Anthony's Delicatessen

Anthony’s Deli is hands down one of the best spots in Mamaroneck for a solid, no-frills sandwich. The bread is fresh, the meats are piled high, and the flavors hit just right. The chicken cutlet heroes? Absolute perfection. The only reason I’m giving four stars instead of five is because I feel like the menu could use a little extra fun. Y’all should totally add a Skibidi Toilet Meal or something—you know, just to keep things fresh and trendy. (Okay, maybe not an actual Skibidi Toilet Meal, but you get the idea!) Jokes aside, the food is great, the service is friendly, and the vibe feels like home. If you’re in the area, it’s definitely worth a visit! Me and my wife love this place!!

I don't even know where to begin. Some of my earliest childhood memories include my father taking me to Anthony's. They have the best bacon I've ever had, an amazing chicken cutlet (perfectly seasoned, not too thick, not too skinny), and their cold cut sandwiches could feed two people EASILY. Every time I walk in I'm greeted by the same smiling faces from Vito (the owner) and the boys. I leave with a wedge for lunch and find myself satisfied for hours. I highly recommend the chicken ranchero, a relatively new addition to the menu and has quickly become my favorite. Over the years the prices have stayed fair and the quality is as consistent as ever. I'll be coming to Anthony's for many, many more years.

This place is fantastic. Great sandwiches, reasonable price, and big flavors. I have only been here once and walking in was very busy. They are keeping with in covid rules. Definitely a go-to place in the neighborhood. Highly recommend to call ahead with an order if you don't want to wait online. They are cash only with an atm inside. No credit cards are accepted. A small parking lot and usually packed street parking. Definitely will be back to try again. 12/12/2020

Came on a weekday while waiting to get my car fixed - great selection, reasonable prices. Loved the Italian Combo - so much fresh meat, delicious peppers, strangely light (ended up eating eat over two days)! Also had the Chubby Chicken which was a little disappointing - pretty salty, a bit dry and bread to filling ratio was off. The cole slaw and rice pudding, though, were great - will def come back with an appetite and try the other delicious looking sandwiches!

Very nice looking deli. I've always heard great things about this deli. I had eggs, sausage and bacon on a plate. They didnt cook my eggs the way I asked and asked for bacon crispy and gave it it me soggy. The coffee was good.

Excellent deli- great sandwiches, old school vibe…impossible to go wrong! Looking forward to my next lunch here- all the best

Pick up order for Graduation celebration on Memorial Day weekend. This is a busy place and recommended from my neighborhood Facebook group. I went in person for the the order, phone was always busy. Italian combo wedge and chicken cutlet wedge, potato salad, sausage & pepper tray, plus grilled veggies. Expertly displayed. They forgot to give my husband the sausage &peppers, called me and offered to deliver. Stellar customer service.

Guy at the counter (the "youngest" one, & that's being generous) was rude and dismissive. Greeted us as if we were an inconvenience with a "What's up." He microwaved... Microwaved??!??!? our bacon egg & cheese sandwiches. Since when is that a thing? As you can see in the photo the cheese isn't even melted. My bagel was cold. As if it had been sitting waiting, which would make sense because he checked out multiple people in the meantime and had no problem being friendly with them. Didn't read our total, didn't look either of us in the eyes, and didn't say thank you. Don't take your miserable life out on the people keeping you in business. The only reason for the 2nd star is I've had lunch there before that was good. But this guy? Grow up and learn what customer service And just being a decent human is.

are you kidding me this old school deli major vouch say it loud with me the best deli in the entire usa the best staff in the business the best bec the best sandwiches always fresh always on point everything 40 years and just as good as day 1 anthony vito all my guys my whole life ive been hitting this spot up thank you for being the best

Best breakfast sandwiches and sandwiches period in westchester county bring wedges back to Florida leaving. Monday

I love Anthony's Deli! I've been patronizing this store for many years. The sandwiches are absolutely fantastic! I usually get the roast beef club wedge. Lettuce, tomato, mayo, and bacon. The sandwich is huge and the price is more than reasonable. The guys behind the counter are lightening fast, attentive, and always respectful. Small store with limited grocery items, which is fine with me as they focus on their stellar sandwiches and prepared foods. I can never just drive by without dropping in for one of their awesome sandwiches!

