Bronx House Pizza - Lake Mary

If you’re in the Lake Mary area and craving solid comfort food, Bronx House Pizza is absolutely worth a visit. The wings were perfectly crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and packed with flavor. We also ordered a deep dish pizza, and it was fantastic—rich, hearty, and baked just right with a great balance of sauce, cheese, and crust. Everything tasted fresh and satisfying. Definitely a spot we’ll be coming back to.

It was busy as heck and food still came out at a perfect pace and the waitress anticipated all my needs. I’m honestly sad I cannot recall her name but she had blonde hair! Joey sandwich is the best Sammy I’ve ever had in my life no joke

Standard pizza with a fair bit of good-quality mozzarella. Just got the plain old pepperoni and cheese for the maiden voyage. Staff seems to be pleasant and attentive. Place was meticulously clean.

I'm a big New York pizza fan, and this place has similar pies. Have to start by saying BEST garlic knots I have ever eaten! And pizza is excellent. The lasagna and calzone I also ordered were okay was not a fan. But I will definitely return for knots and pizza.

Saw this recommendation on TikTok normally TikTok restaurants are a hit and miss, but this one hits on everything. I had the crazy Joey and a small pepperoni and sausage flipping delicious. They have a new customer.

Wicked good food here. First time trying this place out. Pizza was excellent and their chicken parm sub and meatball subs were great. The lasagna was good as well. Came back a 2nd time and had the fried ravioli and Beast of Burden pizza. Both were good as well.

Was visiting my family and decided to stop for lunch. I was skeptical since it’s hard to find some real NY pizza out here in Florida. This spot did not disappoint. So if you’re in the Lake Mary area and wanna eat NY style pizza, go ahead and stop in. They live up to their name; BX!

Another NY style pizza place. Food is pretty good along with their service. Ordered the small pepperoni and small ham and pineapple. The waitress was pleasant and took our order quickly. Food came out without a long wait. The pizza is good however nothing fantastic. It's typical NY style pizza with average taste. You do better eating it with a knife and fork. The crust is very limp and the cheese will pull off easily if you bite into a slice instead. They do have cheese and garlic as well as other sprinkle toppings at the table. Still in search of pizza with great taste.

This is hands down the best pizza in Orlando. After living in Michigan and Chicago and trying deep dish pizza straight from its origins, I have to say, Bronx House does it better. Their sauce is superb, with the perfect balance of acidity and sweetness, and every ingredient they use screams quality. They've also come up with some incredible pizza combinations that are truly to die for. Beyond the pizza, they have what might be the best garlic knots I've ever had, I honestly crave them daily. Everything else on the menu is just as heavenly and made with care. To top it all off, the service is always spot on, and they even serve Italian beers and a rotating selection of craft brews. Bronx House is easily my go-to spot for amazing pizza and good vibes.

Finding good pizza in Florida can be hit or miss, but Bronx House Pizza is a solid win. The crust had that perfect balance of crisp and chew, the toppings were fresh, and the flavor took me right back to the Northeast. Easily one of the better slices I've had in the area. The space itself is clean, comfortable, and has that classic pizza joint vibe without trying too hard. Service was quick and friendly, which made the experience even better. I'm giving it 4 stars instead of 5--not because anything was "wrong," but because a perfect score is tough to earn in my book. Still, this is a spot I'd absolutely come back to and recommend if you're craving quality pizza done right.

The hype on this place, for being mid at best. They really love their Parmesan. Like REALLY love it. If you aren't careful, your drink will have it. First night I ordered Bruschetta and garlic knots with extra garlic butter. I didn't get extra butter, I got mountains of Parmesan. Bruschetta wasn't bad, it was build your own. Second day grabbed lunch. Got a slice of pepperoni pizza and cheesy garlic bread. You'd "think" the cheesy garlic bread would have a bunch of mozzarella, but, you guessed it, mondo Parmesan.

