Anthony's Delicatessen

Anthony’s Deli is hands down one of the best spots in Mamaroneck for a solid, no-frills sandwich. The bread is fresh, the meats are piled high, and the flavors hit just right. The chicken cutlet heroes? Absolute perfection. The only reason I’m giving four stars instead of five is because I feel like the menu could use a little extra fun. Y’all should totally add a Skibidi Toilet Meal or something—you know, just to keep things fresh and trendy. (Okay, maybe not an actual Skibidi Toilet Meal, but you get the idea!) Jokes aside, the food is great, the service is friendly, and the vibe feels like home. If you’re in the area, it’s definitely worth a visit! Me and my wife love this place!!

I don't even know where to begin. Some of my earliest childhood memories include my father taking me to Anthony's. They have the best bacon I've ever had, an amazing chicken cutlet (perfectly seasoned, not too thick, not too skinny), and their cold cut sandwiches could feed two people EASILY. Every time I walk in I'm greeted by the same smiling faces from Vito (the owner) and the boys. I leave with a wedge for lunch and find myself satisfied for hours. I highly recommend the chicken ranchero, a relatively new addition to the menu and has quickly become my favorite. Over the years the prices have stayed fair and the quality is as consistent as ever. I'll be coming to Anthony's for many, many more years.

This place is fantastic. Great sandwiches, reasonable price, and big flavors. I have only been here once and walking in was very busy. They are keeping with in covid rules. Definitely a go-to place in the neighborhood. Highly recommend to call ahead with an order if you don't want to wait online. They are cash only with an atm inside. No credit cards are accepted. A small parking lot and usually packed street parking. Definitely will be back to try again. 12/12/2020

Came on a weekday while waiting to get my car fixed - great selection, reasonable prices. Loved the Italian Combo - so much fresh meat, delicious peppers, strangely light (ended up eating eat over two days)! Also had the Chubby Chicken which was a little disappointing - pretty salty, a bit dry and bread to filling ratio was off. The cole slaw and rice pudding, though, were great - will def come back with an appetite and try the other delicious looking sandwiches!

Very nice looking deli. I've always heard great things about this deli. I had eggs, sausage and bacon on a plate. They didnt cook my eggs the way I asked and asked for bacon crispy and gave it it me soggy. The coffee was good.

Excellent deli- great sandwiches, old school vibe…impossible to go wrong! Looking forward to my next lunch here- all the best

Pick up order for Graduation celebration on Memorial Day weekend. This is a busy place and recommended from my neighborhood Facebook group. I went in person for the the order, phone was always busy. Italian combo wedge and chicken cutlet wedge, potato salad, sausage & pepper tray, plus grilled veggies. Expertly displayed. They forgot to give my husband the sausage &peppers, called me and offered to deliver. Stellar customer service.

Guy at the counter (the "youngest" one, & that's being generous) was rude and dismissive. Greeted us as if we were an inconvenience with a "What's up." He microwaved... Microwaved??!??!? our bacon egg & cheese sandwiches. Since when is that a thing? As you can see in the photo the cheese isn't even melted. My bagel was cold. As if it had been sitting waiting, which would make sense because he checked out multiple people in the meantime and had no problem being friendly with them. Didn't read our total, didn't look either of us in the eyes, and didn't say thank you. Don't take your miserable life out on the people keeping you in business. The only reason for the 2nd star is I've had lunch there before that was good. But this guy? Grow up and learn what customer service And just being a decent human is.