Captain Whidbey

Our stay at Captain Whidbey Inn was nothing short of magical. From the moment we arrived, we were charmed by the serene setting and warm hospitality. The view of the pond from our room was breathtaking—peaceful and picturesque, like a scene from a storybook. The rooms were spotless and incredibly cozy, blending historic charm with modern comforts. Every detail felt thoughtfully curated, making it easy to relax and unwind. The customer service was impeccable—staff members went above and beyond to ensure our family felt welcome and cared for. Our kids were absolutely delighted by the experience. Whether exploring the grounds or simply enjoying the cozy atmosphere, they had a wonderful time, which made our stay even more enjoyable. We spent two nights at the inn and left with memories we’ll cherish for years to come. Captain Whidbey Inn is a true gem, and we can’t wait to return! If you're looking for a magical and relaxing getaway, this place is a must-visit.

Loved the sauna and peaceful grounds! The bartender is super charming and the dinner was fabulous! We came with our dog and stayed in the pet friendly lagoon suites. Very charming and can't wait to return!

We have visited several times for dinner and drinks, but just had our first overnight stay at the Inn. I can firmly say this is a Whidbey Island hidden treasure I wish everyone could experience! Every aspect of the Inn, from the dining room and bar, to the gift shop and the wellness center, is so thoughtfully curated. Every time we go I am blown away by the beautiful interior, the excellent customer service and the overall experience. We can’t wait to come back with family in the summer!

What an amazing getaway spot! You’ll feel so cozy and relaxed here. The main cabin has such a warm and inviting vibe, perfect for unwinding. It’s incredibly peaceful with plenty of places to relax, and every corner is Instagram-worthy for photos. The food is absolutely delicious, and at night when you're dining outside, the staff even bring you a blanket while you enjoy your meal. The local Whidbey Island wine is a must-try—so good! The staff are incredibly nice and helpful, making sure everything is just perfect. While staying in the main cabin is a great experience, if you have the budget, I highly recommend splurging on one of the private cabins. Each one is thoughtfully curated for a unique and special vibe. There are so many things to enjoy here, even for a weekend stay, and you won’t run out of activities. Whether you’re looking for a solo weekend getaway, a romantic escape with your partner, or a fun trip with family or friends, Captain Whidbey has it all. And let me tell you about the robes in the rooms—they are so incredibly comfy, I was so close to buying one before the end of my stay! Definitely pick Captain Whidbey for your next getaway—I highly recommend it!

Historic Pacific NW gem. This place is beautiful, cozy, and charming. Visiting in May worked well, before the peak summer tourist season for Whidbey Island. Evenings by the lobby fireplace or making s’mores at the outdoor firepit need flannel shirts. Dinner in the hotel restaurant was delicious. My mom and I got separate rooms in the historic building, which I loved. If (when) I go back, the cabins also look cool. |Tried the sauna and it was fine. Hotel is a quick drive from Coupeville but it’s a fine spot to just hang out and relax, no tv’s in the rooms. Unplug and chill.

No wash cloths in the room. Had to use one of 2 hand towels instead. No phone in room to call for supplies. Take a $200 deposit in case for "incidentals" but when I inquired at checkout said it's in case we damaged the room and it's not returned for 7 days. Room very dated. No television. The bed mattress was like a futon mattress with no bed springs. Very hard and uncomfortable. Probably was a nice place in it's day. Limited menu in the restaurant. No breakfast. Had to grab coffee to go. Thought it would be a nice place to stay, but more of a disappointment.

Captain Whidbey is the ultimate weekend getaway for anyone looking to recharge and escape the mainland. The serene, rustic charm of the property, combined with its breathtaking views of the water, makes it feel like a true retreat. From the cozy rooms to the tranquil surroundings, every aspect of the stay is designed to help you unwind and reconnect with nature. The peaceful atmosphere is perfect for mental health—staying here feels like an investment in yourself, offering the perfect break from the hustle of daily life. If you're looking for a restorative experience in a stunning location, Captain Whidbey is the ideal destination.

Had a lovely time there. Our room was clean and cozy. We ate at their restaurant. The food was delicious. And their carrot cake is the best I have ever had!

My wife and I had dinner at Captain Whidbey Inn to celebrate her birthday last night. The Inn that the restaurant is a part is quite interesting. The log structure is a 117 years old and is really nice, in a rustic way. There is a great view of Penn Cove and the grounds are really nice. The service was friendly and attentive. The food was good and very tasty. The down side was that the menu was limited and a bit on the pricey side.