I'm from New York and this is definitely one of the best New York pizzas in the area. I would say there are two other similarly good spots. We really enjoyed Bronx house. The consistency of the pizza tasted like home. The tiny little pepperoni stir me off, but that's a preference thing. I like that on their website they advertise it not as New York style pizza but actual New York pizza. Just to give you a sense of how good it was, my wife tries to avoid gluten and she ate two slices of this

Not a bad pizza. I had my reservations, the restaurant looked like a franchise, and NY pizza has been advertised just to attract people rather than serve NY pizza. Fortunately, this was a legit pizza, very tasty and well cooked. I would definitely revisit if I am in the area. The place is also a nice inside, good to hang out.

Came here for a quick bite with my brother in law and sister, as I am from New York & reside in New York. What can I say? Amazing place! I had ordered mozzarella sticks, it wasn't just any mozzarella sticks. They were really cheesy & cheese pull which I love! Chicken tender & fries felt fresh, nothing cold. Everything was hot. I also ordered a Cesar salad & I asked for chicken cutlet, which was so good, it was very crispy. I wish I had ordered more, but it was very quick. I loved everything. 10/10 Ambiance was chill, felt very New York with the decor. Service was great, good customer service & friendly. Hopefully I can come back to try their cheesecake, but recommend everyone coming here!!

Very good food! It was our first time, and we had the garlic knots (excellent), Greek salad, and a deep dish pizza! Service was quick and very friendly. Nice seating area both inside and outside.

Friendly staff, pizza was better than average. Lots of options. Ordered carryout and the text messaging for order progress was great.

Every time my son orders from here, the food is absolutely amazing (their garlic knots were some of the best extra garlicky /cheesy I've eaten) Every time I order from here I get doughy pizza that's burnt on the outside So I can't give them a bad review because I've had a taste of their deliciousness but I cant commit to 5 stars because I've had a not so delicious experience(s) Try them for yourself. You may or may not be pleasant pleased. Buon appetito

I just walked in here because I was having an itch for good good pizza and the reviews seem so good online so I just walked in and placed an order for whatever they had. I must say I had to wait about five minutes more or less, but that was fine, once I left and came back in, my pizza was ready and I died. Crust was delicious, pizza definitely had volume and all the ingredients were delicious. I would certainly come back here again because I must say this is some good pizza that central Florida has to offer!

Very disappointed. I loved Bronx house until our most recent order. My husband only agreed to go to Bronx versus Esca's because he wanted the lasagna balls. Well, they were terrible. The sauce didn't even look like a normal sauce, they sat cold in a brown meat that smelled burnt. They tasted worse than they looked. Pizza was so so and chicken tenders were given with a side of ketchup when we ordered honey mustard. I think that's our last visit to Bronx house.

I love Bronx House Pizza. Everything is fresh and hot and very very tasty. This place is located in a plaza so plenty of parking. Come get you some.

Huge drop in the quality all the sudden, everything that was good here went from a 8/10 to a 3/10. The pizza was great, something changed recently and it's just straight mozzarella, and the box wasn't their logo anymore either. They used to have decent chicken Parmesan, also not great and even smaller portion. Baked ziti was just not so great meat sauce and some pasta. I'm saddened and confused, we loved this place from the get-go and hope they undo this budget cut it seems happened.

First time eating pizza from here after seeing all the positive reviews from Yelp and Google. We ordered a large cheese pizza and garlic knots. After we got home, I opened the box and it definitely looked like a NY style pizza. It tastes just like it too. It had the perfect amount of sauce and cheese and the texture really nailed the spot. The garlic knots were something else as it had a subtle yet flavorful punch of butter and garlic. It was light and fluffy and made you feel like you were not stuffing yourself. Overall one of the best pizzas in town. My only recommendation is that they have an 18 inch as well.

Went here on a recommendation from my daughter... I ordered the motor city Detroit style pie. I'm originally from NJ/NY and always craving a good pizza! I work for a Detroit based company and travel there often and was looking forward to tying this. First impressions: the pizza looked and smelled great. It's 6 good sized square pieces. Initial observations were that the toppings were very stingy and I would have loved a bit more cheese. Crust was nice buttery and crispy but honestly more like a Sicilian pie. Overall, the pizza is really good, just wish they went a little heavier on the toppings especially since the 6 slice pizza was $27. I ordered over the phone for pickup and service for both ordering and picking up was good, friendly and efficient. The vibe in this place is really cute. NY/Bronx themed subway decor. Clean and bright inside and good sized covered outdoor dining available. Overall I would say this was a really good experience, a bit on the pricey side but the pieces are big and filling. I'll definitely go back to try some of their regular pies.

