Mr S.
Google
This was on my to-do list for such a long time. Years, in fact. So hard to get a last-minute reservation, or a spot for 1.
Celebrated because it's historic and the rare spot serving Catalan classics. I've never been 100% convinced by its menu, and as a result, have never been 100% committed to spending a reservation slot to eat here. It IS worth a visit, just to check it off your checklist. But no repeat.
The food is solid, mostly. The pig trotter special was pretty good. The canelons is rich. But the love for it... I don't share the locals' adulation. The cap i pota was a little too salty. OK, but I've had better. A few blocks from here, in fact. The duck l'orange, which the waiter sweet-talked me into - sucked. Note to self - the Spanish are great at cooking many many things, duck ain't one of them. It was dry and overcooked and lacked flavor. Just a waste of stomach space.
The service is biased, and I didn't find it to be great. Regulars and local celebrities get all the attention and love. The space is old, as advertised, and cramped when the restaurant is full, which is almost always. The premium in prices over other places serving similar food and the difficulty of getting a seat - make this place not worthwhile for most tourists and not practical as a regular weekly meal. Try it once. Not really worth repeating.