Baffone Italian Bakery

Came here on a Saturday afternoon and had such a great experience. Food was delicious Gwen our waitress was amazing. Very pleasant, attentive, and answered all of our questions. The atmosphere was quiet and homey feeling. They have so many Italian desserts and gelato. Will definitely be coming back!

This place is extremely clean, loved the atmosphere because the music was perfect level and fit the mood. The food was amazing, homemade made to order, everything was fresh . What I loved most is the people working there loved what they were doing and it showed in the way they presented the food. The calzone was delicious and I don’t even order calzones, dough made from scratch. Noodles in my fungi pasta were amazing, fresh madenoodels. Deserts were amazing loved the gelato. They are just opening up so no wine yet, but will definitely be back. I’m already craving the food after last night.

The ingredients and recipes here are No joke.... INCREDIBLE quality and flavor while also being Super affordable too. I will recommend any and everyone interested in traditional italian food made with superb ingredients to come try this place out, you won't regret it. Everything is made fresh in house with imported Italian products so you won't get that bloated pasta feeling you get from other places. A definite MUST TRY if you're in the area....Oh and the meatballs are 🔥🔥🤤

We got the lemon chicken and the pasta with tomato, garlic, and parm. Everything was hot and delicious. She gave us some valentine cookies to try and they were awesome too!

What a fabulous lunch experience we had. We had the pleasure of meeting the owner and he is a wonderful human and shared a lot of Italian culture with us. Below the pictures of our pasta we shared and the bruschetta we picked. Fresh Pasta makes a difference for sure. You will not be disappointed if you come try this new restaurant.

I was really impressed with this Italian restaurant! The pasta is clearly homemade — fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The staff were so friendly and knowledgeable, making great recommendations and creating a welcoming atmosphere. You can tell they use quality ingredients, but the prices are still very reasonable. A great spot for authentic Italian food without the pretentious vibe.

Absolutely outstanding experience. This place truly feels like a little piece of Italy. The food is authentic, fresh, and full of flavor — you can tell everything is made with care and tradition. From the pasta to the sauces, everything tasted homemade. The staff was welcoming and attentive, and the atmosphere was cozy and genuine. If you’re looking for real Italian cuisine, this is the spot. We’ll definitely be back!

Baffone's food was very delicious. I had a Calzone and my friends had other dishes. We all declared them very, very good. The manager, Marco came over to talk with us and we had a very nice chat. I will be bringing my husband back and I want to try the pasta next time. Everything is homemade, the pasta was hanging up to dry in a cabinet! Just delicious!

My friend and I had a patate pizza and a tuna sandwich. They were fresh and authentic and delicious.

They make their pastries, Gelato, and pasta in house. We had the sausage pasta and the bolognase. The sausage pasta was $18 and the bolognese was $14. The carbonara was$12. We also had the zucchini bruchetta. Everything was fresh and tasty. I'm amazed at fresh pasta at a reasonable price. The server was friendly and helpful. We also spoke to the owner. He intends to open a fine dining side/wine bar with live music by the end of the year. I'm already planning my next visit.

The reviews on google do not tell the truth. This place was average at best. The carbonara had very fatty meat and absolutely no flavor. Noodles bland and texture less. The mozzarella in the caprese salad tasted like it was from your local supermarket, not Dop. And please never stuff a cannoli before being served, It gets soggy. The pizza, was there even a pizza oven? , nothing spectacular, other options around town. Sorry but I tried it and will not be back

I stopped by to pick up some sweets for my parents and for me. The rainbow cookies were $2.5 each and could have used a bit more jam in between the layers. Mami had the lemon Boba cake ($1.5) and said the sweet honey was perfect. She doesn't like overly bready sweets. Pop has not eaten his mini canoli yet because he was still eating his lunch, but he loved the small size of it ($1.5). I will need to return to try some pasta or pizza.

I had the pasta carbonara which was pretty good. Service was great. However, I got a cannolo from the bakery side, it was prefilled and the shell was soft - not good. May I make a suggestion to fill the shells to order to avoid a mushy product. Thanks!

Loved the cannolis! We stopped in before closing and they were so kind. Great food and great service.

Simple menu and a wonderful display of desserts. We stopped by for late lunch. My husband's family is from Italy so he had conversation with the owner in Italian. He came out showed us the fresh noodles that is made daily for his pasta meals. Nice staff and helpful waitress. The bakery is next to Planet Fitness so may be hard to find unless you know where to go. Nice ambiance.

This restaurant is highly rated on Google but my visit did not reflect. The service was good just very slow. We got there at 5:40 had our food at 6:05 when we were the only people in the restaurant. It was very quiet until more people came in at 6:20. The food was probably the worst Italian food I've ever had when they pride themselves with being "authentic". The carbonara wasn't terrible but the meat was undercooked and mushy. The cacio de Pepe was like eating pepper, water and pasta together the only real flavor was the pepper which was over the top. I don't like to slander restaurants or businesses but I heard beeping noises that resemble a microwave. I've never once heard that in small restaurant.

I came to this Italian bakery thinking they would have a wide selection of sweets and pastries but very disappointed, I order the strawberry cheesecake cup and honestly it was very very disappointing , absolutely no cheesecake at all and instead of fresh strawberries it had strawberry jam , it was not eatable, place needs alot of attention, display case needs alot of help, product doesn't look very appealing.

Probably the worst pizza I've had in Orlando. Spongey bottom, probably frozen/microwaved. Unbelievable from an "Italian Bakery" Will not be returning. AVOID

Incredible! You close your eyes as you take a bite and you are transported to Italy. such an amazing experience with the owner. Great staff!