Anthony's deli is the best deli in all of Westchester County. Great prices and a traditional deli experience. Cash only but worth going to the ATM for. The breakfast barge never lets me down. Love this place

I challenge you to find a better deli in the area - it's just not going to happen. Been going here for years for a reason - they make amazing grinders and the prices are fair. Chicken cutlet grinder is my go to although you can't go wrong with anything they make!

This place is the real deal. We came in on a Saturday around noon, which was a rookie mistake to be sure (we tried calling ahead but the line was perpetually busy). The line wrapped around the store. I was worried we'd never eat, but luckily, as I said earlier, this place is the real deal. There's a squad of dudes back there just PUMPING out high-quality, well-designed, gigantic sandwiches. You won't have to wait too long. But while you wait, you need to figure out what to order. The tagline of Anthony's is Home of THE GODFATHER, so definitely rock one of those. It's got enough salami, pepperoni, ham cappicola, proscuitto, mortadella, sopressatta and hot peppers on it to feed my entire family for two meals. That is not an exaggeration. It's served on Arthur Avenue Italian bread, which is what you want to hear. The only thing I'd change is add more oil and vinegar, because for this much meat, you need a little more lubrication. They also crush any sort of chicken cutlet sandwich. The Chubby Chicken is certainly a winner, with bacon, ranch dressing, and cheese...but the Texan is basically the same thing, but with barbecue sauce, so you should probably get both. One of my friends also got a tuna melt, which I think had 4-5 cans worth of tuna on it, if you're looking to reenact a John Mulaney bit. It also looks like the breakfast sandwiches are incredible, and they've got all the drinks, chips, and other snacks you'd ever want along with a sandwich. Two last notes: 1. Their Super Bowl squares are legendary. 2. Whereas many people around the country call a sandwich on a long piece of bread a hero (correct) or a sub (less correct) or a hoagie (not great) or a grinder (no) or a spuckie (absolutely not), here in this narrow sliver of New York it is known as a wedge. Which I'm down with. Real. Deal.

I ordered through Uber eats and my order was incorrect in multiple ways ( forgot cheese, given the wrong type of cake). Their phone is on "busy" but it's been hours? The last time my husband got food from here in person he ordered a grilled chicken sandwich. When opening it since it was obviously wrapped up after the sandwich was made, we found that it was a chicken cutlet. The food isn't bad but you're paying for the correct order not whatever they want to give you. Today I ordered tiramisu and got some random cake that I don't eat?

Very very Good Sandwiches, this place a hidden gem can't believe this place has been here for some time! #WestchesterNY

Great food, and big portions. This is my favorite deli around. You get a lot of food and they don't over charge like other establishments in the area. I have been going to this deli for years and will continue to do so. Keep up the great work!

5 stars is not enough, these guys deserve way more! Fantastic sandwiches, quick service, and it gives the ambiance of a true NY Italian deli. They do not skimp out on the meat at all and their prices are great. I paid less than $15 for a 12 inch wedge, a pickle and a drink! Just a heads up, its a cash only establishment. You are definitely missing out if you haven't tried Anthony's. Best sandwiches in Mamaroneck, maybe even New York!

The best food at amazing prices ...Thank you guys! The quality and the speed are remarkable.

Great sandwich deli. Excellent customer service and killer delicious and generous sized portions!

Breakfast got me sick counter help wasn't wearing gloves, most horrible breakfast over rated because of the size n price. Will never eat there again

There is no skimping here. Sandwiches are overstuffed and staff is awesome. Godfather wedge is #1.

