Andre's Pizza

Pretty sure my $10 side of sauteed broccoli was 1 cup of frozen broccoli they blanched for a second with some garlic. Left a lot to be desired in freshness and portion. Pizza was alright. Not going out of my way or stopping for this a second time. Small place and overpriced.

I heard great things about Andre’s and I was really craving stuffed shells so I called in an order without looking at a menu. I asked for a side of meatballs and a side of sausage. Each side was $9.99! I got 4 half dollar sized meatballs and two sausage cut in half for $20. I understand things are expensive these days but that is disgustingly greedy and if I had seen the cost prior to calling in I would have know to stay away.

I have to say I was pleasantly surprised when I received a small triangle shape portion of bread. It was fresh in fluffy’s, and Delicious. I ordered an entrée that came with a small house, salad and house dressing. I have to say it was probably the best dressing I have ever had in my dining experience. Multiple robust flavors and seasoning conjugating with my taste buds at the same time. The server Sabrina was very accommodating as I came somewhat late. During the last hour of service made me and my partner feel comfortable and welcoming, even though they were preparing to close. I have to say it’s been a while since I have frequented this restaurant and I will definitely be coming back in the near future and will be my new weekly stop. Thank you to Sabrina and the staff for making my Thursday night dinning experience very pleasant.

Stopped by around 1035. AM on Thursday April 17th, 2025 I really wanted a piece of pizza, but Mike who is the owner said the oven wasn't ready yet. So I said ok ill have a cheese steak, provolone cheese and steak. We talked awhile and I got the cheese steak and got in my car and started eating it. That was the BEST Cheese Steak I've had in a long time. Better than anything including Philadelphia. So get a delicious tasting cheese steak at Andres Restaurant in Nottingham, PA. Tell them Neil sent you. Thanks Mike, ill be back. I live in Lancaster nothing tasting like Andreas.

What a beautiful Italian restaurant owned and operated by true Italians from Napoli. From the greeting as you walk through the front door you instantly feel like part of the family. So many choices and specials to choose from. The food is exceptional as is the service and the great atmosphere. I stumbled upon this Gem, because I was trying to eat at a restaurant in town proper of Oxford but, I had a small trailer I was towing behind my car and there is NO parking anywhere in town without being towed! Andrés has plenty of free parking on both sides of the restaurant. There's also outside dining when weather permits. This will be my go-to place and even my go out of my way place to dine from now on.

Veal Parm was top notch. House dressing for salad was phenomenal. Garlic bread was so flavorful. The cheese they use means I'm coming back to try the pizza. Oh my, all the times I drove by this place and didn't stop to eat. Not anymore.

Thought this place was going to great because I saw some Liscio’s roll boxes outside. The place itself is nice. What you would expect of a pizza shop. The guy that took our order wasn’t nice. He seemed like he didn’t want to be bothered by us. I took some time to look over then menu and he was rolling his eyes and grunting. So I ordered and he barely spoke a word to us. So we stood there waiting to pay and he just looked at us and said “go sit”. The food came. The slices we ordered were good. Not anything to rant about. The sub looked like it was just thrown together. I took a bite and noticed a small hair on it. Thought it was my eye lash and took a further inspection. In the middle of the sun was this long black hair. I took it back and said something to the guy and he seemed like he didn’t believe me. It was me and another guy with short haircuts the only person in the building with long black hair was the unpleasant guy that took our order. Anyway they gave me another. It was okay. Still looked like it was just slopped together. If I ever come through here again I’m going to keep on driving right passed this place.

This is my second visit and so far they are batting 100. Mike crafted and boxed my pizza up with a smile, and even double checked it visually. How they fit that pizza in the box edge to edge like that is a magic trick. Got the Sicilian pizza with half mushrooms, pepperoni, spinach and olive. The dough was springy and vibrant and the pizza was delicious. My six year old son gave it the thumbs up of approval and they don't get any pickier than him. The chef salad was on point too with fresh meats and cheeses.

A lovely pizza stop that's quite close to me, but I've never gone to until just now! I ordered inside during dinner hours, and was served quite fast. The place is small, but the people are friendly, the food is wonderful and inexpensive, and I left the restaurant with a smile on my face. Sabrina did an amazing job making sure I always had a drink, and I was having a good time. Thank you, Sabrina! I had the meat lovers pizza, and finished as much as I could, took the rest home for the family! Charming atmosphere, great food and positive vibes. What more could you want for dinner? (Ps, they have lunch too! Check out their specials!)

