Stephen L.
Yelp
As the name suggests, Cacio e Pepe is known for its famous pasta dish of the same name, which is uniquely served out of a large pecorino cheese wheel which was very cool. Naturally, as a cheese lover, I had to order this. The pasta was cooked to be nicely al dente, and was unsurprisingly deliciously cheesy - maybe a bit too cheesy by some people's standards, but was more than fine by me. My main complaint though was that there were large whole peppercorn pieces in there, which were simply too big. With every bite, I felt an intense sharp pepper flavor that took away from the actual tasty pasta flavor. They really should just grind down these peppercorns, and the dish would be much more enjoyable. $23 for this dish might seem a bit high considering it is basically just cheesy pasta with nothing else added (aside from the peppercorns of course), but given the unique presentation, it could be considered reasonable. Plus, the portion size was decent and more filling than it looked.
We also tried the 3 for $30 salami and cheese combo. The prosciutto was high quality, the capocollo salami was also good but a little too salty, and the pecorino tartufato cheese had little truffle pieces inside and was tasty. Again, I think this was a little overpriced but I suppose one could argue it is authentic and pretty high quality so not too bad.
The place is cozy and lively, with some classic Italian restaurant vibes inside including wine bottles along the walls. The staff were average friendliness, pretty attentive, and the service speed was decent. For some reason, they have decided to only accept Amex or cash as payment, which is a bit inconvenient. They do have an ATM in the back though for this exact reason. It can get pretty busy during the weekends so I would recommend making a reservation if you're trying to go during peak hours.
Overall, I think Cacio e Pepe is a decent authentic Italian restaurant and I would recommend it if you are interested in experiencing the cheese wheel pasta for yourself. Otherwise, I think the pasta is just okay in quality and the options might be slightly overpriced, but not exactly a bad option either.