Bailey B.
Yelp
What a wonderful place! I'm not a huge fan of Mexican food -- probably because I haven't yet found something that consistently agrees with my palate, as I hate hate hate cilantro. It's genetic! However, I knew I had to try out Antojitos Izcalli because of how many wonderful reviews they get on pretty much every reviewing platform.
It did not disappoint! Although it's a little hard to access, with a small parking lot and a lot of construction going on nearby, it's definitely worth the trip.
Everyone working there was extraordinarily friendly, welcoming, and pleasant. If it's always that way, then I'd recommend coming when you're having a bad day; it's impossible to be unhappy around such a joyful staff. Although seating is limited, they do a booming carryout business, which is what I wanted anyway.
I got the quesadilla suprema with chicken. I'm guessing it's made with chicken tinga and Oaxaca cheese, but that's just a guess! Regardless, it was fresh, hot, and huge. I couldn't finish the whole thing. They also do homemade refried beans, which struck a great balance between mostly-smooth with a few whole beans mixed in. The rice could have been a bit more flavorful, but I still enjoyed it. The woman at the cashier gave me several carryout salsa cups without me even thinking to ask, which I super appreciated. I tried three different salsas/dips; one had too much cilantro, but there was a creamy avocado dip (not guacamole, it was too watery; not sure what it was but I liked it) and an extra hot salsa that I really enjoyed. Next time, I'll be sure to ask for sour cream, if they have it -- that was the only thing I felt I was missing.
Whether you're like me and looking to learn to love Mexican food, or a Mexican food fanatic, I highly recommend this place -- it's delicious, homemade food cooked by some of the kindest folks I've met in Tuscaloosa.