Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

We booked Andrews Inn for 3 nights after reading the glowing reviews on Trip Advisor. We received a very warm welcome from Isabella, who truly is the most wonderful hostess. Nothing is too much trouble, we were immediately made to feel completely at home. We stayed in Roma which is a beautiful room with a big 4 poster bed. It has a lovely front porch with 2 rocking chairs. We borrowed the bicycles to get around Key West, which was a great way to see the area. |Breakfast was lovely sitting out by the pool, and the 24 hour coffee, water & ice were nice touches. |Happy hour is between 2pm & 4pm, which was a selection of wines, beers & snacks. This was an opportunity to have a drink with the other residents and get to know them. We can understand why some people come back year after year. |Thank you Isabella, Johnny & Lazlo for all that you did to make our stay so enjoyable. We hope to return again! Alison & John.

Yet another amazing stay with The Andrews. When you visit twice a year you begin to run out of superlatives. Clean. Modern. Friendly atmosphere. It has become apparent over the past several years that if you had a less than completely pleasurable experience during your stay, that might be on you. A few handfuls of stays over the last several years and The Andrews has it right. Wonderful hostess and staff. Every need exceeded and “bend over backwards” is not an exaggeration. The owners have the right people in place and are doing all the right things. I am not a paid reviewer. My reviews can be researched over the past several years in regard to this property. See you in April! We can’t wait!

My wife and I have coming to the Andrews inn for years now, usually just before the holidays to celebrate my birthday. Once again we’ve had a wonderful experience. The entire team couldn’t be more welcoming and helpful. Though not large the rooms are well appointed and each offers a unique stay. The breakfast buffet and Happy Hour provide delightful breaks from whatever activities you may have planned for the day. Izabella is a shining star of hospitality! We are already booked for our stay in 2026 and I recommend booking early as the Inn fills up quickly!

The Andrews Inn was an absolutely lovely place to chose for a few days in Key West. It’s a little piece of quiet paradise in the middle of everything! Lazlo and Isabella do everything to keep everything working smoothly. Breakfast is lovely with lots of variety and the pool warm and inviting. Our room was very private and comfortable. We highly recommend you try it!

We had a lovely stay. The room was nice and clean. During the night it was quiet.|The breakfast was great and always fresh. I even received freshly made Gluten free breakfast, which was delicious and healthy. Perfect for starting the day.|We will definitely recommend this Inn to friends and family and will come again next time we are in key West.

Everything was perfect as usual. This was our 4th stay at Andrews and we would never stay anywhere else. We love the small size and all the amenities, as well as the great location. Izabella is the best, she makes sure everything is always perfect. Can’t wait to go back.

My fiance and I stayed here at Andrew's Inn for our 5 year anniversary. From the cleanliness of the room to the accommodations, happy hour and delicious breakfast served every morning, we were right at home. We walked to Duval street almost every day we were there. We also got to hear the Hemingway Tour right from our balcony. This hidden gem is an untapped resource. And we definitely will be going back. Thank you to the staff for keeping this place as tidy as it was. And for being friendly and making us feel as comfortable as possible while staying 😌 with you.|Ryan and Nina Sheehan

Our stay at Andrew's Inn & Garden Cottages in Key West was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we arrived, we were enveloped in a sense of calm and luxury. The inn has a beautiful, resort-like atmosphere - lush foliage, charming pathways, and peaceful surroundings that instantly make you feel like you've escaped to your own private paradise. Our room was cozy, spotlessly clean, and thoughtfully appointed with incredibly comfortable beds and soft high-quality linens. The bathroom was clean, refreshing and offering a stunning view of the Hemingway House that made our stay special. The amenities made our stay even more enjoyable with fresh continental breakfast and a delightful daily happy hour by the pool. The free bike rentals were a huge plus, allowing us to explore Key West with ease. The location is perfect - tucked away just enough from the hustle and bustle of the main street to feel peaceful and private. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, always checking in to make sure we were comfortable and had everything we needed. Andrew's Inn truly felt like a hidden gem. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a luxurious, intimate escape.

