Antigoni’s Pizza

4 Stars — Here’s Why This past Friday night, after a long week and zero desire to cook, pizza felt like the obvious choice. When I walked in, though, the atmosphere caught me off guard. Things felt mildly chaotic—several employees behind the counter, a couple customers waiting, and what looked like a few mixed-up orders. No one acknowledged me to ask whether I was ordering or picking up, which felt a little strange. I kept the mood light by chatting with another customer until I finally caught a young man’s attention to pay for my order. And because I’m five months pregnant, grabbing a slice of chocolate cake on the way out felt like the right thing to do… until I saw the price. Almost seven dollars for one slice! I don’t hurt for cash, but that’s practically the cost of a small pizza. Still, I’d already committed, so into the bag it went. While waiting for my pizza, I took a bite of the cake—good flavor, but definitely on the dry side and absolutely not worth $6.75. I also mentioned to the staff that the walkway needed more salt, as it was extremely slippery where water drips down from the roof. They had some salt out, but not nearly enough and not in the most critical spot. Then came the biggest disappointment: the pizza itself. One of my photos shows how little cheese was on it, which was surprising and a bit disheartening. I’m someone who loves leftover cold pizza, but this one didn’t make the cut. With so many pizza options in the area, I’m not sure I’d return. Blessings

The place is about perfect even just walking in! I Knew the food was going to be good, and I wasn’t disappointed! Got my mom a steak and chz, onion+ gr pepper. She absolutely loved it, and I got the Greek salad we only both ate half of each and we couldn’t be happier! Can’t wait to try all the homemade fresh cakes they got available too. Keep up the good work Antigoni’s

Not the best pizza but it was good, the sauce and pepperoni were tasty. I got their "regular " crust, it was very crispy. The online ordering was great, the staff were nice and friendly. I noticed that they had a drive thru window, quite different for a pizza place. The inside was very clean. I will go back and try more of their menu items.

What an amazing Food this place is serving. Everything is so beautiful, We eat with our eyes and oh my God. Thank you for coming to Scarborough. Me and my family and my business will be weekly customers👌👌👌

So happy to finally have Antigoni’s Pizza in Greater Portland! Though new in the area, head to Lewiston and one can’t say enough about the excellence of this family owned business, veterans of Lewiston and Turner area! Don’t delay… head over to Antigoni’s Scarborough for the best food and service experience. And above all, meet the friendliest and most generous hosts and you won’t regret it!

I have visited Scarborough often, but I was not aware that this gem is open en route one. The food is beautiful and on top of everything is very tasty. All you need to do is give them a try. Oh my God!

Anna who took my order at the front was kind and cheerful. She was able to answer questions about the menu and I ended up going with the loaded cheese steak. It was a great sandwich! Currently there are three small tables and chairs inside to dine at. One of the tables is tucked away. I saw the gyro come out for another customer. I will be back to try that next.

Such a cute little place!! After trying for the first time twice in a row this week, I ordered some Salads from the catering menu for a party. Amazing people and the food is better than everywhere else around. If you give him a try, you will not regret it.