Jeffrey Z.
Yelp
I'll preface this review by saying that my wife and I are pretty spoiled and have stayed in amazing places all over the world. Canoe Bay is absolutely gorgeous, very serene, and compares with many places in those regards, as did our cottage. However, the service does not even come close to comparing, which is, perhaps, by design. It is difficult to find a staff member, and it appeared that you couldn't contact reception from the room phone. The booklet in the room said to use our cell phone to call, but both of us had very spotty service.
We had a lot of fun here enjoying our beautiful cottage with two fireplaces and two decks overlooking the lake. We hiked around the property, paddled through the lake in a small boat, and loved walking through their organic garden. We even saw a few deer, a snake, tons of frogs, and a few other creatures.
The lodge in the middle of the property was very nice and features a beautiful library filled with books, a good collection of DVDs from which you can borrow and watch in your room, a gym, as well as some hotel-type rooms available to guests. We enjoyed grabbing a book and sitting on the back patio overlooking the lake. (The lodge is said to feature wifi, but it's pretty spotty. However, in this kind of getaway, that isn't a major issue in my opinion.)
Our biggest issue here was the lack of availability of food and beverages. We meant to pick up some wine on the way but forgot, and that ended up being a huge mistake. We got the package that included food, but the breakfast (delivered to your room each morning) was only a small muffin or two each, and the lunch was either a very small burger with no sides ($16 if you didn't get it included) or a salad. Luckily, we were able to order wine with our meals and walked over to reception to order a bottle at one point as well.
The dining room where we had dinner both nights of our stay was very nice. The food was nothing special but decent, and the staff was wonderful. They are really good about accommodating allergies and preferences if you let them know beforehand (there is a set menu each night). The food was fresh, but the flavors were nothing special. The entree the first night was short rib with gnocchi, which excited me. The short rib was pretty good, while a little dry, but the gnocchi was some of the worst I've ever had. It was like glue.
All portions are small here, so if you are like me and like to eat a lot and get hungry throughout the day, be sure to bring your own snacks (our cottage had a functioning refrigerator and microwave). Also, if relaxing on your vacations tends to involve a lot of drinking, I'd recommend bringing your beverage of choice. Not only do they not serve any liquor, but the wine and beer are expensive. Bring bottled water too. While it's provided, they only gave us 2-4 at a time, and we drink a lot of water. With the food and beverage supply, it almost felt like we were at some sort of health retreat. So unless they are going for that, they ought to at least have more available to interested guests that are willing to pay.
I generally don't mind places with limited service, but for the price, I think this place should really step up the service if the costs make sense on their end. Despite its few downfalls, this place is wonderful overall, and next time we're looking for a peaceful getaway in the Midwest, we may go back (with a full cooler).