We recently came here for a 40th birthday celebration and everything was fantastic! Andrews Inn totally surpassed all of my expectations! When you walk in you are immediately greeted by an awesome pool area with lounge chairs, tables, a little tiki bar, and a vibe that screams Key West! To make it even better, we arrived at 2:15pm which was HAPPY HOUR at the pool, which included complimentary drinks and snacks! The pool was perfect for a dip and to stand around and chat. It was very warm and always clean. I loved that the lounge chairs came right to the edge of the pool so our freinds who didnt wanna swim were still close enough for converstation. We stayed in the "Madrid" room, which was immaculately clean and super cute! The king size bed was very comfortable and the room had a huge dresser for storage and a small fridge to store some cold waters and soda cans. Each morning they also put out a small breakfast which is an absolute perfect way to start your day! Breakfast out on Duval can cost like $30-50, so we loved the ability to fuel up here before venturing out. The breakfast items rotated but it included cereal, english muffins, bagels, hashbrowns, sausages, fruit, granola bars, orange juice, milk, and more. In addition to all the great amenities was the incredible level of service. Izabella went above and beyond to make sure our group was taken care of, all while doing it with a big smile everyday! And the best part of Andrews Inn has to be the location! You are steps away from Duval Street yet you are still in your private cozy world that is still peaceful and quiet. We often stayed up late and there was NO noise coming from Duval. We will definitely be staying at Andrews Inn again on our next visit to Key West!

Situated behind Earnest Hemingway's house, our studio was a gem of a find right off of Duval St.! Thanks to Air BnB superhost, Jeanine, who was very friendly and accommodating. We arrived in the late morning from the Key West Express Ferry and she made sure that our room was ready for early check in at 12 p.m. Jeanine also allowed us to leave our bags at the inn after check out the next day, since our ferry wasn't leaving until 6 p.m. It was the little touches that made this a special weekend getaway! From the Tommy Bahama bath products and make up cleaning wipes provided, complimentary happy hour with Napa Valley wine and premium beer with beer nuts, the attention to detail was a pleasant surprise. I highly recommend Andrew's Inn & Cottages for your Key West vacation!

Having never been to the Florida Keys before, my wife and I decided to extend our anniversary trip in Key Largo to include a short stay in Key West. I chose Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages based on other reviews I read and was not disappointed. Andrews Inn is situated in a great spot, just behind the Hemingway House. This makes it a short walk or bike ride to many great restaurants, bars and shops in Key West. We stayed at the Roma and enjoyed how cozy the room felt. Bed was very comfortable too. Isabella was very friendly and helpful in showing us around and letting us know where to find everything. Also had a great time talking and getting to know other guests during happy hour around the pool. When visiting Key West again, the Andrews Inn will be my first pick to stay.

We found this Inn through a search and noticed that they had availability for the two nights that we wanted to visit. The price was very reasonable so we booked. The location is just off Duval Street, spaced between the wharf at the North end and the Southernmost Buoy at the South end, both are less than a 15 minute walk. The Inn itself is a beautiful oasis in the middle of the island, lots of palms trees surrounding the small but beautiful pool area. It feels so secluded. We had a 2nd floor room, (Paris), and it was perfect for the two of us. The room was well appointed, clean and comfortable. Upon check-in, Izabella was warm and welcoming. She went so far as to print us out a five page listing of attractions and restaurants along with a map of the island. A free hot breakfast and happy hour with complimentary beer and wine rounded out our stay. This place is a hidden gem in Key West and we will definitely be returning soon.

You will find this place down a dingy alley off Duval St., and as you walk there you think, oh my God, what did we book. But then, you open the gate, and let me say, this is a great place! Pool, breakfast, happy hour. We stayed in the Malaga Room, which had a private patio overlooking the Hemmingway House pool. Lotsa cats which even tho I am not a cat person, was OK. Loud roosters nearby but that's Key West for you. Jorge the manager was very affable and helpful. We left our phone charging cord at home, but they lent us one which saved the day and we didn't have to buy one! 6 rooms plus they have I think 2 houses that the renters can come by here for b-fast and happy hour. Not alot of parking but we didn't have a problem as we used our rental car sparingly. The room was clean. Lush landscaping around the salt water pool. Did I mention happy hour? In the pool no less. Stay here!

