John D.
Yelp
Booth Decay
FKA "The Boothbay Region Lobstermen's Co-Op," is an actual working Lobster Dock that also happens to have a fast-casual restaurant and bar.
We arrived after a day at the nearby Botanical Garden and were ready for our first Lobstah Roll back in Maine.
The Good:
*Happy Hour daily 3 - 5 p.m.
*Clam Chowder was fine, but I thought it should be thicker for my liking. Carissa thought it was fine fwiw.
*Fairly large parking lot that could get filled during busier times of the year, but parking was plentiful upon our visit.
*Full bar with everything from spirits to local micro and macro brews on tap.
*Amazing views from their dog-friendly outdoor dining. They also have some indoor dining upstairs during inclement weather.
The Meh:
*Service wasn't friendly at all from the order or pickup booth. In fact, I'd say it was downright sassy-- and not in a good way. When we asked for our lobster buttered and not dressed (i.e., mayo) we got a giant eyeroll from the maître d'. Why she cares is beyond me, since she's not doing much beyond taking orders. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
*The bartender was slightly better service-wise, but she tends to disappear and you have to wait around for her to re-appear.
*Fries were whatever, but at least they were cheap.
*The Lobster was overcooked and chewy, which is disappointing. However, we will say they were very generous with the Lobster itself, as we both got fairly large pieces of claws. Pro Tip: If two people want a regular Lobster roll, you're better off ordering the large and splitting it. I'm pretty sure the large was at least double the meat of the regular, and it was only $10 more.
*The roll they use for the roll didn't really hold up to the moisture, as it was fairly soggy by the time it reached our table.
The Ugly:
*They really have the gall to charge $2 for a tablespoon of melted butter. As if paying $40-50 for a sandwich isn't enough... 0_o
Conclusion: Below avg lobstah roll with great views but grumpy Gus service. Hard pass.