Amy K.
Yelp
Friends picked us up from the Tarrytown train station and we came here for dinner on a Tuesday night. We had a good meal, good service, good time catching up.
Our 2 friends had the cheesesteak sandwich and both of them loved it. One had fries, the other had a side salad. He had a beer. My husband had the veggie burger with cheese (small upcharge). I had the veggie burrito. We ordered a side salad to share. He had an Amstel light, but I ordered an on tap stout. I must say, the tap list described it perfectly, a stout with hints of peanut butter and chocolate. SO right up my alley; I couldn't finish it (I rarely do) but I enjoyed every sip!
All of had the beer pretzels, which come 4 to a serving so that was perfect for us! We each had one deliciously warm soft pretzel, and the platter came with a small Dijon mustard cup and a slightly larger small cup of melted (probably like a Velveeta?) cheese. We happily devoured those pretzels!
The only false note, which turned out to be no big deal, was that our server inadvertently misunderstood my friend - he ordered French onion soup as an appetizer, which didn't come. She had thought he wanted it with his meal. But the manager said no problem and took it off the check with no fuss at all.
I was very surprised and pleased that for an old-timer tavern they offer a number of vegetarian options!
One caveat you should be aware of. This place is in an old building and is definitely not handicap accessible. One of our party has great difficulty walking, even with her cane. But the street-level entrance was chained off, we had to enter through the alley on the side. There's a staircase there that made it very difficult for her to get in. When we finally all got inside, there were 2 large groups seated in that upstairs room, and the hostess asked if we'd prefer a quieter environment - down a different staircase leading to a street-level room. We were actually fine in the upstairs room - actually got a kick out of a small wedding party, and we sang happy birthday to the woman in the other group who was celebrating. BUT again, getting our handicapped fried out, back down those alley stairs, was difficult. So just be aware, if this is an issue for anyone you're going with.