Hot 97! The combination of the breaded chicken, honey and pepperoni is perfect. And we are definitely fans of the crust, it's not too doughy, a perfect amount of crisp and as a whole- oh so flavorful. The vibe of the restaurant is laid back, the servers are kind, and the greatest part is how fast everything came out. Very happy pizza lovers leaving here ;-)

Well after the harrowing morning courtesy of Milton, we were pleasantly shocked to find this joint open. I am a pizza snob, so I'm hoping a joint named after my childhood home will "deliver." No table service today; order at the counter and they'd bring it to us when ready. BTW: only pizza available; no dinners or whatnot. We ordered a bottle of cab Sauvignon to wash away our problems and wash down our pie. Speaking of which, we ordered a "Big Al," which has red sauce, "mutz," sausage, pepperoni and banana peppers (we opted for none). I asked for it thin crust and well baked. Around 20 minutes later and out it came exactly as ordered. Queen Bee was actually shocked at how good this thing was! To me it was likewise, reminding me of what I'd normally find in a run of the mill NYC corner slice joint. Good quality ingredients portioned out in good ratios, plus a decent crust which was neither too bland nor doughy. I say it is definitely NOT typical Florida crap! While the decor wasn't really standout, it evoked something akin to what one might perceive as evoking "Da Bronx." At least the subway sign was accurate IRT recent vintage and Motown, classic rock and such were playing. We really needed a sit down wind down experience, which is why we stayed rather than carrying out, which is what I'd normally do from a joint like this. The atmosphere here doesn't deserve a $65 price tag. $35 for the wine (it was good at least) was overpriced along with a $24 pie... Did we like it? Yes, plus the fact that the counter girl as pleasant, friendly and accommodating. Would we return? I don't foresee being in this area again, so for me it's a moot point. However if a pizza to go is your aim while around the area, you could do a lot worse, or as one would hear back yonder: "woise!"

After a long drive from Savannah, pizza was the obvious choice for dinner. With a catchy name and gleaning Yelp reviews, Bronx House Pizza made the cut. We opted for outdoor seating and were waited on quickly. The waitresses (3 of them!) were friendly, offered superior service, filled water glasses without asking, and made small talk. The pizza was delicious, cheesy and eaten very quickly! The wings were also saucy and savory. Would totally eat here again!

The pizza here is real good-- you can tell the dough isn't frozen, it's perfectly crispy and just a little salty. Their buffalo pizza is delicious. More affordable pricing would make this 5 stars for me.

I've been to Bronx House Pizza in Lake Mary twice now. On both occasions, the food was excellent. I had the meatballs on my first visit. They were flavorful, tasty, and had an excellent texture, i.e., not too dense.

The staff is always friendly with speedy service. We get the garlic knots and the department of sanitation pizza. Both are fantastic and can feed 4 people easily. I love it with a salad! We are making it a regular spot in our cycle of great places for pizza! Try it!

I would highly recommend the Bronx House to friends and family. After my great yelp experience I knew I had to bring my family here and it was right on par just like I imagined. I really can't choose between the salad the pizza or their wings because together they are a triple threat! If you want a small joint but one that doesn't skimp out on quality dishs I suggest you pay them a visit. I know I can be a complainer when I go out to eat too but not this spot. I'm too busy stuffing my face lol. Oh and my sweet hubby took advantage of the free cannoli they give for a review. It's a kind touch but on the real this place is 5star lil joint.

