Joseph C.
Yelp
As mentioned in previous reviews, this place is well-lit, well-organized, and has a fairly large selection. However, the selection is not at large as if it could be if the books had been crammed into rows and rows of tightly compacted shelves a la The Strand and other warehouse-style sites. This dilemma presents a used book buyer dialectic on preferred bibliophile environments; maximum stuff at the expense of organization and creature comforts on one end of the spectrum, sparse pickings in an excessively lit and decorated showroom at the other. Autumn Leaves balances this nicely, avoiding the feel of a warehouse but still providing enough light and space to see the books. Further, if you really want the warehouse element, trek downstairs for their extensive used vinyl collection. Great variety, good prices, wonderful hidden treasures among the vast stacks of 45's sold at bulk prices. The cafe upstairs is also very nice; good simple sandwiches, excellent coffee, and comfortable seating.
The only thing that prevents my doling out five full stars (and consider this review 4.5 stars, pretty darned good) is the store's hilarious but mildly annoying selection in terms of history, political theory, and other humanities texts. Granted, this is simply an inevitable consequence of drawing on a large college town for cast-off books for inventory, but there's a thoroughly twisted circumstance to be found on these shelves. You'll find a fairly sparse selection of basic historic surveys, academically rigorous cultural studies, and solid reference materials... but shelf upon shelf of communist treatises, anarchist manifestos, Marx/Engels/Trotsky/Lenin biographies, non-violent resistance and public disobedience manuals, etc. The juxtaposition in selection between the mainstream and loony books in these sections is pretty funny, but an impediment to any real reliance on Autumn Leaves for decent books in this genre. Otherwise, though, perfect... and, really, this quirk makes it all the more perfect for the Ithaca Commons.