C L.
Yelp
My wife and I just spent a wonderful long weekend at Blue - Inn on the Beach. We wanted something relaxing, upscale, and within a 3 hour drive of our home in Connecticut. This place was perfect! Three elements contributed to our wonderful experience; the location, the amenities, and the staff.
The location is wonderful. The hotel is situated right on the beach on Plum Island. Plum island is a modest beach community in a good way - mostly local residents who love the low key pace of things. The hotel beach never had more than several people set up in front of the hotel. We had an Ocean View King room which is on the second floor and has a semi-private balcony overlooking the beach and ocean. The ocean is about 100 feet from the balcony. There are beach lounge chairs set up directly in front of the hotel and folding beach chairs and umbrellas are available to take closer to the water.
The amenities included bikes, a hot tub, parking, fire pits, and breakfast delivered to your door every morning. The rooms are well appointed with everything you'd need. The breakfast was fantastic! Every morning at 8am a small wooden box was delivered to your door, which included two baked eggs over greens, two fresh baked products, fresh fruit, oats, orange juice, and fresh coffee. I cannot tell you how enjoyable it was to carry this treasure box out on to the balcony every morning and enjoy the ocean view over breakfast!
Despite a recent change in ownership and only being open for a few weeks, the staff was incredible. Shannon is the hotel manager and was really great at check-in and throughout our stay. Jay is the 'everything' guy... he walks the property throughout the day and will set up chairs on the beach for you, get you buckets of ice with bottles of water, and, most impressively, will sit down and have a nice conversation with you about the island, the property, surfing, etc. He worked for the previous owners and is a great resource for the hotel and the area. His recommendations for the fried clams at Bob Lobster was spot on! The rest of the staff are all friendly and have smiles on their faces.
Overall, Blue exceeded our expectations. Admittedly, we had four perfect weather beach days - so Mother Nature may have tipped the scales in their favor! The hotel is upscale without pretentiousness. A few things that may bother some people... no restaurant/bar onsite, no pool, and no activities/water sports. These were not a problem for us. We were content to relax and soak up the sun on our balcony and on the beach. We kept our refrigerator filled with cold "beverages." We had great meals in several places minutes from the hotel.
We will definitely be back!