Docile L.
Yelp
We arrived at the City Club on Thursday June 18, 2021 around 3:00 PM. This is a wonderful get away location we have cherished and sponsored several months a year for the past 10 years. We have appreciated this place for its historical architecture for its historical decor and friendly staff.
Sadly, this place has changed.
Eventhough after reopening its doors after the COVID-19 related closure, the architecture remains intact in its outside, inside it is a completely different story. Before we address the inside I must stay how disappointing it was walking in the premise and being received "greeted" by some type of property manager in a very cold, impersonal almost punitive in character. Upon our arrival she approached us at the top of the stair and yelled "You guys need to wear masks, and if you don't have any, we have some back there." She was rushing around erratically, for no reason, since we were the only guests at the site, at that time.
She pointed at...we don't know where....
We were ok with her cold welcoming, we understand people are panicking about the COVID thingy, and they should, but since the Club is Just reopening, a more gentle greeting would had been appreciated. This is particularly necessary because there were no signs outside the door stating mandatory use of mask.
The real shocker was how much Japanese furniture and decor have been added to the inside. These cheap, Japanese pictures, tansu, chairs, picture frames, vases, tasteless flower pots with pasted on codfish, heavily ornate bureaus, chinoiserie style bookcases, etc...all really repulsive and vulgarly out of place. At times we felt like walking into an all-you-can eat cheap sushi restaurant in the middle of an Asian furniture flea market. Nothing wrong with Asian furniture, but for the city club...? That was ridiculous.
Also the premises were dirty with cobweb everywhere, There was no sign of maintenance personnel other than a single guy running around, exploited keeping the place head over waters. The women working the office and the general manager should walk around with a rag, dusting off the place, that would be a good use of their time.
The breakfast given was only comparable to US Army MRE's. One hard boiled egg, one tasteless peach yogurt, and a really dry chocolate croissant. These breakfast boxes were stacked up at the front of the reception booth, with a $45 sign right behind them. Not sure what that was all about but we felt confused and werent sure if they were charging $45 for such breakfast insults. To add insult to injury, when you approach such breakfasts boxes the receptionist locked eye with yours to ensure their ostentatious display was indeed effective, maybe hoping you left behind a $20, a $20 and a $5 atop the table.
The room: it was clean, however there was paint peeling off from the bathtub walls. Not safe for children.
There was also a non functioning water knob on the shower pipe head-high which posed a serious threat. We hit it on our way down to soap our feet, and on our way up to rinse them out. This was just an absolute poor design.
In the bed area, the mattress was hard as a rock, this made us feel like sleeping at the Tower of London, It was simply a true punishment. But, the biggest problem was the two sharp acorn bedroom curtain hooks, which were screwed right behind the bed, were there should had been a head rest head level. In the middle of the night, upon raising to use the restroom we banged our heads bloody upon them every time.
I had to unscrew the acorns from the hooks in order to avoid being maimed by such terrible negligence.
Lastly, outside our room there was a black and white picture of Julia Morgan accompanied by Two reproduction paintings of the same picture on each side. These had no decorative, nor historical value. We weren't sure we felt like Julia Morgan's presence times three was spying on us.
I hope they spread them out or just get rid of the extra two. We wander if the paintings were viewed as the unwanted gift you have to say thank you for. Really, too much beauty in a single wall.
We will continue supporting this place because the restaurant is beyond wonderful. Exquisite French cuisine, fresh ingredients, amazing duck, trout...really excellent. But what set this restaurant and the Berkeley city club apart from the average is the phenomenal Staff at Julia's restaurant. There were absolutely professional, accommodating, attentive, friendly, responsible and over all gems. We want to say thank you, especially to Maria and Karel. We would love to be back just to see them again.