Jason B.
Yelp
I'm genuinely glad that others have had good experiences here, but unfortunately, that was not how my breakfast went. I was in the area visiting my family over the holidays, and I met three of my friends for breakfast here.
We all got water and a couple of the guys ordered coffee. After a bit, we ordered our meals. I chose the butcher's skillet, which came with four or five different meats, eggs, and cheese over a bed of fried potatoes--basically heaven in my mind.
Once the food was brought, and I took a bite of my meal, I was slightly crestfallen. The bowl had the aforementioned ingredients, but essentially no seasoning to bring it together. I mean that there was not even salt or pepper to add a little flavor. It was incredibly bland.
Also, the cheese was hardly melty, which I think was a combination of the dish being not quite hot enough and the cheese being added right before being delivered to the table. At this point, I was pretty down on this place already.
But then one of the other guys at the table found an eggshell in his meal. He brushed it off, but that is a cardinal sin in my mind. If you're a breakfast place, you can't be letting that happen. Even still, I understand mistakes happen.
We continued talking and eating, and two of the guys said they really enjoyed their food, so I'm glad about that. But about five minutes later, I too bit into an eggshell. At this point I was very displeased. 50% of our plates came with eggshells at a breakfast restaurant. Not great.
The only reason I didn't give a 1-star review is because our waitress was very good. She was polite, prompt, and helpful the entire time, even joking with us a little bit. We talked at our table for probably an hour after finishing our meals, but she told us to let her know if we needed anything, and still came back for coffee and water refills a couple times. Usually there's a huge drop-off of service when I stay to talk after the meal, but not with our server.
We had great service, but eggshells and bland food make it so I don't plan on returning.