Ryan D.
Yelp
First of all, I rate a bar highly based on the total experience. I really didn't want to think this place was pretentious like previous reviews, but I'm sad to foreshadow the rest of my review. Lets start with the positives. The cocktails at Buck and Breck are well deserving of their #50 best bar in the world rating. My bartender, who had a shaved head crafted two excellent and complex cocktails. I forgot their names because I was starting to feel the alcohol by then. But there lies the problem. I dont know the bar keeper's name because there was barely any conversation. I'm terrible with names, but there was barely an attempt to connect at all. All I can't tell you is he had a shaved head, and was stoic when there was no need to be. I'm a big fan of exploring the cocktail scene in different cities, and most of all tasting and experiencing the art of the cocktail each bar keeper can bring. The cocktails are like great dishes to me. I love experiencing the complexity and story behind the cocktail. This place definitely delivered on a wonderful complex cocktail. But unfortunately, they didn't deliver on the story. Each craft cocktail usually has a story behind it, a vision or inspiration behind it. Unfortunately, at Buck and Breck the staff failed to elaborate on what that was with the cocktails I ordered. The bar keeps were attentive in offering me a drink, but they were dry on their hospitality. And in a bar like this, hospitality is what usually puts it over the top. The skills, on creating a great cocktail, of their bar keeps are top notch. Unfortunately from my experience, their ability to connect and share that with the customer was not top notch. It wasn't like they were incapable, because they were having a wonderful conversation with another patron, who was looked like a regular. And seeing that is what added to the feel of pretentiousness. I understand if it was a busy night. But it wasn't busy when I went, and there was barely an attempt to conversate about the cocktail or in general about the inspiration behind the cocktail or bar. It felt like going to an art gallery, where the artist felt too good to explain their inspiration. It was sex without the connection. I will give this place it's just due, that their cocktails are amazing. 4 and half on cocktails, but 2 and a half on hospitality. I've been to many highly acclaimed bars in SF, LA, San Diego, Denver, Portland, Chicago, Paris, Milan, Zurich, and New York. I really wanted this to be favorite bar in Berlin. Unfortunately, the hospitality prevented that from happening. Its a speakeasy bar, and they tried hard to model themselves after the best speakeasy bars in New York and else where. Unfortunately, they lacked the charm that puts those bars over the top. I hope Buck and Breck learns that they can have that exclusive and accomplished feel, at the same time be charming and welcoming. No need to present yourself as the "too good for you" bar. Even at a top 10 bar like Employees Only, in New York, I never felt that vibe. In fact I can't wait to be able to go back and visit Employees Only, because they treated me like it wasn't for "employees only." After all, Buck and Breck should still be a bar where your patrons matter. You are rated the 50th best bar in the world, but it's best to take a page out of the book of the higher top 49 bars, and work on customer experience. Cocktail wise, you deserve all the praise you have been given. For the every day cocktail fan, work needs to be done to live up to your rating. It's actually a 3 and a half star rating in my book. But unfortunately Yelp does allow you to give 3 and a half ratings, so I'm going to round down for pretentiousness.