Lake Mary-My New Yorker GF and I were shopping in this area and she was so excited to try this place out. I am a Californian and know absolutely nothing about New York style pizza. In fact, I haven't met a pizza, in Orlando that I have liked yet. So, if we go to try this New York style pizza. the first thing she ordered was a slice to eat while we were waiting for our to go order. I ordered the Department of sanitation pizza and the boogie down fries. My friend got a plain cheese pizza with added anchovies. Since she is the New York pizza connoisseur, I asked her what she thought of her single slice. She mentioned that the crust was not bubbly, like it should be. She also mentioned that the sauce was just OK. Our orders were up and we took our pizzas home. My combination pizza had plenty of goodies on it, although what they call sausage is some kind of sliced meat product. Not exactly sure what that is. A little offputting for me. The pizza was OK, nothing to get excited about. The fries had gravy, cheese, and resembled poutine. Very salty and not edible. Again, my review is from a California perspective. I think I'm figuring out that. I don't enjoy East Coast pizzas! The gal at the counter was very sweet and helpful.

Sitting outside the Antipasto Salad - mixed greens, tomatoes, salami, pepperoni, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, giardiniera, kalamata olives, roasted peppers was a great way to relax and enjoy a glass of Montebello Moscato. Yeah, don't judge me on the Moscato. Even with the place being in a strip mall, sitting outside still works. Service was very attentive outside and I ordered the Personal bacon and pepperoni pizza for dinner. I probably could have still taken half of it home, but I didn't. My excuse was it being the only meal of the day! Coming from the tri-state area, finding good pizza anywhere else can sometimes be a challenge. How did Bronx House hold up to that measure? Close. The pizza could have been a little thinner. Otherwise, the crust was decent, and I will certainly be back for more at some point.

Let me start by saying the service was great. We had our server but other staff would also come by and check on us so we felt well taken cared of. We started with the whipped ricotta appetizer which was delicious, the ricotta was creamy and it has just the right amount of honey. It did throw us off that the ricotta was refrigerator cold we expected it to be warmer, I don't know why we expected that but it was still delicious and we would order it again. We then ordered the haymaker pizza which was epic. The crust, the sauce the taste it all worked. We ended with the chocolate dessert that was rich which is what chocolate dessert is supposed to be. As you can see we loved Bronx House Pizza!!

Really solid pizza. Available by the slice. Favorite item was the outstanding meatballs. Super friendly prompt service. Great option on this area. I'm not from here but will return next time I'm in town.

Ordered a good amount of food for a work lunch and everyone loved it! Ordering by phone was easy but I wasn't able to use any of the coupons online since it was by phone. Bummer. Thankfully, they were willing to deliver earlier since they normally only deliver after 3pm. We loved the caesar salad, garlic knots and the pizza (sausage, pepperoni and cheese). We also got the cheesy garlic bread and the marinara dipping sauce was perfect! Forgot to take pictures but highly recommend this spot if you're in the area and looking for good, quality pizza and apps.

A nice addition to the Lake Mary area! A pizza restaurant where you can taste the quality of the ingredients! I enjoyed the Hot 97 pizza, which is a must for lovers of spice with the pepperoni, jalapeños, fried chicken, and hot honey! The appetizers are one to be mentioned as the Lasagna Balls and Bruschetta are meant to be shared, but you may not want to, with how delicious they are! I was also able to try the cannoli and cheesecake, the cheesecake is a thick and creamy slice, that has a strawberry sace to add flavor! I'd return to try some of the sandwiches and other pizzas, and I recommend that you do too! Review 1/2024

This is a cool spot for pizza. We went for dinner and we were seated promptly. The ambiance was very cool. We ordered our drinks, and our pizza. We ordered the Haymaker and it was really good. I'd definitely recommend this restaurant for lunch or dinner!

$28 for a 3 topping pizza, $35 delivered. Arrived cold, delivery was 2mi from the store. Very light on toppings. Cut was haphazard. No better than any other local pizza joint, just WAY more expensive. Won't order here again, just not worth it.

Ordered pizza for the office. Everyone loved it. The crust is crispy and chewy just like New York. Lots of toppings. Many different options for pizza. First time trying the Detroit style- it's not a favorite. The topping to bread ratio is not for me. Menu looks great. Lots of non pizza options like salad, pasta, chicken parm etc. Love that they're on Grubhub since there's no way I could pick it up. I would order from here again.

