Josh Ryder
Google
First: the location is fantastic, mere minutes from the beach by foot. Close enough (and quiet enough) that you can fall asleep the sound of the waves at night. Parking is ample, the hosts are really wondeful and very knowledgeable about the area. The rooms are well appointed, the queen bed is very comfortable, and the shower runs plenty hot. An utterly incredible location matched with equally great accommodations.
Pro-tip: the Piha store is pretty small and expensive. Make good use of the fridge at Black Sands lodge and bring in your groceries from Auckland.