Boyo I.
Yelp
5 stars because of the spectacularly beautiful setting with 4 uniquely amazing golf courses. This is a must-see destination for golfers and the place is 100% dedicated to golf "as it was meant to be" (as their slogan says) with nothing else to distract (or entertain, if you don't happen to be a golf fanatic).
We played with two different caddies (Al was terrific, the other guy--not so much). It was a nice luxury for $100 to share a caddie but it certainly wasn't necessary to enjoy the difficult courses. We didn't use caddies for three of our five rounds.
We had to transfer rooms during our stay which was inconvenient but it allowed us to experience two different accommodations: A Chrome Double and a Forest Double at The Inn. The Chrome Double was larger, like a townhouse without a kitchen, and it was surrounded by a lush green forest. It was peaceful and deluxe in a sort of Scandinavian way. The queen beds were terrific. We spent one night in a slightly less expensive Forest Double room at the Inn and it was more like a motel room, albeit a nice, spacious, clean one. The shower an jacuzzi tub in the Inn room was superior to the one in the Chrome room. The Inn is walking distance to several courses and the Lodge (where you eat breakfast) whereas the Chrome is a three minute drive or ride on the free shuttle.
The food at the various courses was very good, especially at Pacific Dunes. Get the fish sandwich or the bratwurst and onion rings. (I wrote a separate review of McKee's Pub).
As for the golf, Trails was grand and spectacularly beautiful. Pacific Dunes was too scenic to be believed and it's understandable why it's rated as the #1 or #3 best course in the US. Old Macdonald was extremely interesting as it is apparently the finest recreation of one of the old links courses in the UK. There is very little difference between the fairway and the greens, and the recommended play is often to putt, sometimes from well over 100 feet from the hole. Bandon Dunes, the original course, was easily our least favorite, though it was still very nice and had a few spectacular holes. But it had a few duds, unlike the others.
The condition of all the courses was very good.
The customer service and friendliness of the staff from start to finish was exceptional. Also, even though you're isolated at the resort, you don't feel like their trying to always make an extra buck of you.
The major downside of a trip to Bandon Dunes is that it is quite possible you could book your trip in advance (as you need to) and then arrive only to endure horrible weather the entire time--in which case, you basically can't enjoy the golf if you dare to play. We had unexpected torrential rain (merely an "Oregon mist" our caddie called it) and we had to stop after 13 holes. And despite having rain gear, we were soaked and unhappy. Fortunately, the next three days were fine, two of them glorious.
All in all, despite the remoteness and inconvenience of the place, it's an adventure that every lover of the game should go to at least once. I'd like to return.