Service, setting is wonderful and right off Duval. Close to everything and the breakfast and happy hours are excellent. Nice community of guests hanging out!!

Wonderful oasis right in the middle of everything. Beautiful big old key lime and palm trees surround the internal shared patio poolside and breakfast and happy hour spot. Owners are friendly and accommodating and the restaurant Viva across the street is a fun place to start a day drinking walk about or delicious brunch. Resort rooms are beautiful, clean and very air conditioned which were perfect for an afternoon siesta. Outlets are the only limitation but that's common in Key West. Pack a power strip and purchase reef safe sunscreen. CVS right around corner.

Just now home from my trip to Key West and I think at this point I have found a hidden jewel! You walk through the gates and into an island paradise! You can't tell that you're in the middle of a bustling coastal town full of tourist. Albena and Michael greeted me when I arrived and showed me around before I took off to explore outside their little paradise. But that night and the next, I found myself pulled into their quaint, little piece of heaven and not wanting to go outside the gates! The room I had, was so nicely decorated and had small touches that made you feel like you were home! I will definitely keep coming back! Thanks guys for a fantastic weekend!!!

This place is on the Duval strip but hidden enough to get restful night of sleep. It seemed like most of the people that were staying this past weekend are repeat customers :) Very friendly staff and so are the cats that were chilling in the premises. The property is also right behind the Hemingway house. We stayed at the Malaga room with queen size bed, sofabed and private patio where you can glance at the Hemingway house. Office is open from 9am-6pm so try to get there early if not, they will leave the key for you with instructions. Our room is clean and spacious enough. Bathroom has modern amenities. We really enjoyed our stay here and will be coming back.

Our stay was just delightful here! It's a hidden little oasis just off Duval Street. Very quiet and cozy. Adorable courtyard and daily Happy Hour. They even have books to read and sun lotion to use poolside, as well as ice tea and fruit infused water and ice all day to keep hydrated. We enjoyed a view of The Hemingway House's backyard and grounds from our lanai. Manager Lisa was on hand to answer any questions during the day hours or make suggestions of places to visit. A lady I'll just call 'Z' because I don't know how to spell her name, laid out a magnificent spread daily for breakfast. She also cleaned our room daily and did a superb job. We met a lovely couple from the UK who visit every year. Lots of kitties here and there, even a mama hen and her chicks hung out nearby. We are already planning a return trip this summer.

Our stay was perfect! Location was perfect ! We talked with Lisa before and during our stay. The staff were polite and friendly. Perfect spot right off Duval, but without the crazy noises late night. Hidden and nestled between fruit trees and tropical plants! Our room was located in the Eyebrow House which is right around the corner from the main cottage. We had a full kitchen, upper deck, hot tub and living room space. They had all the little things you would need to have a perfect stay. Everything was clean and bright and it really felt like home. PERFECT spot!! We will def be back again!

It was our first visit to Key West and Andrew's Inn turned out to be a perfect place to stay - close to lots of the action but removed enough to be relaxing and chill. My husband and I stayed for 3 nights in the Roma room. Check in was super easy and the staff was very welcoming. We walked into our room and it was like we stepped into a Tommy Bahama shirt. It was filled with Key West comfort and charm. The bed was very comfortable, and the air conditioning kept the room nice and cool. We also had a front porch off our room with two comfy chairs. The rest of the grounds were nice as well. The pool is VERY small - more like the size of a hot tub, but there were several lounge chairs and plenty of tables and chairs for breakfast. There was a small cabana setup with filtered water and ice tea always available as well as sodas for purchase. They also had nibbles like peanuts and a snack mix. In addition to that they had beach towels, sunscreen and chairs you could take to the beach. Every day they offered breakfast - eggs or pancakes with breads, yogurt, and fruit - and they had a happy hour with free wine and beer. One of the highlights for us was all the kitties running around. There were at least 6 and I'm sure the number varies over time so if you don't like cats, be warned. We love cats so we enjoyed watching them romp around and nap on the benches. We also rented their beach cruisers and rode around the island - so much fun! Everyone at Andrew's was super nice and laid back. If I'm ever in Key West again, I know exactly where I am staying.