The best deli in Westchester County. Everyone is super friendly and works efficiently. The price is amazing for how much food you get. Highly recommend 10/10!!!

Great food large selection American guys behind counter have great attitudes and want you to get exactly what you want and prepare it with care! Think taking seeds out of long hot peppers! I believe they use San Marzano sauce which is such a flavor changer but whatever it is it's very good! Prices are very reasonable and line moves quick!

Anthony's is a great little local deli which has won multiple "Best of...Westchester" awards the best few years. They serve up some solid sandwiches at a good price and you get a lot for what you pay. My first time ordering here was an Italian Combo on a wedge and the thing was a behemoth. When they handed me the bag with my sandwich inside, I was awestruck by the weight. The awe didn't diminish once I sat down to eat it and unwrapped my sandwich. They load up their sandwiches with the meats and cheese of your choice and their bread is of good quality. The overall taste, too, was on point...so much so that I came back less than a week later to order another Italian Combo, but on a roll this time. Truth be told, the combo on a roll was plenty filling. I couldn't put away all of the wedge, tried as I did. Things to be aware of: 1. There is a long line anywhere from noon to around 1pm most weekdays 2. Their parking lot has room for only a handful of cars (but there is plenty of free street parking available) 3. They accept ONLY CASH - no credit or debit cards A wedge sandwich is probably enough for 2 adults with decent appetites to share. Only those with the largest of appetites can put away an entire wedge by himself/herself. My usual/favorite deli up the road on Halstead Ave. is closed on Mondays so Anthony's is a welcome option and a great one at that.

Hello this is Lee. I had a sandwich and it was good. It was called the chubby chicken. Man it was good. It was good. Like a bacon egg and cheese salt pepper ketchup hold the mayo. I will go back.

Excellent sandwich, I think I ordered the godfather and it did not disappoint. The potato salad was also great, the egg salad needed a little seasoning. Super friendly guys, clearly a beloved local shop, highly recommend. Bring cash.

Man, can this place make a mean sandwich! This morning I ordered two breakfast sandwiches for delivery, and they hit. the. spot. What I really appreciated about this place is how customizable the sandwiches were. I was able to get the turkey, egg, and cheese with hot sauce and a bacon egg and cheese with avocado and hashbrown. Both sandwiches were huge and the Kaiser rolls were so soft. Their fries remind me of the type you'd get at the a fair or boardwalk & would pair incredibly with some salt and vinegar on them. The service was so speedy and everything was packaged well upon arrival. This will definitely be one of my go-tos in Westchester when I'm looking for a mean BEC.

There are a lot of sheep in the comments thinking that waiting in line meant great quality. I wish I could give this place negative 3 stars. My first suggestion would be taking names down if you're going to entertain long lines to avoid giving the wrong order. I'm pretty sure I got someone else's poorly constructed sandwich because I got an sausage, egg, and cheese with ketchup which is something I personally would never order (no offense to those who do). The parts that weren't covered in ketchup didn't taste great either. The ketchup helped a little, which isn't a compliment. Normally I do not write bad reviews but I have to look out for my community. I wish I paid more attention to the negative reviews initially but for those that said they do not like black people, that's absolutely correct. I find this fascinating because they don't look like they'd be on the cover of anyone's KKK brochure anytime soon. That being said I'd skip this all together, especially if you're part of a marginalized group (saw some homophobic claims that I don't find hard to believe).

I tried the Triple Play hero today and was not disappointed. Melted American cheese on top of two deep breaded chicken cutlets and a nice dollop of homemade chili. I have to tell you it exceeded all my expectations! The chili was so good that I'm going to order it on future sandwiches from this place and the hero is so huge it made for two lunches. I can't wait to order from this gem of a deli, again . You won't be hungry after eating this one !

