Eric Z.
Yelp
I was skeptical of this place because of some of the reviews I had read. I had been waiting for a while for this place to open up since my wife and I love to live it up every now and then at a swanky looking place as a brief escape from taking care of our new child. I figured the Ritz-Carlton wouldn't disappoint. We had a really great time.
Bellpine did not disappoint. We sampled 6 of the entrees, 2 cocktails, a glass of wine, and a dessert. The tab came to $209 before tip, which was definitely a splurge for us, but we were satisfied with the experience. We were told that for a "full meal" we should expect to order 2-3 entrees per person (most of the menu is tapas-sized dishes), and the prices ranged from $18-$30+.
The service was phenomenal. Our waiters were very attentive, never letting our water glasses get empty. They checked in with a smile at just the right frequency to let us chit chat on our date but also make sure we were taken care of in terms of having a delicious beverage to sip on. They were also incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, like being able to tell me where the beef and vegetables we were eating were sourced from, and able to detail all of the different notes and flavors in some of the more intricate dishes. It was also clear that the staff had all actually sampled the food before, which in my opinion is crucial for amateur foodies like us who ask frequently for recommendations. Our marble dining table was frequently cleaned between service as well. Our entrees came out in 3 waves, and the first wave came quite promptly, as did our cocktails and wine. The ambiance was fantastic, with very comfy chairs, nice marble tables, nice romantic lighting, and gorgeous views of the city.
The Salmon Crudo ($24, ~six slices) was phenomenal. Buttery, fresh King Salmon sliced thin, laying in a shallow bed of citrusy ponzu sauce with little pops of cured lemon gel.
The Crab Berliners ($26, two crab rolls) were very tasty, essentially two little crab rolls in brioche buns with some sugar sprinkled on the bread to be more donut-esque. Mildly sweet, very savory fresh crab, very nice. In my opinion, this one is most likely to be the crowd pleasing, obvious choice.
The Shrimp & Grits Corndog ($19, two corndogs) was decent. It's pretty much an overpriced corndog but with a shrimp sausage in the center instead of a hot dog, with some drizzles of bougie sauces on top. It's tasty but by no means special in my opinion.
The Bay Shrimp & Potatoes ($19, six pieces) was nice, like elevated potato bites filled with shrimp topped with essentially a homemade ketchup.
The Butternut Squash ($18, ~8 pita triangles and a medium plate of squash) was honestly the climax of the entire dinner. This thing was bonkers good even without a protein. The hazelnut butternut puree was sweet, buttery and nutty, with a little coffee aroma, and crunchy bits scattered throughout. Spread on a pita triangle, this thing was sweet an savory heaven. I would come back just for this dish.
The only food item we got that we truly do not recommend is the wagyu beef waffles ($30, two waffles). It was puzzling - the waffle was not particularly great, not crunchy on the exterior nor fluffy in the interior, the beef itself, though crowned "wagyu" (from Washington state, nothing like real A5 Japanese wagyu" tasted like very plain roast beef slices, the whole dish was bland, and the waffles had hole-shaped cutouts in the center for some strange reason that turned them into waffle bagels.
The dessert we got was the Forest ($14). Easily the most unique dessert I've ever eaten, designed to look like the forest floor, with pistachio mousse "moss", a mushroom-shaped shell containing chocolate and a porcini ice cream, all super unique flavors that I now know I am very into. This one definitely felt like the most "experience-y" of all of the dishes we got.
The cocktails were also phenomenal and beautifully presented. The Buzz Buzz ($20) we got had a fragrant honey flavor to it that went beautifully with the Maker's Mark, and was presented in a beehive-shaped glass dome. It's served with a Szechuan flower inside that numbs the tongue slightly, akin to the Szechuan peppercorn. Very nice detail! The Butter Kiss ($18) was even better in my opinion, on the sweeter side but with a buttery, caramely richness to it. I'd call it "adult Butterbeer." My wife ordered a nice glass of Eola-Hills Pinot Noir ($16), which was of course poured at the table after she was kindly offered a tasting sample.
I'm not sure where all the negative reviews come from to be honest; I understand that people may have worse-than-expected experience with service or with wait times for their food, especially at this price point, but for two pretty average people who like to go out and splurge every now and then on a nice date, we had a lot of fun and would come back!