Butter Baker Market

Butter Baker is one of those places you see on Instagram and say, “oh I want go try that!” and for good reason! I went in August after hearing about their monthly soft serve flavour being a hand crafted sorbet made with fresh passionfruit, orange and guava purée twisted with a Tahitian vanilla soft serve ice cream. I mean COME ON, how could you pass that up?! The ice cream itself was summer in a cone, honestly. It was sweet and tangy, but not overwhelming. Service and atmosphere was great too, as the place was cutely decorated and my order was quick to come out - almost no wait at all. A couple things to keep in mind when visiting Butter Baker: - Unlike the Dundas location, seating in the Markham location is very limited. I think there were only two tables when I went and both were occupied. Since it was super busy, I saw families taking their ice creams to picnic tables nearby or ever sitting under the trees. So, if you plan on walking and expecting to sit down and dine, make a reservation ahead of time (if you can). - It is a bit expensive. I think it came to about $9 for a cone with taxes, which is admittedly a bit on the pricier side for ice cream when compared to Dairy Queen or other local ice cream shops. I think it’s definitely worth it for a one time thing, but definitely something to keep in mind if you are balling on a budget. - There is no clear, large sign that says Butter Baker, so finding the place was kind of task. It was kind of hidden and tucked away in a type of business plaza, so it doesn’t lend itself well to being recognized easily. Follow Google Maps and keep your eyes peeled. All in all, I’d definitely recommend Butter Baker and would probably return myself next summer to try out a new flavour of soft serve. If you are going as a group with kids and all, just be warned because your wallet will be taking a hit :)

Butter Baker in Markham is a cute little shop tucked away in an industrial area, giving it a hidden gem kind of feel. The space is cozy with lots of little trinkets to browse, though I did find myself wishing they offered more pastry options. I tried the shortbread cookies in a jar ($10.50) along with a latte. The cookies were absolutely addictive - finished the whole jar in a day - and paired perfectly with the coffee. The latte itself was smooth and well-balanced. Overall, a charming spot that feels special despite its location. While I’d love to see a bigger pastry selection, the quality of what they do offer makes it worth the visit. I’d definitely come back.

One of my sister’s and my go-to spots for delicious bakery treats and ice cream! They switch their ice cream flavors once in a while! They don’t just offer tasty desserts—you can also find tea bags, coffee, utensils, bags and cute little items for sale. The prices are a bit higher than other places, but everything is handmade from scratch, so it’s definitely worth it as an occasional treat! :>

Bought the Tiramisu cake for my son’s birthday. Butter Baker is consistently good. It’s a go to for our birthday cakes and any special occasions. Just make sure to order ahead of time online especially if you want a bigger size.

I will give credit for all the other times I've been here, the ice cream is usually very good. HOWEVER, this time the cone melted faster than the ice cream that was already melting. The cone disintegrated and the wet ice cream went everywhere. The ice cream was still decent but I had to eat it out of my hands.... I'm not sure if that is worth $8.

Such a good cake, although it tastes more almond-y than pistachio? It’s also on the higher end on pricing for cakes but the quality is there.

My favorite ice cream spot! They introduce a new flavor every month, and I absolutely love the fruity ones! It’s always buzzing with people on the weekends, especially during the summer. Just a heads up, you might want to prepare for a bit of a wait, as their service can be on the slower side. But don’t worry—they prioritize quality over speed, and it’s definitely worth it!

Everything looks good but tastes bad. Definitely not worth the hype and premium price point. We tried the croissant, cookies, birthday cake, and soft serve, which was the main reason for our visit. The texture of their soft serve was like an airy slush, collapsing as you eat it rather than melting smoothly. Although there were visible specks of vanilla bean, the flavor tasted artificial and watered down. I’m usually a fan of Earl Grey desserts, but this one tasted off and too perfume-like. They also don’t accept cash for purchases (lame business practice) but do accept cash tips which is amusing. There should be clear signage, specifically on the front door, stating that cash is not accepted so customers without cards don’t waste their time. They happened to have some change the day I went, so they were able to take cash but I only had big bills so I purchased one of their retail items to balance the total. The one star goes toward their retail selection. Lots of cool locally made/canadian artisanal products.