Great sandwiches 1 sandwich feeds 2 people Got chicken parmigiana and Italian combo... 2 sandwich's feed my family of 4 easily Still have a chunk of the Italian left over I just picked up two trays of food for tonight's dinner meatballs and a pasta dish for $40 I don't know how they do it but you get plenty of great Food for your money last week we order the chicken scarp And it was delicious as well. We order what they call a family dish and again you will not get better food for the price anywhere to me the best deli in the area for sure super service as well

Greatest bacon egg and cheese of all time. Aside from that, the chubby chicken is my go to, and the chicken cutlets never disappoint. Thin, crispy, packed with flavor.

My favorite deli to grab a nice sandwich or a BLT. I must admit the BLT's are addicting!

Have never had a bad sandwich. Tell them what you want and they got it! Favorite local spot from a local

Hate to write a bad review on this place since my family and I have been going here for years. Seems as if the quality of product has greatly decreased in recent orders. The past 3 times we have called in orders they have been made very wrong and the hero's were made about half the size (which is the reason we drive out of our way to go to Anthony's for the fat hero's they are well known for). Below is a picture of what is supposed to be an "American combo wrap" which only came with cheese. Writing this not to bash the place, but hoping that they will return to the Anthony's we know and love.

Love the food here. Crazy amount of options, big sandwiches for a really great price.

Antho y'all Deli is one of those rare "hole in the wall" type delis that is always packed with customers. From their piled high sandwiches, to their double-fisted grabs of bacon for their BLT's, to their homemade Chicken Cutlets, and everything else in between; Anthony's Deli is THE deli to go to!!! Line looks long, but turns over quickly. Staff is patient, nice, and will throw in your bag a mint or two.

Three stars because service and KINDNESS matters way more than how good your food is. I come here probably every other weekend for breakfast, if not more frequent. I order a turkey egg and cream cheese with hash browns and hot sauce (delicious, get it!!!). Every single time the guy acts like it's crazy and so complicated instead of just writing it down. Sure maybe it's a little different, but what do you care? Write down my order so then you don't have to forget and ask me over and over and be polite. I worked in a busy deli in my teens and was always polite even if customers ordered four slices of ham, two of bologna, etc. Instead of being polite the man chooses to give me an attitude despite how many times I say thank you. I wish there food wasn't so good because then it'd be way easier not to give this mean man my business. Get the breakfast barge if you're hungry. It's freaking delicious but a huge sandwich!

Just say no. Lived in Westchester all my life and Anthony's used to be good but not any more. Dry impossible to chew pastrami, soggy fries and onion rings, tough chicken parmigiana with no cheese, indifferent help, long wait. Not worth it.

I swear that when the guys are making a sandwich and slicing the meat on the deli slicer, they either lose count or just don't care how much they pile on the bread. It's funny when someone orders a Godfather, there's 6 kinds of meat (salami, pepperoni, ham capicola, proscuitini, mortadella & soppresetta) that I've counted at least 12 slices of each, plus the provolone & hot peppers. Sometimes they stop after 12 slices, look at it and pile on 3-4 more slices. I don't know why they bother to put lettuce on it just to give a semblance of having a vegetable in there. That sandwich can feed a family of 4 and believe me, I have! On hungry days, I would go for a Chef's Choice (pastrami, turkey, melted swiss cheese & russian dressing) on a wedge and I still have half the sandwich left over. The Chubby Chicken (chicken cutlet, bacon, ranch & cheese) is another heavy duty monster. For a more normal lunch, opt for a roll instead of the wedge/hero/sub/grinder. It will still be packed with meat, but you'll stand a chance of finishing it. One Anthony's sandwich can easily swallow up 2 Subway foot longs! Hungry for breakfast? You can order it all day, but get there in the morning for a Breakfast Barge (3 eggs, cheese, ham, bacon & sausage on a wedge), guaranteed to clog up your arteries and drop you back into bed! They have a small parking lot for 4 cars, so get here early for lunch, otherwise you can park in the street. Even then, the line inside can still go out towards the door, but the guys usually step it up and handle the crowded lunch rush.

