LaLaetti L.
Yelp
Welcome to the Auswanderermuseum BallinStadt in Hamburg aka museum about emigrantion.
First of all: I will not join the overall praise for this museum. Now, 3 days after I visited it, I still think the quality of the exhibition is pretty mixed.
I visited it with friends, both fluent in English and German, and we switched languages depending on which seemed to get us quicker through, because the museum was pretty crowded on the day of our visit.
We both had intermediate to advanced knowledge of German history and emigration waves from Germany. I don't know how much you would get our of the exhibition if you are just searching for information where your ancestors are from. That's because the exhibition is pretty inconsistent.
Albeit, the general layout makes sense: Situation in Germany and Eastern Europe Migration waves Destinations - the development of the ships and the ship passage Entering the new country (with a special focus on Ellis Island) Immigration Countries other than the USA/Canada (Brazil, Australia) famous immigrants who've made it.
In another building the history of the BallinStadt is told, with the situation which led to the building of the barracks, their short-lived fate from 1901-1914 and the seemingly even shorter time between WW I and WW II. Plus the story about the back-then CEO of HAPAG, the shipping company that invented ship cruises and got big by shipping immigrants over the Big Pond.
About the flaws in the concept:
English vs. German:
Everything is labelled in English in German, but the German label dominate, the English is always a bit shorter and layouted in a smaller font.
Bigger picture vs. individual story:
In the beginning you are confronted with six individuals, which should guide you through the exhibition and tell you their story. They literally tell you their story, which might be longer with the one and quicker with the other. Unfortunately you cannot skip when you dialled the wrong language, you have to wait until they are finished. On crowded days, you have to stand in line, there are only two earphones per puppet, and you can dial only one language at a time for both earphones.
And in the end you find out the six individuals don't really guide you through. You just see them back at the end of the exhibition, then they tell you what their life is like not that they are away from home for a couple of month or years. There is no alternative way to find out about their fate, you either wait and here or you don't find out about them.
During the different stages of the migration, there are different individuals who show up and just present one piece of information, you don't get informed what their background is, et cetera.
So if they already put such an efford in telling an individual's story, why don't they use it to describe the different stages of emigration better?
History of BallinStadt
There is a lot of pictures and exhibition objects which are not labelled, and you might only get the meaning of it later on, if you get it.
Conclusion:
Ok, we learned a lot, and I think for kids it might be funny to run through a ship which changes from early 18th century to early 20th century within a few meters. But there is a lot that is forbidden to touch (not a good idea with kids). The fact that a lot of exhibition objects are not labelled and you might learn to know what it was waaayyy later is annoying.
The entrance fee is 12 EUR, which is not cheap. As the museum is not publicly funded, it is heavily sponsored, f.e. by Ancestry.com. This is a bit ironic, because the digitalization of the archieves is publicly funded, so it is a strange kind of private-public partnership.