Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts

Performing arts theater · Sag Harbor

Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts

Performing arts theater · Sag Harbor

1

1 Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Photos

Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null
Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts by null

Highlights

Regional theater productions, drama education, concerts, and camps  

Placeholder
Placeholder

1 Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 Get directions

baystreet.org
@baystreettheater

$$

Information

Static Map

1 Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 Get directions

+1 631 725 9500
baystreet.org
@baystreettheater
𝕏
@baysttheater_

$$

Features

payment credit card

Last updated

Oct 9, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@travelleisure

Sag Harbor, New York Travel Guide

"According to Vazquez, a visit to Bay Street Theater is an absolute must. In the summer, they also offer kids camps, giving families another reason to love the theater; parents can relax while their children are entertained! Additionally, the venue often hosts concerts, workshops, masterclasses, and more, so be sure to check the events calendar." - Travel + Leisure Editors

https://www.travelandleisure.com/how-to-visit-sag-harbor-new-york-7559443
View Postcard for Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts

Dia CJW

Google
3rd time at this theatre 🎭, and it’s a 10/10! Small, not a bad seat in the house, pleasant staff, great location, and fantastic shows with the best of actors/actresses!!! Bonnie and Clyde had the best singing 🎵 one could ask for. And the BAND was fire 🔥. For a minute…I thought I was at a concert 🎶!!! Looking forward to the next time :-)))) #GRATEFUL

Jivan Ramesh

Google
The show “Deceived was wonderfully acted and performed! Stage was easy to see.

canyoudoanybetter

Google
Great theater in the heart of Sag Harbor with top shelf shows, quaint indoors and tasty food and drinks!

Maddi Stone

Google
I absolutely love this theater!! I got to see Nancy Atlas with Special guests Pamela Betti and Gene Casey!! What a great show!!! Can't wait to come back!!

Gregory Barbera

Google
Great place. Wonderful staff and the perfect size theater where every seat is a good seat. Say a great production.

Michael Tillman

Google
It was a wonderful show with good wiews of the stage from the audience. The sound system was clear. The bartender was friendly.

Mary T McPartland

Google
My favorite place to catch some of the most professional, well-attended theatre out East. Pay what you will night allows everyone to attend at very affordable rates. All of their performances are excellent, not a bad seat in the house as all sightlines are clear to the stage. Personally, I love the side sections. If you're on a budget, grab the $25 seats and have a great night out!

max bednarcyk

Google
Bonnie and Clyde is an amazing show and bay street is a very cool venue

Charles M.

Yelp
Great talent and professional director. We always are able to get good seats. The equity actors are top notch and put on wonderful performances. We go every year when we arrive in Sag Harbor.
google avatar

Krystyn P.

Yelp
What an adorable little theater! In all honesty I wasn't expecting this cozy venue tucked away by the waterfront. While it appears there's a pretty steady repertoire of plays that circle through the place, I had the fortunate experience of attending one of Nancy Atlas' Fireside Sessions. I literally had no idea what to expect, but the set list was filled with classics that you could either singalong with or get up and dance to. Would definitely recommend watching something at the theater if you have a chance!
google avatar

Joel H.

Yelp
What a cute little theater. Sometimes this is just what you need for that special intimate show. We came to see Steven Gutenberg. What made it just a little more special is that my wife knew and worked with him as a teenager. (Just a few year's ago.) We parked at the pier and were lucky that we caught someone just leaving. It's not easy on a nice Summer day between the locals and tourists. Once we entered the lobby, we looked around for a bit then went into the theater. A big semi circle of comfortable seating. No one is too far from the stage. Steven's show had a small cast and I could not think of a better to have seen this. The staff is very courteous and helpful. I can't comment about food since we did not have anything here. I am looking forward to coming back to enjoy the setting both inside and out. KUDOS to the team here at Bay Street Theater.
google avatar

Bill S.