Ordered takeout chopped antipasto salad, absolutely terrible $15! Order came in a small styrofoam box , minimal cheese and meats, won't be back

Great food, great service! Very friendly staff, authentic Italian style cooking. Great prices too.

Andres has become our go-to pizza joint and we've had most of the menu by now from the pizza to calzones to salad to pasta to cheesesteaks to grinders... it's all delicious. My personal favorites are all the Buffalo chicken items (I am a Buffalo chicken addict), the white Stromboli, meatball grinder, and the tiramisu. We don't eat in often and usually get delivery, but when we do eat in it's a casual environment with big portions.

Delicious Sicilian style SquarePan pizza, and the rest of the food is good and authentic as well

My family and I just tried this place for the first time. There's a lot of Pizza places we enjoy in this area and we've heard so many good things about Andres. We ordered a pepperoni and a plain cheese pizza. Both were good, but I think they're more greasy than other places around here. There was so much grease on the pepperoni pizza that it overpowered the flavor of the cheese, sauce, pepperoni, and crust. Speaking of the crust, it's a little over cooked for my liking and very tough to chew on. Overall, this place does have good pizza, but I've had better. I wouldn't mind coming back to try other items on their menu!

Best pizza in Oxford area! Love this place! Highly recommended we always get the pepperoni pizza or the cheese pizza.

I'd love to give them five stars because most of their food is excellent. However, if you try ordering online, you'll actually be ordering through Slice delivery. Slice is awful. This was my second attempt to get food delivered. Don't do it!! Slice just can't get drivers who know where they're going. By the time the food - that wasn't my order - was delivered to my door, my own order had been sitting at the restaurant for nearly an hour. I finally went to pick up my own order that included garlic knots. Maybe they're good when they're fresh but by the time I got them home they were inedible. Maybe someday I'll be able to taste Andre's garlic knots.

A staple of quality food have never been disappointed in the 30+ years of takeout or dine in. Service has always been amazing, and the atmosphere is classic ambiance of a mom and pop pizza place with much more to offer.

Can't beat the variety of options and every time we order we quite happy with the choice from a slice to mozz sticks to dinners

Food was great! Didn't get exactly as we ordered but it was still really good! Service was very fast. Ambiance of this little restaurant is very nice!

Just go! Our favorite Italian foods in a 50 mile radius. The pizza and pastas are delicious and some are unique to Andre's. Their bruschetta is the best I have had anywhere...crispy homemade toasty bread stacked high with juicy diced tomatoes, garlic, fresh basil, and a secret olive oil poured over it all. You will lick your plate. The owner Mike is kind and friendly and the entire staff works hard to make you want to return. There are two nice dining rooms that are comfortable and clean. Now I have made myself hungry!

Hands down, the best New York Style Pizza in town! I can't speak for anything else on the menu because I only order the Pizza.

This place doesn't look like much on the outside, but don't judge it too quickly. The food is outstanding. Pizza is the best in Oxford but don't sleep on their pasta dishes. And their garlic knots are incredible.

My family's favorite Oxford pizza spot! We usually get take out. I haven't tried much else but have heard their other options are great, as well.

This spot is serving meal kits as well as offering delivery during COVID. I'm so glad! Of course nothing beats the in-person experience when you go to pick up right now, but delivery is a great second option. I've been nothing but impressed with the service and the quality of food and their bread is amazing! I keep going back to try new things and haven't been disappointed yet! Cheers

We love Andres. Best pizza and Italian in Oxford. Service is always good and food is always amazing.

Best spot in the area for anything pizza related. This spot is above and beyond everything else in the immediate area. The pizza is light and crispy, the soup is unbelievable, and you need this food in your life.

If you enjoy New York City pizza, go to Andre's. Delicious pizza. Everything they make is great; soup, salad, sauces, etc. Their homemade salad dressing is so tasty, never had anything like it.

Talk to Mike .... Covered in flour, and a great guy from Naples. Cares about what he does, and is proud of his food. Here for 35 years? Yes, he has perfected his pizza! The pizza was great. Cheese, the best. Sauce, fresh and flavorful. Nice taste of the dough and crunch on the crust. Did I tell you he bakes and sells artisan style loaves of bread? WOW!