This was my first time in Key West. My husband and I came down here for a "mini moon" after our wedding. We stayed in the Roma Room. It was extremely cozy. The room was a good size as well as the bathroom. The bed was super comfortable. There is someone that will come in an clean the room as well as give fresh towels if you need. The breakfast provided was mainly continental but every morning there was a special breakfast that one of the workers would make. When we stayed there we had Omelettes one morning, banana pancakes another, and they also offered French toast another day. Their Happy hour by the pool is beer and wine with some bar type snacks. The location is great located right off of Duval Street. It is far enough away where there is not much noise. A few cats roam the property but keep to themselves. You may also see a Rooster by the pool. We went to Key West in September, only downside is that it is the "off season" so some places in Key West are close until October.

We had an amazing vacation here before Thanksgiving. Every employee was kind, courteous, and helpful during our stay. The inn is literally next to Hemingway's home and has its own little group of cats that lounge about. We stayed in the Roma, which had tons of space and a gigantic bed. Everything was clean and orderly and we even had our own little porch to relax on. It was a bit secluded which was nice for sleeping at night, but also right off Duval street so everything was walking distance. Every morning, we were provided breakfast and every afternoon there was happy hour with complimentary drinks. I believe the inn was fully booked our first couple of days but it definitely didn't feel crowded at all. This is the only inn we'll stay at when visiting Key West in the future. I absolutely love it.

Amazing attention to detail!!! We frequently travel to Key West and love staying in the historic district. This has been our favorite place to stay so far. I could go on and on about this place. The attention to detail that they put into this place is impressive. The breakfast setup in the morning includes many options as well as mimosas. The toiletries are good quality. Beds are very comfortable! We stayed in the Pamplona room and loved it. It's upstairs, very roomy, and has a cute little private balcony. They have a drink station, restroom, and shower set up by the pool which was very nice! They set up free beer and wine for happy hour everyday from 4:30-5:30. They owners are super welcoming too! We will definitely stay here again!

I've been coming to the Andrews Inn for several years now and refuse to stay anywhere else on the island. Both sites (the main inn and the Eyebrow House) are just steps from Duval Street, which comes in very handy when you are crawling back at 3am from a night out! Jorge is always a pleasure to deal with and he makes a great butter spread for breakfast....he's also pretty awesome with NEVER forgetting the complimentary happy hour everyday at the main inn! Blanche is always on-the-spot in case you ever need anything and if you have a few minutes to spare (he can talk!) have him tell one of his funny stories of "back-in-the-day"....hilarious! I've never had a single bad experience at the Andrews Inn but have TONS of great ones! This is the place to go to get away and relax, but to also be very close to the action on Duval Street. The Hemingway House actually shares the back wall with the main inn and some of multiple-toed cats will hang out with you at the pool. Pretty cool! The beds are all comfortable with clean linens and the rooms have pretty thick walls, if you catch my drift. (wink, wink...nudge, nudge...) Also, the pool is always the right temperature, although you would be hard pressed to do laps in it. I'm looking forward to my next Key West trip and like I said, there is nowhere else I'd rather stay!

Fantastic! Every single thing from the moment we arrived was amazing! Don't even think twice, if you are lucky enough to find availability, book it!

I can't imagine staying anywhere else on our next visit! Perfect location, good price, no breed restrictions on dogs (we had a hard time with this) with a reasonable pet fee, very friendly staff, and beautiful rooms. My girlfriend, pup, and I stayed in the Treehouse loft and it was truly awesome. Don't let the 'loft' in the name fool you... It was very spacious on the inside with a slightly smaller full sized kitchen and it was nice having a little porch on the outside to relax and get some sun. I loved the outdoor shower! The jacuzzi was nice, but not necessary IMO. And don't get me started on the complimentary happy hour every day! Met a lot of really nice folks there. It was the perfect time to grab a drink before heading to dinner or just perusing Duval in general. The ONLY knock I could give our location (Treehouse Loft), was the lack of parking. We didn't have any assigned spots, but every time we left, I was able to find one within the view of the room. Maybe I just got lucky. But really, most people who visit probably won't even have a car. Just rent a bike! Andrews Inn will be the first place I call next time I'm in Key West.