I am not surprised by the service I received. Rachel was my server for lunch this day. She was kind and paid attention to requests. She even helped explain the difference between some of the menu items. The inside was clean and open spaced. The decor was like a NYC pizza parlor, but bistro vibes. I ordered: Garlic Knot Sliders: The knots were fresh and had the right amount of butter and garlic. The meatball was flavorful and juicy throughout. Personal gourmet Butcher Shop: The pizza dough was baked perfectly. I enjoyed each cheesy bite. The cheese pull was dangerously delicious. Veggie Calzone with added ham and pepperoni: It was flaky and fluffy and filled with cheese and ricotta. It came with a side of red sauce. The red sauce is so good. I would recommend getting extra if you want to make a personal pizza at home. Thanks for such an amazing experience again.

This was a hit!!! Everything like the Bronx, minus the attitude! Sauce, quality, cheese, and aesthetically on point! Waitress was on point! Garlic Knot meatballs sliders were so good! The pizza we had was outrageously good!! The beast burden pizza was a great choice. Worthy of a come back visit!

When Bronx House came into the plaza, there was a lot of buzz. I was recommended by a lot of friends to try out their great pizza. Our first visit, we tried the chicken parm pizza which was so delicious. It's a simple pie with pieces of breaded chicken cutlet. The sauce was very tasty and fresh as was the dots of mozzarella. On another visit, I ordered the gnocchi special - gnocchi filled with ricotta in a pesto Alfredo sauce with chunks of chicken. The filled gnocchi was perfect and the sauce was creamy and cheesy. My husband ordered the Sunday Gravy & Meatballs. It's a spaghetti and meatball dish with giant meatballs. The sauce was a simple red sauce that had a rich tomato flavor. He really enjoyed it. The servers were helpful and quick. We didn't have to wait for a table for any of our visits. There is plenty of seating, both inside and on the covered patio. They seem to do a bit of take out, so I hope their popularity is growing in Lake Mary.

There's a new-ish pizza spot in town u gotta visit! Bronx House in Lake Mary was created by Chef Bruno Difabio. Let me tell you, he knows his stuff! We tried so many of their popular items and everything is made with carefully thought out techniques paired with the freshest ingredients The eggplant parm is TOP notch and we really enjoy the Detroit style Haymaker pizza. Highly recommend! Also, I really enjoy putting the Lake Mary salad on a slice of pie...

After attending an Elite event here, I had to come back and bring friends! I was so excited to try more from Bronx House Pizza. We had to start off with the garlic knots, which have definitely broken into my top five knots in Orlando! They're served in a platter of extra butter and garlic and come with a great marinara for dipping. They're bursting with flavor and we loved them! We went with both a NY style and a Detroit style pie, because both are worth trying! We did the Hot 97, and it delivered! Fried chicken, jalapeños, hot honey and pepperoni made this a spicy and unique pizza that I'd recommend for any adventurous pizza eater. Our Detroit style choice was the Nuts and Bolts, which featured pepperoni and sausage with peppers and onions. I am a true Detroit style girl now! I love the fluffiness of the base and the crunch at the end. They do both pizza styles so well, and I'd recommend either one! Our server was attentive and kind, and the kitchen made us a large instead of a small pizza by mistake and didn't charge us for it. This place is a great find!

Had a calzone. Excellent. Enough for 2 meals. Will be back. Pleasant environment and friendly service

Was shopping in stores nearby and came in for some dinner. Cute pizza shop that does provide a small amount of covered outdoor seating. We sat inside and it was seat yourself. Our server was quick with getting us drinks and taking our order. We split a "Department of Sanitation" pizza after of course asking the server WHAT THE HECK IS THAT?! It's practically a supreme pizza with Pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, tomatoes, onions, and black olives. It was yummy. Next time I would like to try one of the many pasta options on the menu. The restaurant was extremely cold. A couple next to us had to go out to their car and get jackets to bring in and wear inside. We heard another table near make comments to the server about how chilly it was. I think patrons would stay a little longer for dessert and such if it was a more enjoyable temperature inside.

Great pizza experience... true NY ingredients-we loved the chicken and meatball Parmesan sandwich. I recommend you come and enjoy a taste of New York style Italian food. And the service is also great.