Ordered a sausage and pepper sub and what I got was a sub with peppers, onions and little thinly sliced sausage that they use as pizza toppings. Wow talk about missing the mark, you are supposed to use whole sausages in a sausage & pepper sub. What a joke, what a scam... stay away

Their white pizza is the freakin' best! Wings? Awesome. Looking forward to trying other menu items. The paint on the building was made to look like brick, which is glorious!!! Pretty neat! I can appreciate artistic talent, not only when it comes to food.

If you read my reviews, you know that I try to be consistent. For restaurants, I always compare chicken parmesan. Andre's does chicken parmesan right! I've been going here for a long time ( more than 10 years) and there is nothing I don't like on the menu. I must have had more than 10 chicken parmesan meals! This place is clean, the staff is friendly, the food is great. My only problem is that too many people will find out about this place !!

Recently relocated to the area and tried their pizza three times. In my case three times is not the charm three times is the trash. The first time I ordered a slice of cheese pizza and it was pretty good. The next time I ordered a medium pepperoni and it was meh...This time I ordered the same pepperoni and it is terrible. The pepperoni tastes like it came from a rendering plant as does the entire pie. The entire pis was nothing but oil with that rancid rendered fat taste. The ingredients this place uses have to be the cheapest available and the pies are not cheap. This was $14. and change for something that will go in the trash. There is no excuse for this other than they just don't care.

Was recommended by a friend. Moving to the area in a month, so we were thrilled to find this place. Their Sicilian Pizza is amazing. We've also had a pasta dish and Chicken Parm sandwiches... all excellent. Great menu. It will be our go-to spot when we move in. Also look forward to the dining rooms opening up when things clear up.

We go there quite often. Service is very friendly. Food is excellent. Try the pizza. WOW!! Added bonus, it's BYOB

Staff is great and very friendly. I brought my mom for her birthday in Feb and got soup and a cheesesteak pizza. It was so fresh and really good. The owner was very friendly and came over to see how everything was. He sent over a piece of their almond cake for dessert. They make the cake there and it was one of the best cakes I ever had. They are currently open for takeout only and looks like they are as busy as ever! Give it a try.

Was disappointed use to be a good place . Pizza was burnt dri and over priced . Would of took it back but didn't feel like driving it back . Won't return. Use to go there all the time .

Our favorite is a large pepperoni pizza with cannoli for dessert. Very tasty, cooked crisp. Just like northern NJ!

They are the best pizza around hands down! Oxford/Nottingham Pa. I've had Jersey and NY pizza and it's comparable!

Decent food. But among the rudest employees I've ever come across in a restaurant. I'd have given it more stars, but can't do it just because of the bad dining experience I had because of the employees. It might be worth it, if you order take out and can tolerate being insulted by the employees. As for me, I don't plan on ever ordering from there or eating there again.

Pizza and special cheese steak are ok but those are about the only things I have had there that I liked. The servers (one that I think is the owner) tend to not be welcoming and have been rude in the past. It is also not the cleanest place either. There are many other pizza joints in the area that I would probably choose first before going here. Customer service goes a long way for me and if I repeatedly get bad service from a place I will stop giving them my business.

On food alone, outstanding! The outside decor isn't up to date, but once I bit into the pie I didn't care where I was, it was one of the top 3 pizza experiences of my life!

Wow! Super impressed! I visit oxford every couple of weeks to shop at the Amish stores and have always eaten before going out. This time we went with family and just decided to grab something on the way. We saw Andres Pizza first and thought why not let's try it! The 3 men that were working that day Saturday November 9th were awesome genuine and kind people. They were so patient with my family and I and all the food was freshly made and tasted amazing! Thank you Andres Pizza!!

I moved 0.2 miles away from this location less than a year ago. Since then I've tried a few times. Upon rude/awkward mgmt, I have experienced overpriced & such poor quality that it was thrown out even after 10 beers. Shame on me for the second two times of trying. Don't waste your money. Order from Bravos.

Love Andre's Pizza, we have pizza every Sunday and always choose Andre's!! Great service and such friendly people!!! Been going there for years and will always!!

After trying all the pizza places in Oxford, this is my favorite. It tastes as good as the best pizza in SW Philadelphia or Delco - thick cheese, very tasty. Large sizes are LARGE, so you get your money's worth.

