Jason G.
Yelp
My partner and I stayed at Borgo San Felice for two nights, and overall, I thought this was a beautiful property with amazing rooms, character, and staff.
The "hotel" itself is actually a former village. An actual village with a church and a school and houses that they've turned into the various facilities of the hotel. Thus, that character of the hilltop town is still there.
Service was friendly throughout, and kept the Relais & Chateaux standard that I very much enjoy. The concierge was great, and she was able to book us more than a few tastings at well-known wineries around the area. They have existing relationships with a few wineries and so they certainly treat you better when the wineries know that you're coming from this hotel. Plus, the hotel is centrally located in the Chianti region, but the hotel itself has its own winery with very well-known and well-regarded wines. You should definitely do a tasting here as well.
We were upgraded to a suite, and were informed that it has their new style of decorating. I'm not sure with the old style looked like, but everything I saw was very tastefully done and very luxury.
Overall, I can't recommend this hotel enough. There was one slight hiccup with the pool bar, and it was taken care of and fixed three times more than was necessary, and the staff was very professional.