Such a delightful, authentic bed and breakfast in the heart of Key West. Although it is right off Duval, the inn is very quiet and peaceful. It has a rustic, eclectic charm while still maintaining modern amenities. The AC unit in the room was incredible and kept us very cool in the sweltering heat. The complimentary happy hour was also a nice touch. We were impressed with their hospitality and look forward to returning in the future and referring friends and family who are planning to visit Key West.

We have come to Andrews Inn many times. The level of service is amazing. The staff is amazing. The The breakfast and Happy hour are a huge key why we continue to come. We refer many people to Andrews Inn. Hopefully new ownership realizes the level of service is why people return.

Stayed in the Roma room. Gorgeous and perfect accommodations. Very clean and in a great central location. Loved the attention to detail and the fully stocked pool cabana. Our room also featured a very relaxing front porch. A true oasis. Lisa was super friendly, and even let us keep our backpacks in her office outside of check out time. Won't be staying anywhere else in KW ever again!

Wonderful place. Lisa and her staff were friendly and went out of their way to make sure we were comfortable and had everything that we needed. From the complimentary drinks and morning treats to the nice cottages and pool. Our Roma cottage was very nice and loved the porch. It was very quiet for being just off Duval St. Park your car and have fun. Rent a bike and explore Key West from this ideal location. We will definitely stay here again on our future visits.

Just got back from vacation and we stayed in the Tree Top Suite at the Eyebrow house at Andrews Inn. I was so impressed with the level of service we received. Our room was everything we had hoped it would be and more. Our staff was so helpful and friendly. Not to mention, free breakfast and happy hour every day! It's so close to all the major places to go and see!

We stayed in the Malaga room which backs up to the Hemingway house. Very clean room, smells great too. Also it's a green bed and breakfast which means they recycle. Yes you do have to travel down a little alley but nestled in the middle of the other homes is a little piece of paradise. Breakfast is great fresh fruit, muffins and a hot entrée which changes day to day. Coffee, hot tea and mimosas to wash it down with too. They also offer a complementary happy hour with wine and beer.

My wife & I stayed here this past weekend and it was absolutely incredible, if was so relaxing & peaceful. We stayed in the "Paris" room and it was so comforting, we simply just loved our room. They offered complimentary Happy hour beverages such as wine and beer, I must say i haven't slept so good in quite sometime prior to staying at "Andrew's". We really did not want to leave, but we all must return to reality lol. The only thing that was a slight inconvenience was the early morning roosters waking us up, which was around 7am. However, we're already looking forward to our next stay, LOVED IT!

Managed to snag for one night the King Cottage with Patio and Hot Tub for $250. There was a free parking space for this reservation. The cottage is nowhere near the rest of Andrews Inn units, its surrounded by cottages of another business name across Duval street. The downside is having to check in and out across the street, getting ice across the street, and enjoying the free happy hour (beer & wine & chex mix) and breakfast buffet across the street. The big upside is the privacy. The king cottage is totally private, totally all yours. The bathroom at the king cottage has an enormous walk in shower with two different shower fixtures. One didn't have hot water so I presume was not the one to use. The experience was almost five star, but after being spoiled by the breakfast buffet the day before at another nearby B&B, I'd have to knock off half a star off of Andrews Inn. But this place is very Key West! Happy hour was great!

We recently stayed Andrews Inn & Cottages. I looked at the reviews on a few websites and booked the Paris Room. Everything was just as the photos look like. Beautiful clean rooms, air condition worked well as it was very humid. Swimming pool was very nice and clean. Breakfast was good, although some bacon or sausage would make it better. Happy hour was a plus. Parking was limited but we had one very close to our room. The staff was very accommodating! Andrews Inn was centrally located, near Duval where all the restaurants were . We walked a block to the Conch Train and a block from the Hemingway House . We will definitely stay there again

My girlfriend and I had a fantastic stay at the Andrews Inn. You could not ask for a more perfect place to stay. This lovely oasis is tucked right off of Duval Street and behind Hemingway's house. The staff was amazing, the complimentary breakfast, happy hour, wonderful pool and access to information were superb. We highly recommend. This is a great place for couples or a lone get away. Not for party types.