My family has always left LOVED it here. It's not your normal pizza chain it's much better the the dominos food and this will always be my favorite pizza parlor.

Both my teenage boys love their pizza, it's the best in the Oxford area. The staff is very friendly and takes pride in what they serve. We've been getting our pizza here for a few years now and have never been disappointed.

I don't usually do this but I want to let everyone know about the service or lack of service I received at Andres Pizza in Oxford, pa. I ordered a pizza on Friday 4/19/2019 at 5:39 pm. I was told it would be 45 min a little longer than I think it should be but was ok. With it. My husband left to pick it up. Another customer walked in just seconds before him. She said she ordered a large pepperoni pizza but didn't give them her order number. She walked out my husband told them we ordered a large pepperoni pizza and our order number. The young girl behind the counter informed him that they just gave away our pizza. They asked if we could wait another 45 minutes. They didn't offer anything else like maybe another pizza would be ready in a few minutes. My husband left and came home and told me. I called them back and asked to speak with owner or manager. I explained what had happened which they already knew. He told me that if a walk In customer comes in that instead of making them wait they give others peoples pizza"s out. They informed me that I can buy pizza elsewhere. I'm Very disappointed and I'm sharing my experience and will find another pizza place in Oxford not like we don't have any. Happy Easter!!

My family always comes here. The owner and the employees are always so nice! The owner knows exactly what we get every time, which is kinda cool! Their pizza is amazing! They building doesn't look like the fanciest place in the world, but it's not about the look, it's about the people running it and the food they create.

Odd. Third time we ate inside and they dont put the pepperoni on while it cooks, they've put them on after so you get raw roni. Pissed me off cause a latge and 2 sodas $22 Not happy like the first time

Andrea's pizza is perhaps the best pizza establishment in Oxford. The price is a little bit high, but the product is always a high-quality treat. Ande's uses the freshest ingredients. I've been a customer of theirs for over 20 years and I've never had a bad meal come out of there yet. I've tried their subs again very good and their wings are grea. Their Italian dinners are wonderful and a house salad dressing that is really good and he markets in himself highly recommend this spot to get dinner take-out pizza and for a great Italian I thetic mea Andres pizza is perhaps the best pizza establishment in Oxford the price is a little bit high but the product is always a high-quality in the freshest ingredients I've been a customer of theirs for over 20 years and I've never had a bad meal come out of there yet I've tried their subs again very good their wings are great and their Italian dinners are wonderful as a house salad dressing is really good and the markets in himself, Hghly recommend this spot to get dinner take-out pizza and for a great Authentic Italian meal.

I am staying in Nottingham for the week on business, Oxford is just a short drive so I got some pizza. Quality pie at a reasonable price, I will probably be back before weeks end.

They have the best Seafood Ravioli. My wife and love this place. We try to stop there once a week. The brothers are great to deal with.

Food is excellent! We go all the time and have never had a bad meal. The staff is nice and courteous. Prices are good for the amount of food you get. If you live in the area this is the only place to go to get pizza and other Italian cuisine.

My husband and I were Andre's regulars for the first 2 years we lived in Oxford. Out of no where their food and service went down hill. We haven't been there in years. Their pizza went from being really flavorful to tasteless and one night I ordered sausage and pepper sandwiches for my husband and his friends. They were cold and it wasnt a long sausage on the rolls...it was sausage wheels. His one friend counted only 4 tiny pieces the rest was peppers (canned...ew), onions, and mushrooms (canned). Pretty sure that was the last night we ordered from them.

Food ok, But business attitude terrible! After ordering a meal, from menu, and eating, the bill was delivered, by waitress. I noticed a higher price then listed on menu I questioned the waitress and she went back to check, with owner I suppose. She then apologized and pointed out that the priced had increased! I asked to speak to the owner, who came out and questioned my concern! He explained that the menu was printed in 2009, and was too expensive to replace! He went on and on about how good the food was there, and how the prices were good and I should understand why prices were increased, etc, etc. he ignored the fact that I was never informed about increased prices. He went on and on but agreed to refund the extra money. What a way to run a business! No one else was in the resturant , I wonder why! If you still decide to go there.....Check for NEW

Chef salad said $6 on the internet menu ended up being 8.54 and the salad was the worse I've had guess that's why there wasn't one person eating in there