Nancy M.
Yelp
I hope mgmt takes time to read. I have visited NYC lots. Arlo is a cute facility. The rooms tho small, were clean.The breakfast food was tasty.The shared spaces were nice.The rooftop bar is quaint yet cramped w/most of your view blocked by a concrete wall. Some Arlo staff were great.
As for problems, the website doesn't provide info it should & there's no way to communicate thru the website or your res. except submit an inquiry at "contact us". This goes unread nor answered.Call (get a name - you'll need proof)
Online reservation invites u to choose & pay for an upgraded room. Be warned, Arlo ignores this upgrade upon checkin without refund explaining that this depends on availability, not your reservation. (??) we paid $30 a night more for an upper floor with an view , but never received, they never explained upfront & refused to refund the upgrade cost at check out. The website suggests that you park at nearby LAZ parking. The closest walking dist to LAZ is across 7th Ave. They should be clear , esp when asked,that the LAZ parking on 37th is actually accessible from 38th and Arlo has valet service there.
(pull up to hotel and have valet park your car for the same price as schlepping to the other ( closer on map ) garage and being charged twice. ) .
We had 2 pp in a 2 person rate room. We checked in w/2 and had confirmed 2 immediately after Arlo showed just 1 name in the confirmation. I also wrote in confirming 2 at the 2person room urban king w bkfst rate & confirmed by phone (!) and again at check in that the peloton bikes were available in the fitness center.
Meanwhile, I've a single small spinning suitcase & backpack . A porter keeps insisting he " handle it for me " as if I were unable to rest my hand on the handle .
Arlo suggested a higher rate now so I had them confirm rates for 2 we're still what I paid. Then they wanted to deny the second person breakfast. (?) After several minutes of confusion amongst those behind the desk, & reviewing reservation, we were told, oh yes, given our vouchers & room key to a standard room. No explanation. And silently charged $25 + tax for second breakfast voucher anyhow.
The room was tight as some say but well laid out. The refrigerator was not functioning. And the " upgraded urban view " didn't happen. Ours was an adjacent building and into someone's office and clothing on hangers.
The peloton bikes, why we chose to pay more and stay at Arlo, were both inoperable. A kind maintenance worker came down promptly but was ill and sneezing and coughing all over the bikes. mgmt had failed to keep one bike activated, and to fix the stripped seat adjustment on the other making it useless to anyone under 6'10". As compensation, ironically, we were offered free breakfast which we'd already prepaid for ( twice as it would turn out) we were told that the manager would be notified and do something to compensate It never happened.
The breakfast service was okay except for the 6 times and four servers we had to ask for cream for our coffee.
The bill was confusing even tho we had vouchers There was a $8 service fee , an $8 service gratuity and a another request for a tip on $50, We'd prepaid in advance w/our rateso it was bizarre. We left some tip cash anyway.
We checked out of Arlo & were suspiciously not offered a receipt or total. When requested it took over 10 minutes for someone to then find our res. (?!?) and produce a receipt where we'd been overcharged for an extra breakfast, a room upgrade that we'd never received and of course no mgmt compensation or acknowledgement of lack of fitness center amenity we'd booked for and confirmed in advance. We questioned the overcharges.Now they couldn't pull up any confirmation details & itemization, nor written communications etc. 20 min later they were arguing that I had to prove that I'd communicated about the second person, that breakfast was included in my rate, that I booked the upgraded room. I did all of this and then they acknowledged and offered to refund $25 that they had charged double for one breakfast . Only that.
The city bike access as never granted and when requested there was confusion as to how to go about granting this.
Some employees were great, others had no idea how to answer , help or operate or read their system. Some were friendly, but some just snotty and pretentious. It was a weird unpredictable mix.
The subway is not conveniently nearby in relative city terms. Nope. It's a hike. Easier to walk to most Times Square, Central Park lower east and west side locations and high line than use Public transport from here. If you have mobility issues, you'll be paying out the nose for rides to anywhere. And parking as $75 for an suv per night btw.
Frankly, the whole experience was a cluster and the hotel staff couldn't care less and seem trained to rationalize and conceal overcharges.