Amazing! Place is super cute and very clean! Very intimate setting, similar to what it must feel like to be a 'conch!' Walking distance to everything!

We stayed in the Malaga room. We loved the location and the common area with the small pool, beautiful trees and foliage, breakfast tables, and cats. Breakfast was good and the staff was great (turned us on to a great local bike tour by Lloyd -- another story). For the price this hotel was a good find, and will return here but will try a different room. The room was okay, but my biggest problem was the bugs. There wasn't a morning we woke up, or afternoon we returned, where we didn't find at least a few dead bugs in the room and occasionally live ones. Couldn't walk around barefoot at night for fear of stepping on something. I realize this is the tropics...but I hate bugs and I think they could be spraying or seal up the place more. It may be worse on the ground floor like this room is. The bathroom was nicely done and we loved the bed .The room is small and cozy. It was generally too hot while we were there (June) to use the patio that is adjacent to the Hemingway house, but may be nice in the winter.

Privately and quietly nestled, centered actually, in the middle of a block off all streets, including Duval Street. Peaking thru the foliage out one of our windows, we could almost see the Ernest Hemingway pool on that private one acre lot. To be sure, being so conveniently located in old town, you will see and walk by some funky, even dilapidated cottages. The front gate opens to an alley off Duval and the back gate alley passes cottages being renovated and is just around the corner from the Hemingway House entrance. Our room, the Roma, is so nicely appointed with a most comfortable king bed, vaulted ceiling, Caribbean colors and art work. We loved the tile floors. The bathroom is bright and clean with a small tub/shower combination. Plenty of hot water with adequate pressure, once we figured out the trick with the faucet. Wonderful toiletries including soaps and shampoo, que-tips, makeup removal wipes and even separate face clothes. Thirsty soft bath towels were decoratively arranged and replaced daily if requested. The private porch has two comfy chairs and a side table. It faces the back entrance gate rather than the pool and other guests. The generous breakfast was available at 8:30 with coffee by 7:30. You can expect a wide variety of baked goods, hard boiled eggs, yogurt, and hot and cold cereals. There is also one hand made hot choice each morning. We had a custom made omelet our first day, French toast on our 2nd day and a frittata the morning we checked out. We heard the Blueberry pancakes we missed were good as well. The pool area is lovely and well maintained with a small pool adequate for a refreshing dip. The staff is warm, friendly, helpful and attentive while ensuring a private homey experience

Overall it's not a bad place. But, there were rooms for improvement. We spent 3 days there renting one of their vacation homes - the EyeBrow house i think. The service was good, and the place was very clean. However, the bed was a bit small and the mattress was uncomfortable. They also had tenants upstairs, you could hear them walking around and it got worse at night when you are trying to sleep. Breakfast was on the lower end - very basic. We've had better.

We stayed here last night and found it to be a quiet, charming little place. The proprietors were very friendly and accommodating. The room was clean and quaint. The bed was very comfortable and we slept well. The location to Duval was perfect as well. Will stay here again.

Friendly and helpful staff. Beautiful, clean and relaxing place to stay. Would be a definite return and stay place.

This was our second time staying at Andrews Inn. Last year we stayed in the Mango Hideaway and this year we stayed in the Treetop Studio. We enjoyed both cottages, but Treetop had more privacy and a full kitchen. It felt like you were really in an oversized tree house! Andrews Inn has a very relaxed feel and includes all the amenities you could ask for on a Key West getaway. The location is perfect and the staff is the best! Our dogs think so too:)

A very nice little hotel with only 6 rooms or so. We stayed in "Paris", equipped with Paris-themed decorations and all. The hotel is in the back of an alleyway right off Duval, and you can see the Hemingway home from our balcony. They have a happy hour with free wine and beer every day from 4:30-5:30 and a complimentary light breakfast. In general the place is very cozy and quiet and the staff are all friendly. Also, they have bike rentals at $10/24 hours and free beach gear to borrow (chairs, umbrella, mask and snorkel, fun noodles, etc.). We had a great stay!

Great place to stay. Repeat guests. Both mango hideaway and sailor cottage were great. Lisa was very helpful. Can't enough nice things.