Canteen

NOT vegetarian friendly. Ordered a veggie bowl and was given a chicken bowl. After taking it back they then gave me a veggie bowl with pieces of chicken still inside, after confirming they didn't just remove the chicken pieces. Hopefully the chefs soon learn this isn't acceptable - I don't advise any vegetarian to go near this place.

No vegan option and the most boring protein free vegetarian options you can imagine. And apparently the vegetarian stuff is contaminated anyway. 🤮

Being one of the ONLY businesses/eateries on an island surely ensures your business-survival. Anywhere else, this place would've floundered so quick. +1 to all other previous reviews (go take a browse) Over-priced, mediocre to bad, customer service is awful. Wait time was ok when I visited, but it was breakfast. Egg sandwich was ok, lacked salt. Coffee I ordered was so bland and weak, when I ordered EXTRA shots of espresso. This is a sin in NY. At those prices, you'd think they'd invest more in personnel. For faster/better food prep and a more gentle mug at the register. Yet, we know nothing will change *sigh*. Until my next FI trip next year, Canteen. Until next time.

Food is great. But, poor customer service. If you’re willing to wait 1 hour for a burger and fries this is your place.. Hope you treat your customers fairly. Best of luck to your business and I hope you’ll fix the issue.

Two “eggwichs” and a coffee $37? What’s worse is they’re poured eggs like a holiday in, no taste. Ordered both with bacon and one came with sausage… for that price they should be cracking fresh eggs and maybe even offer bagels as an option? Outdoor seating was nice and inside was clean. Metal chairs don’t have cushions for some reason. Not comfortable! Maybe they don’t want you to stay for too long…. The Pines can do better. 2 stars.

not good. Over priced. Chicken wrap is over seasoned cold chicken and tastes like they made it yesterday and sorted it in the fridge. The fried shrimp in the taco tasted like corn dog batter. 0 out of 5

Wonderful place to grab breakfast or lunch right on water. Friendly staff. Simple menu. Great to eat outside on-site, grab something to-go for beach or coffee/snack before taking ferry back home. Commercial strip has great convenient shops next to each other. Bathing suit/beachwear shop, grocery store, floral shop, wine/liquor store. Everything you need all on beautiful convenient strip. Also a hair salon/barber shop and hotel.

There aren’t many places to relatively quickly grab food in Fire Island, so it’s pretty hard to avoid Canteen. The food is hit or miss yet expensive for what you get. I did however find the burger to be good. The breakfast menu is limited yet the breakfast burrito was shockingly bland. Food aside, it’s convenient and centrally located. Perfect for a bite after day drinking by the pool or the beach.