andolinis during my trip to Tulsa.Awesome Pizza. I ordered 3 pizzas and they were all amazing. The my were made very quickly and were incredibly delicious. The restaurant was packed and everyone seemed to be enjoying their food. I will be returning and would recommend that you do the same.

Great food! Love the garlic knots! Friendly, helpful employees! Cool atmosphere! I would recommend!