Michelle T.
Yelp
Please don't come here - this is a terrrrrible spot...
[whispering]...have I scared you away yet? Damn! I didn't think that would work given this place's perfect 5-star rating! It was worth a shot...living just around the corner, my husband and I are regulars at this point and this place felt like our little secret for some time before the lines started forming outside by people curious to get a look behind the blackout curtains.
We've had many lengthy convos with Dwight and Quinz, the brothers who run this fine establishment - enamored by the speakeasy culture of London and NYC, they wanted to carve out their little slice of that in Amsterdam center with Bar Oldenhof. Everything from the decor (ex: antlers hanging on the wall to pay homage to the street's namesake - elands ="elk" in Dutch) to the music (jazz / jazz covers) to the photos on the wall (NYC, what what!) just fits together beautifully. It's like spending the evening at your coolest friend's place, the one who knows a thing or two about interior design and mixology!
The brothers are also the ones mixing the drinks which is why it may take awhile to get your order - quality takes time. But they are always upfront about this and will warn you when they're short staffed for the night. Every drink on the cocktail menu is expertly prepared (pull up a chair at the bar if you want front seats to this show!) with new seasonal drinks appearing every few months - and they're as STRONG as they are delicious! Not sure what you should get? Don't be afraid to ask for advice or even a modification of an existing drink, they're very accommodating.
Have I mentioned that there's FOOD here too?! Every bar snack I've tried here I can totally recommend.
Sidenote: I've been here so many times that I've devised my own Oldenhof drinking game of sorts: as soon as you sit down, you're offered some bar snacks. As soon as you finish that plate, you get something more...and different. So I spent quite a few visits trying to reach that third snack, and have enlisted my drinking buddies to help me out on the quest before last call hits. For the rest of you, I will save your livers and satisfy your curiosity with a spoiler alert: 1- nut mix, 2- olives, 3- prawn chips. You can thank me later!
The Oldenhof brothers are truly a class act - a reliance on good vibes, better drinks, and positive word of mouth continue to make them a huge success! No speakeasy gimmicks, just easily the best cocktail bar I've been to.