Benjamin M.
Yelp
There is a scene in one of my favorite movies, "The Sting," where Robert Redford is sitting in a depression-era diner and is pushing around the "Blue Plate Special" meal on his plate instead of eating it. When the waitress rings up his lunch he tells her "I guess I should have ordered the meatloaf," to which she curtly replies "It isn't any better." That sort of characterizes Bob's Diner.
I didn't come here for the food, but I expected to at least have a decent meal in a diner atmosphere. What I found was a run down restaurant with a limited menu (that due to the font was hard to read the optional choices) that seemed to focus on sandwiches and burgers. I heard they did good breakfasts but it was dinner time so I ordered the chicken parm. sandwich and my wife had the hot roast beef. Service was quick and friendly, and soon our food was up.
My "sandwich" turned out to be a frozen chicken portion deep fried, with cheese melted on, and placed between two of the softest, thinnest pieces of white bread I have ever seen. Then, chunky tomato sauce was ladled over the very top of the bread. A side of crinkle cut fries finished the plate. I was a bit disappointed as I actually expected a sandwich one could pick up and eat, but this was knife and fork territory. The sauce tasted acidic like canned crushed tomatoes and was the highlight of an otherwise unremarkable dish. I wish my fries were super crispy (nearly burned), but they were cooked normally (or as my wife would like them). I tried my wife's roast beef sandwich and it was okay, though it was drowning in what must have been salty, prepared gravy.
Going for broke, we ordered dessert: slices of pre-made apple and lemon meringue pies. Mine was heated upon request and was decent, and my wife's was unremarkable.
But why did I go in the first place? Because it is located adjacent to the railroad tracks, and I wanted to see a train while I ate! The diner's interior is decorated with train pictures (some of historic Watervliet and Albany, some just generic art) and I am a train buff so this place has been on my list for a while. All in all, an average meal with friendly staff. I really think breakfast is where they probably shine, and I will definitely be back for that.