Alexander B.
Yelp
If you're looking for the opulence of Blue Bloods at Casa Loma, don't go to Barberians. If you're looking for an exception steak that is cooked to perfection in an old world and intimate setting, well, than Barberians is for you. I have reviewed Blue Bloods as well and you can see my comparisons.
The low light, candelabras and antique flint lock and WW1 rifles mounted to the ceiling provide a warmth that can be described as a family home. Tucked neatly off the street I thought the venue had a secret feel to it, which I'm in too. I wore a blazer and didn't sweat through it which meant the temp was comfortable for eating without being something the wives were complaining about .
We had the gambit of dishes, the cheese bread, oysters, and all the salads. Ask for more pickles, they are done in house and they are a kosher delight. The wedge salad was the best way I've seen one done, I recommend it.
I had the Dry aged Ribeye, Chicago style (butter charred on the outside and rare/medium rare on the inside). If you like steak, you'll order the ribeye, Just pay the money and enjoy.
We had a variety of sides (sprouts, green beans, fries) the sprouts take the cake though, highly recommend.
The cheese cake was ok, a little soft and warm for me but hey, it's cheesecake. I ordered an espresso that never came and didn't have the heart to remind the waiter a second time. My water glass was filled after every sip....so The service was attentive and in general I have no complaints.
Be prepared to spend at least $400+ for this experience. I don't see how you can get out for less.