Racist deli is still racist. I should have read the reviews to figure out they were rude. They actually whisper about you in front of you as if they are little school girls. SMH. We went there to try something new and the moment we stepped in it, it was like stepping into the "Insurrection Deli". Fine, hopefully the food is good right? We spent $40 bucks on breakfast and lunch. The reviews must be somewhat right...right? Wrong! The sausage was grey and tasteless, the eggs were undercooked, and to top it off, they got the order wrong?!? If you are going to be racist, at least get the order right. Odd enough is the people in the back are not whyte but still racist??! So, if you want a 0.5/10 sandwich seasoned with racist undertones, this is your deli. If you like racism, then you'll give this a good rating (see other ratings). But if you have any active tastebuds, even if you like racism, you will realize the sandwiches are barely edible.

Excellent heros. The bread is so good. Everything we've ordered is excellent. Bacon, egg and cheese. Philly cheese steak. Grilled chicken. All big. Excellent.

Good , generous sandwiches, fast friendly service and reasonably priced. You do have to get past the messy, dark disorganized wait line to appreciate. Someone recommended I try Anthony's, but if I walked in off the street I would have walked right back out.

BEST sandwiches! Hot food great! BLT very special. Favorite deli ever.

Everything here is amazing, you can't go wrong - every time. And I have ordered from them A LOT. Would recommend BEC, Italian delight, eggplant parm, and mozz sticks.

One of the best local delis. You always get a bang for your buck with hearty and tasty sandwiches!

Very small, 4 car parking, park on street, long lines... but oh my what a great place for sandwiches! The prices are right on the staff move at lightning speed. The food is to die for, fresh fresh fresh. Just the best place around for lunch. Try it. Frank G

Made my way to New York from Texas to bury a dear friend. One of the bright spots in my pilgrimage was a visit to Anthony's. It's like a time warp, everything remains the same. Enormous wedge sandwiches..... Same price....... Same people. This place is timeless and really really good. I only come up every couple years.... And I always make it a point to visit my favorite deli.

All the food is Top notch. Would definitely recommend this place. Breakfast or lunch and Even a early dinner you can't go wrong.

Their special Chicken Cutlet Italiano (under $10) is an amazing sandwich. Fresh crusty sesame hero bread is stellar. Their cutlet is wonderfully crispy and breaded, as well as actually hot when served in the sandwich. A bit light on the fresh mozarella, the bruschetta and vinegar helps keep the sandwich vibrant. And obviously a two meal ordeal with its size. Compared to Cosmo and Alex, this is a superior cutlet sandwich.

When you need a property deli in a pinch for breakfast, lunch or really any number of a million ways to stop your heart from beating and gain 50 pounds Anthony's is there and does a great job putting quality deli out consistently

Great sandwiches very fair prices. Tough to park but worth the wait. Skip salads and just get the wedges..

Generously stuffed cold cut sandwiches. Prices are more than reasonable. Some "specials of the day " disappoint once in a while. Overall my favorite deli!

Alyssa V can go scratch. Good food takes time and this is by far one of the 10 best delis in Westchester. You don't stay in business this long without doing something right. Please don't go back so the line is just for the un-privileged.

Makes the best sandwiches. They do not skimp in the meat. Delicious bread. Cash only.

Not really for vegetarians. I'm not a fan of this delicatessen since I'm vegetarian plus the place doesn't look clean. It's filthy plus the options are not a lot. Don't recommend if you are vegetarian

I don't know how Anthony's Deli stays in business. Your average sandwich/hero has enough cold cuts to remove more than 1/2 and still have enough left over to make 2 more average sandwiches. (No Exaggeration). The sandwiches are huge, the price is cheap. Have a look at the photo of the Balboa I posted. $7.25 for a 1FT hero stuffed with Roast Beef, Swiss & Garlic Oil. It's Lunch & Dinner. Awesome!