Yelp
This place always makes me laugh. Picture it, 1987. I just separated from the military. My buddy was a bouncer here when it was a club. He whispers to me: Bianca Jagger is upstairs. I RUN upstairs and start making goo goo eyes at Bianca Jagger. She is with a dude who looks like a dork. We make eye contact, she gives me the up down and then turns away. I thought I had the moves like Jagger!!! haha 30+ years later, the Bay Street Theater is open for theater performances and musical venues. I was reading the playbook given to me when we walked in, there are a few fun performances happening in 2019. The seats we had gave us a commanding view of the stage. We saw Denny Laine from Wings, he gave a great and very intimate performance. He asked for audience song requests and I stumped him. He said he forgot the song!? Dude.. Paul McCartney lives in Montauk. I was telling my wife how cool would it be for Paul to show up and they both sang Jet??? Ah, such is life. It did not happen. Paul... Uncool man! Parking for the event, we parked at the pier for free. During the summer, I'm sure its a madhouse so give yourself extra time. From the comfy seats to the intimate stage, Bay Street Theater gave us a unforgettable, 5 Yelp star performance.
google avatar

Linda K.

Yelp
Wonderful intimate theater with a nice mix of edgy new offerings and older classics. Seating is in the half round and sight lines are mostly excellent. I've been coming for many years, most recently to see a great production of "Frost/Nixon" whose wonderful reviews were well earned. They give subscribers first dibs (as they should) but I always manage to get single tickets later in the season. Parking can be tough in Sag Harbor especially on weekends, so get there early to ensure a spot and enjoy.
google avatar

Mrs G.

Yelp
Cute little theatre, great location. Do not miss the improv group, The Stowaways! So much fun tonight & what's better than hearing your suggested funny word ur phrase ending up on stage? Such talent in this troupe! One tiny criticism--- if you specifically differentiate between Catwoman actresses... know who they are.... no way was that Eartha Kitt-like. Loved the charades! Will definitely look for another show to attend.
google avatar

Sen-Pei H.

Yelp
More than pleasantly surprised. Came here on a whim with friends to see another friend, Bopa King Carre, play with the Nancy Atlas Project. Invited by Joe Haines (Smokin' Joe), who let me on the ins of the good shows in the area. At first I had my reservations. There was a bit of a cheese factor, when a musician dressed as a banana walked out onto the stage, which ended up being cute and fun to enjoy. As the set progressed, I was astounded at the set of pipes on the singer, Nancy. Bopa (Equanimous Minds), of course, was great at playing bongos - especially his facial expressions. Then Winston McAnuff (Electric Dread), came out and gave a special little performance. Apparently the Nancy Atlas Project is based on a bunch of friends who go on tour and have come together for a nice little gig every Friday. Red wines (I ordered a cab) were $7, which is affordable, if not the best quality. But it went down smoothly and good to taste. Either way, the show was amazing. It definitely was uplifting and there was a lot dancing in the back and front rows. Will come back.
google avatar

Melissa G.

Yelp
Great theatre! Quality productions, loves giving back to the community. Their main stage season is during the Summer, so parking might be a hassel. I truly look forward to seeing each show. Also frequently used as an outlet for up-and-coming shows and artists. I highly recommend this theatre.
google avatar

Ashley N.

Yelp
Awesome theater! Recently saw my cousin perform in the travesties and was so impressed by the staff, actors and actresses. This theater is so intimate and you feel a part of the show. If it was closer for me to see a show here, I would definitely see all the shows.

A J.

Yelp
Good local theater. Fun shows with arena-style seating. Can be chilly - bring a sweatshirt!

Daniel D.

Yelp
We just saw Annie get your Gun. What a fabulous production. This is the 3rd musical we've seen there and thoroughly enjoyed each one. Incredibly talented crew.

Jan S.