5 stars because babyyyy that parm was absolutely delicious. I'm from New York, and new yawkers don't play about pizza! Chef Bruno DiFabio did his thing with this place. the staff were all so great & very attentive. Had the Chicken Parmigiana, Detroit Style Haymaker Pizza | NY Style Popeye Pizza, & Colossal Cheesecake | Cannoli The parm was so good, fresh, these are real ingredients, not tomatoes in a can lol. The ny style popeye pizza was perfect as well. The ricotta with spinach was a perfect mix. The cheesecake was fantastic!!!! Fresh, creamy, slightly crunchy. My tastebuds were dancing! Lol. Definitely returning again.

My brother and I decided to try out Bronx Pizza next to the Publix in Lake Mary. We had to wait for one more of our prescriptions to be filled, so we thought we'd give it a shot. We ordered the mild buffalo wings with ranch dressing and the 10-inch personal size gluten-free cauliflower veggies pizza, which wasn't on the menu. When we were ordering the "build your own pizza" option, the server suggested we try the veggie pizza, which wasn't on the menu either. The buffalo wings were baked to perfection and had just the right amount of tangy mild buffalo sauce. The bones looked fresh and not frozen for too long. The cauliflower pizza was definitely the star of the meal. It had a good amount of fresh veggies and cheese in every bite, and the crust was crispy. We enjoyed the food so much that we would definitely return to try other items on the menu. The service was great, and the music was not too loud. The trendy country music they played added to the overall experience. We had a good time and would recommend Bronx Pizza to others.

Enjoying family time and ordering a large pizza- The Beast of Burden!! Happy New Year Bronx House

I stopped in here yesterday for a slice of cheese pizza. The girl on the phone said they were premade which is obvious and the norm for pizza sold by the slice. Place had people there on a Friday lunch. The price was good at $3.21 but the pizza was bad. Lacked flavor. Poor quality ingredients. Just not good. At all. And i didn't feel good after eating it. Won't return and do not recommend.

We picked up to go, walking in it looked very clean and modern inside. The restaurant is a bit small but it has a large outdoor seating area. The person at that handed my order over seemed friendly. And ordering in the web was very straightforward and simple. The waitresses were running around and seemed very attentive. The garlic knots are bomb, such good garlic flavor and they have a little bit of crisp. The lasagna balls were really good too they were crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, we loved them. The pizza I would say is pretty standard it's pretty good but not the greatest. The chicken parm pizza was really good though and I would have it again.

They serve by the slice which is always a plus for us! We ordered 3 slices of pizza (I can't remember the names), but they were all delicious! The sliders and garlic knots were so good! And we ordered a cheese pizza for the kids, which they thoroughly enjoyed! We were visiting Orlando and saw this place on Instagram and decided to give it a try, it didn't disappoint!

As a native New Yorker, I know my pizza and the Bronx House Pizza is the real deal. I enjoyed my quick lunch (slice and iced tea) and will definitely revisit whenever I am in the area. So glad I found Bronx House Pizza!

I was expecting just another NY pizza joint but boy was a wrong. The pizza just felt as if it came out of oven at home ( yes I make my own pizza). The employees made me feel welcomed and I love going to places where you get genuine smiles. I will be returning with my family because this place felt like family. Oh almost forgot the Buffalo wings were some of the best wings I've had in a while.

I ordered through Door Dash so I can't speak to service or ambiance. Received the garlic cheesy bread and a veggie calzone. I'm not sure how to describe the garlic bread but it could have used a bit more love, or maybe a different cheese, it just seemed like slices of cheese had been slightly melted on the bread. I felt like the calzone needed some help with seasonings. I think since there were a lot of fresh veggies inside, the saltiness from the cheese wasn't able to carry the filling, so I would recommend in the future that the veggies be seasoned (or seasoned more) in the future. I think the pizza sauce was good. I may give them another chance since I've heard good things about the pizza. Maybe that's what I need to try next time.

Pros: The cheese pizza was absolutely delish, my party and I got our food delivered quickly. The crust was filling and so was the entire pizza as a whole. Cons: The pizza wasn't hot when it was delivered. I cannot rate the service or ambiance because we ordered through takeout; we did not dine in. Overall score: B-