Mouette G.
Yelp
First, the obvious: the view is fantastic, and the grounds pretty good. That's 3*.
The tasting experience is sub-par, perhaps because the winery is a victim of its own success. A crowd worthy of a pub on a Friday night pushes to access the two bar counters. The wines covered by the free tasting were forgettable, nothing you can't find elsewhere, the good ones seem to be covered by a $5 surcharge tasting which is not advertised.
Service was not enthusiastic: for example, I asked and was denied a try of the ratafia, at which point the customer sipping it explained the surcharge tasting thing, why did it take a customer to let us know? Asking about the wines I was tasting, I was told the semillon was a simple wine, and the shiraz fuller bodied. I was waiting to hear that the sky is blue and grass grows on hills but he was already processing the next batch of tasters. I could not find a list of older vintages or rarer things that might be worth a purchase - maybe one needs to know about that in advance as well?
Only three toilets, two unisex and one female. Again the crowd meant a delay. There's a reason for having male toilets, it is possible for more men to be done quicker if you have a urinal, this means shorter queues for everybody. The only other place I know with unisex toilets is McDonald's, and they do it to discourage people from relying on their toilet...
If you want to observe the beauty of the Hunter Valley from high up, get through the dirt track and enjoy the view, but skip the stressful experience indoors, or come outside rush hour.
If you want to do a tasting with your view, go to Scarborough instead - same setup, but much better service (more interested, at least) and the free tasting has food and the better wines of the house.