Yelp
Award-winning Broadway director John Doyle has pared down and updated Shakespeare's weak comedy "As You Like It" for summer fun and frolic at Bay Street Theater (thru Sept.3 and going on to NYC's Classic Stage Company this fall). Most of the speaking/singing/musician cast is outstanding, particularly Ellen Burstyn, Bob Stillman, Andre de Shields, Hannah Cabell,Kyle Scatliffe, Leenya Rideout, Cass Morgan. There is charming music added to Shakespeare's Elizabethan lyrics ("Hey nonny, nonny....") by talented Bway/Hollywood composer Stephen Schwartz -- my favorite part of this production -- but why waste all this talent on such a silly play? Oh, it does have Jacques' (Burstyn) famous "All the world's a stage" monologue, but the dialogue is mostly a collection of clever one-liners that many will miss because they are spoken quickly and mostly quietly, alas. On Mondays, when the play is off, Bay Street has Jennifer Holliday solo on Aug. 21, Stephen Schwartz with Liz Callaway, Scott Coulter and Debbie Gravitte on Aug. 28, and a free concert production of Cole Porter's "Kiss Me Kate" with Melissa Errico and Richard Troxell in Sag Harbor's Mashamuett Park on Aug.25 & 26 (bring you own chairs).
google avatar

Luana D.

Yelp
I purchased eleven tickets for a concert the week that they became available, which was three months before the concert date of October 13. I was lucky enough to get the first two rows, center. I had two family members traveling from out of state and since I had seen The Sixties Show before and had been raving about them for some time, we were ecstatic to have such great seats. When we arrived at the theater (first time for all), we were so amazed by how quaint the theater was and how we truly had the best seats in the house. Fast forward to the opening of the 8:00 show, and what was supposed to be a CONCERT (as described on their web site and tickets) turned out to be obnoxious, rude, most-likely-intoxicated dancing patrons who gyrated, twerked, and pranced across the stage fully blocking the view for every single family member in my party while the wonderful, high-quality band playing gave it their all. I, along with several other patrons whom I did not know, immediately went to the lobby to complain and we were told that there was nothing they could or would do and that it states on their web site that dancing may occur and is permitted. Mind you, the band is NOT on an elevated platform so people dancing in front of them completely blocked the view of the people in the first two rows, especially center, which is exactly where we were. The people who worked there were difficult to find, impossible to talk to, and nobody--absolutely nobody--in my party EVER saw any employees actually IN the theater, except when they were helping people to their seats before the show. Audience members were screaming for the impromptu exhibitionists to sit down, words and cursing were exchanged, and it was generally getting very ugly, with absolutely no intervention from theater employees. I was horribly embarrassed not only for my out-of-town guests but for my two teens, as well. Even if somewhere on their web site it DID talk about the possibility of dancing, it does not say that views from some seats would be completely obstructed. Second, they need to decide if they are going to be a venue for a musical concert, or dancing. It is absolutely and utterly unfair to people who not only came to hear the band, but to SEE them as well. If people want to dance, they should go to a club conductive to dancing! Nothing I write here can fully encapsulate how disappointed we were and how angry that a concert that we looked forward to for three months turned out to be the colossal disappointment that it was. The great band and music turned out to be a forgettable blur because it took several very angry trips to the lobby (where we were consequently ignored) to beg for some semblance of order (is it asking too much to have an unobstructed view to a show??) and were met with a "too bad" attitude from the horrifically unprofessional staff. It was a first and DEFINITELY last trip for my eleven family members (plus two friends who bought separately but sat with us) to the Bay Street Theater. Never again.

Beth B.

Yelp
With some exceptions, the theater at Bay Street tends to be very second rate summer stock. For more serious summer theater, places like the Berkshires (Massachusetts) and Stratford (Canada) blow this place away. With the proximity to all the talent in New York, you would think they could produce higher caliber theater. It's the only game in town for the Hamptons so if you are looking for something to do, it's not terrible. But I was surprised to find that they have a weirdly inflexible ticket policy and won't do simple exchanges. The top theaters on Broadway all have "no exchange" policies, but are actually very flexible and accommodating if you make a mistake and ask for a different date, etc. I would think if those theaters, which are owned by large corporations, could do that, it shouldn't be too hard for Bay Street.

Lisa F.

Yelp
Every play we have seen here has been over the top excellllllent. Love this venue, get tickets and be a part of this small intimate theater.