M A.
Yelp
If you're a crafter, don't rely on Binders to fill a niche for you; if you're an artist, welcome to heaven. Seriously, Michelangelo wishes this place was around in the Renaissance. Aisle after aisle of wax for encaustic, tons of variety of paints, colored pencils, markers, and pastels, and an entire back wall filled to the brim with any kind of paper/canvas you can imagine wanting to use. It's incredible. Don't think for a second that this wide variety of options means they give up quality for quantity. Oh no. Everything in these sacred walls is top notch, sometimes with a price point to match. Yet even the expensive items tend to be cheaper than buying them elsewhere, so don't skimp! Even the staff here is super helpful and friendly, so feel free to ask questions and get all the info you need.
Now for crafters, there are some stamps, inks, and of course plenty of papers to pick from, but this is mostly a shop for the diehard artist or a budding artist in search of starting tools. Still, crafters should check this place out to find charcoal or pencils or other odds and ends to experiment with - who knows what goodies will inspire you next?
I love getting to come here, though the early closing time means I usually can't come except on weekends.