Blue Colony Diner

We stopped on our way through to PA for lunch. Plenty of parking! We were seated immediately. The waitress, Kelly, was pleasant and professional. I don’t think she knew quite how to react to my jovial side, but that’s fine. We were seated right next to the baked goods - and there were lots of them! My hubby got a slice of cheesecake after his meal. The menu was extensive & it was helpful that the foods were divided by meals (breakfast, lunch, & dinner.) We ordered our meals and they were served quickly. The food was good. It’s a great place for a meal right off of exit 10 off of I84!

Very neat place, found as we were traveling East and hopped off the highway to have breakfast. Farmers Market Omelet filled with ham, veggies, Swiss cheese. Served with a side of potatoes and toast. Also corned beef hash, eggs over easy, potatoes and toast. Really good but nothing over the top. What I would say is over the top, their multiple display cases of desserts and pastries. Wish we had been there later in the day so we could have tried dessert.

This location is so convenient, right of the highway. Service was quick and efficient. The menu was a little excessive, probably 100 items to choose from. Everything I saw, even the baked desserts, looked delicious. The one thing I was not prepared for was the portion size. You could easily make two meals out of these serving sizes. So plan ahead and bring your appetite. I will visit this place again and try something new.

So much love for this place!!❤️Awesome 24-hr diner, great service and delicious food! And really nice waitress Kate. Makes for a great highway stop too, a good and safe break from driving. This place has been here since 1973 and I can see why. Late night 2am breakfast was awesome! Wasn’t rushed because they are open 24 hours and I love that.🏆 It’s top notch all around, the real thing. Great food, coffee, and awesome desserts. Stop and eat here, you won’t be disappointed!🙂 Update, March 23, 2025 - Stopped in for dinner on my way from NC to NH and 5+ stars again! The leg of lamb special tasted great and what a value - $16.95 for soup and salad, entree, and potato - I substituted the mashed. Also got the peanut butter cake for dessert to go with. Yumm! Server Areti was super professional, friendly, and helpful. Stop by anytime for an awesome food & service!!🥗🌯☕️🍔🥞🍰🏆👏🌅

First time I would ever complain about food that is too much! A big salad a cup of soup, and a basket of bread. Way too much to eat and then my main course of tilapia was on top of a huge bunch of pasta. I just couldn't eat it all. But anyway the price was reasonable. And the service questionable.

Terrible experience. Asked for a well done burger and got medium rare. Saw specks of hair on my cheese burger. Waitress was very disrespectful and was just very rude in general. Chili was disgusting, two slabs of cheese were put on chili that was barely seasoned. Would not recommend. We treated the waitress with respect and all she gave back was blank stares and a monotone voice while I saw her with other customers where she was happy and cheery.

Old school diner food is good. I come here to revisit the high school days for French Frie, cheese and gravy and their awesome milkshakes!

While heading down 84, we decided to stop for breakfast at Blue Colony, which I’ve always been curious to visit. It was a pretty average experience, even for a diner. The waitress practically threw our dishes on the table and had zero personality. Food was okay but I definitely have spots I like better for breakfast. Good as a 24 hour option as there aren’t many around.