Douglas M.
Yelp
I've been here a few times and started my review before covid and then went back recently to finish but many things changed, so here the break down:
First change, All Hero's $15, kinda price for a small town shop, but they usually have a line so people are finding it worth it. For me at that price point, the sando has to be over the top good.
I ordered #16 Italian Combo (ham, salami, prosciutto, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onion, roasted peppers, pepper rings, garlic, oil and vinegar, salt, pepper, oregano)
It was good, but not over the top good. If I return I would add mustard and may with no cheese. I removed the cheese, provolone is to strong and over powers the meat and veggies. I have a feeling they might not allow changes, they seem to run a tight ship. The bread was really good, long sub roll, chewy crust with a soft inside. The meat was good quality and all the veggies but wow factor was not there in the dressing. I assume they combine the garlic, oregano, oil, vinegar, salt and pepper to make the dressing and then squeeze bottle it over the veggies. The flavor was light, not bold. I couldn't taste the garlic or oregano, the vinegar came thought which was good, but again light. To make it over the top worth $15, the dressing needs to be better.
Precovid visit notes.. They are not serving these salads but the guy mentioned that would be coming back.
Anti pasto salad, good.
Potatoe salad, good on the sweet side, kinda like Costco brand
Macaroni salad, good, a little sweet, but not too bad. Traditional style
#6 Vinni's Stromboli, toasted, pepperoni, Genoa salami, ham, provolone, roasted peppers and tomato salad. This seems to be there signature sandwich, which is very good, if I return I'll try this again
#18 Buffalo Bill toasted turkey pepper jack blue cheese, ranch, cholula, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes red onion, It has some spicy heat, it was ok
Cool Hand Luke, pastrami, pepper jack, hot cherry peppers, Russian dressing, deli mustard, toasted
The breads was awesome, peppers are hot, maybe a little over powering, pastrami is Good quality, the rest good. I might try this one again