Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

We have stayed at Andrews for many years. Why do we go back? Because it’s the best! Yes we have been other places but.. Andrews is tucked in a lovely spot. Behind Duval yet quiet and accessible. Isabelle and company make sure YOU are priority. Breakfasts are very good and you can enjoy coffee, water any time you wish. We have stayed in every room and prefer the Roma. It’s spacious and so clean. The pool is a nice size and has jets- nice to relax in. We always have an amazing time!

My husband and I stayed here for our honeymoon and loved it! The location is perfect and central to the island. You’re close to Hemingway house and many delicious restaurants, but it still feels like a private oasis when you enter. We had no issues with noise from Duval street. Happy hour in the afternoon was very pleasant, breakfast was always good, and our room was impeccable (we stayed in the Madrid room). I only have 2 complaints that are so minimal in my opinion, that it was not worth rating less than 5 stars. I wish that the coffee bar set out fresh creamer or flavored syrups rather than the little cups of shelf-stable creamer. Also, I wish that the staff hosed off the pool deck more often. There was often bird poop on the lounge chairs and pool deck. There are a lot of birds though so it’s understandable. Overall though, we loved our stay here and look forward to returning with family and friends!!

Our stay at Andrew's Inn & Garden Cottages in Key West was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we arrived, we were enveloped in a sense of calm and luxury. The inn has a beautiful, resort-like atmosphere - lush foliage, charming pathways, and peaceful surroundings that instantly make you feel like you've escaped to your own private paradise. Our room was cozy, spotlessly clean, and thoughtfully appointed with incredibly comfortable beds and soft high-quality linens. The bathroom was clean, refreshing and offering a stunning view of the Hemingway House that made our stay special. The amenities made our stay even more enjoyable with fresh continental breakfast and a delightful daily happy hour by the pool. The free bike rentals were a huge plus, allowing us to explore Key West with ease. The location is perfect - tucked away just enough from the hustle and bustle of the main street to feel peaceful and private. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, always checking in to make sure we were comfortable and had everything we needed. Andrew's Inn truly felt like a hidden gem. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a luxurious, intimate escape.

My wife and I stayed here with family and friends for our son's 21st birthday. We rented out every room and all of our guests had an amazing time. The location off Duval was perfect, the pools was refreshing, the rooms were clean, and the Breakfast and Happy Hour was amazing. The best part was the staff. Staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating. We have been coming to Key West for 23 years and have stayed in many different hotels but never a B&B. This was our first and was the nicest place we ever stayed. We will definitely book here again.

We just returned from a short trip to Key West. The weather was rainy but honestly this made for a very pleasant experience. The Inn had good accommodations with upgraded memory foam beds-very nice. The pool was the highlight-just the right temperature and a great welcome back after sight seeing. We were able to check in early and out late. We met some fellow guests during the happy hour and had enjoyable evenings chatting. Beautiful lush grounds and a convenient location to everything.

We originally found out about Andrews Inn on Reddit, from some locals and former guests. This Inn and the staff far exceeded our expectations. Located literally in the backyard of the Ernest Heminway home this beautiful property is a Key West dream. Imagine our surprise when we looked over our porch to see the tour, we were a part of, just over Heminway's hand laid brick wall. In fact, we were visited quite often by own friendly 6toe kitty from next door!|Our space was the Roma cottage. The room was pristine, well appointed, and absolutely cozy. A Nectar mattress nestled in a four-poster bed; nice cold ac and premium sheets made for a great post-Duval nap and the authentic Key West porch was the real Chef's kiss. The pool area was insane. When its 99 degrees and 80% humidity, this private lush tropical pool alone is worth every dime. We could hear all commotion from Duval and my wife commented several times how fantastic this lil garden heaven was to escape the madness. The best part is the small boutique feel of the Inn. You really feel like it could be your home with a few friends. Don't skip the full breakfast including charcuterie and 24 hr coffee. Bikes are included so you can just zip down to the Southernmost point (5 mins away) or Mallory square for sunset. |Izabella, the manager, was amazing. We visited as a part of a "make a wish-bucket list) stay for my wife. Izabella and the staff at AIC made it so nice she shed a tear having to leave.|I personally want to thank the staff and owners for being great people in a sometimes not so great world. This weekend will live forever in our minds.|GORGEOUS|PEACEFUL|COZY|ESCAPE

Peaceful. Quaint. Clean. Private. Just a wonderful hidden oasis. I wouldn't recommend kids since there are only 6 rooms, it's more of a getaway for adults that want relaxation. Great parking. Quiet. Free bikes. Respectful staff. Definitely would stay agin.

We loved our stay at Andrews Inn. We had a large group and took all the rooms, which gave us the ability to use the entire courtyard for gatherings - this was the best part because the courtyard is charming with a huge tree, shade and very well decorated, including a small splash pool. The breakfast nook and snack/happy hour bar was also great. Breakfast was above average and adequate. Bikes included was appreciated. Location is amazing as it's only 1/2 block from the craziness of Duval Street, but it's still tucked away and very quiet, considering its proximity to all the nightlife - most of the really loud bars are up the street 1/2 mile.||Rather expensive, especially for some of the rooms, which are quite small (Venezia) - Madrid was bigger and very nice. Service was excellent, but sometimes there was no one around. ||Will return for sure. Thank you to all the staff.