Anthony’s Supper Club

Let me tell you about a really authentically good Italian restaurant! Our servers name was Lisa very cool 😎 and chill waitress. Now on to the food! What can I say i tried all 3 meals and can't decide which one I love most. Got a Jamaican jerk chicken pizza for myself. Who would of thought a Italian place could do such a awesome job on that? But, they did! Phenomenal job one of the best pizzas I have had, and I have traveled the country. Now onto the chicken parm. My son got this, but dad had to make sure it was good. Ok Anthony you're moving in. I wanted that too. Nice breading on chicken, not too soggy, and that sauce you got something going on there. Wow! Now onto my wife's meatballs plate. Those blow my homemade meatballs out of existence! Perfect is the word, again with that same pasta sauce. Your garlic bread on the side, again off the wall. So my review of this place best Italian I have ever had. All three dishes perfecto. Will definitely be going back! Our new Italian place we call home.

Probably one of the best pizzas in the area. Food was all excellent. Drinks were good. Did I mention the food was excellent? My only complaints were that the service was very slow and the blue walls and bright lights don't match the quality of food you are getting. We will definitely be returning and probably making this my new pizza joint.

A group of us had dinner here and I have to say from the drinks to the apps to the meals everything was amazing. Great hometown feel with great food. First time and will not be the last for sure. Definitely one of not the cleanest restaurants I've been to. Thanks for everything see you soon!!!!

If good vibes, great food, and awesome staff had a baby, it would be this place. The atmosphere is so chill I’m considering paying rent. The food? Let’s just say I’d fight a raccoon for the last bite. And the staff is so friendly I’m 90% sure they’re legally required to adopt me now. Highly recommend!

Great pizza! Many other things that we have also enjoyed. Limited seating, so make sure to make a reservation.

The first time I ate here I left my credit card and drove all the way home and had to go back. The second time I ate here my daughter forgot her purse and once again we had to go back! Neither of us are scattered brained, and this is not a common occurrence. My thoughts are is the food is so good you literally must lose your mind🤣🤣 This is food you get in the Buffalo area not Chautauqua County!! Be careful though it may put a spell on you!!!!!!

Fantastic spot! The outside was very unassuming. The waitresses were friendly and genuinely happy to be at work. I even overheard them chatting with each other about how they love coming to work and the owner/chef is great to work for. That spills over into how they greet customers; with a smile and attentiveness. The food was fantastic. It's rare to see a restaurant with such high marks, so my expectations were pretty high. They did not disappoint! Creative spins on traditional dishes, outstanding execution on classic recipes. This place is a gem.

Delicious pizza and food. Great service. Nice atmosphere. Looks to be well cared for. And did I mention delicious pizza 🍕! UPDATE: GO TO ANTHONY'S, you will not be disappointed! The quality, quantity and price of the food makes it well worth the visit. We have tried many menu items over the past few times visiting and have never had a bad experience. I would even go as far as to say that we have never even had a mediocre experience. It has been excellent every..... single....... time! The truffle fries are amazing! The pizza is off the hook!