I'm going to open this review by pointing out that the main lodge is 21+. This is not clearly mentioned up front on their website, except in the FAQ, or if you book the room directly from them, and did not show up as a restriction when booking our room (with our 2-year old) online. If you book through a third-party site (as many of us do), you might never be aware of this until you arrive (like us). It didn't seem to be an issue when we checked in and received our key, or inquired about borrowing a pack-and-play crib, but it was mentioned once, a little snottily, during "quiet hours" (10pm-8am) around 10:05 PM, when he fussed the one and only time all night, for about 2 minutes. I would expect that, upon check in, someone should have said something then, if it was going to be a problem, since he was visibly with us the entire time. Thankfully, this was the only mention of it being a problem, and notably from only one particularly grumpy neighbor whose stomping, door-slamming and snoring were dozens of decibels louder. I guess that's why each room has a white noise machine, huh? It certainly worked for us, to drown him out! Other than that less-than-ideal interaction, we loved our stay at Captain Whidbey! I'd earmarked it as a place to check out in previous years, but never made it for one reason or another. The lodge itself may be a gorgeous, rustic cabin, full of creaky floors and paper-thin walls (good luck getting imtimate without the neighbors complaining!), but it would be hard to beat in the category of old world maritime aesthetic, and all of those things only add to its charm! There's a fantastic on-site restaurant & bar (4pm-10pm) and an espresso stand (7am-2pm), and you can pretty much take anything back to your room, if you'd like. The rooms themselves are a little on the smallish side, but they are very cozy and come with fantastic views of Penn Cove. The bed is firm, but strangely very comfortable; all of us slept like babies...even the baby! Bathrooms and showers are clean and spacious, but shared, and there is only one shower per gender, so you may need to plan ahead accordingly. The grounds also includes a sauna and wellness center, which we were warned takes some time to heat up, so plan ahead a good 30 mins if you are looking to use it. There are also multiple firepits (with wood provided), life jackets and rentable kayaks (in the summer months), and plenty of cozy places to curl up with a book and relax. There are some caveats to enjoying your time at Captain Whidbey, but if you know what to expect, and plan accordingly, your time spent here is sure to be a memorable one.

We love coming here for a weekend away. It's very peaceful and relaxing and calming. I love how quiet it is and it's very enjoyable that they offer coffee in the morning at the main lodge. I do wish they had coffee makers in the rooms. There are no televisions in the rooms which could be good or not so good, but I find I enjoy the views more without it. They have a small, cute coffee shop on site, and lots of gardens to see, and an overlook of the water. Highly recommend!

This Historic 1907 building is a cozy lodge right but the water with rich history, a beautiful garden, peaceful lagoon and a nightly fire. The rooms are split up- with the option to stay in the lodge which shares a bathroom between all rooms or by the lagoon. They do have pet friendly room available as well. The rooms are equipped with a sink and mirror. The beds in the lodge are very comfortable and bathrooms were available around the clock despite It being a weekend with other travelers. I absolutely loved the sitting areas on the second floor of the lodge to enjoy a cocktail or read a book. The downstairs lounge is also a great place to relax and make friends with other guests. The grounds are beautiful and the Chefs garden was great to walk through as was the lagoon with a hammock structure and a nice walk around. There is a gift shop and coffee spot on the property but only open in the morning. Renee and Jordan were very friendly and courteous at the front desk and we felt very welcomed and cared for. All in all a great experience!

Beautiful weather. Pretty pond and lagoon view from the porch of our room; also beautiful views from the back of the lodge. Tasty food and drinks. Friendly and accommodating staff. Clean and mostly comfortable room. Nice products in the shower. Sitting on the porch of our room, which is part of a very creaky building with very little privacy, you can hear the traffic. Room is minimalistic with no a/c or fan and an extremely small and tight bathroom space; like a room you'd find at a camp (& not a luxury one). Food is overpriced; $44 for this small piece of salmon. $12 dessert was good but it was prettier than it was plentiful.

Outstanding ambience and delicious beverage selection. Popped by with a few friends after Musselfest for a night cap. The entrance to the quaint lodge opens to a large stone fireplace and a wall of windows overlooking the water. We grabbed seats at their bar along the back. The bartenders were friendly and assisted in beverage selection. I ordered a pilsner and it was served in a cute glass. Great spot to gather with friends for a night cap!

yelpers here--as always--totally nailed this place. A 3 for food which was ok, the service was slow but why feel rushed anyway? But the cool old building and views are lovely and that's why you're here ;)

The staff was SO kind and helpful. They went over and above to help. I had an allergic issue (all me, allergies are frequent to all kinds of things and a preexisting cold made it worse) They allowed us to switch rooms to a newer part of the property. The inn is a wonderful old 1907 log built lodge.

We had a great stay at the Captain Whidbey, in the Edit Cabin specifically. Experience's will definitely vary as this property has guest rooms that share a communal hallway bathroom in the older, creakier, thinner walled building that I think surprise people / put them off, skewing the reviews on Yelp. But for those who spring for the pricy cabins, your experience will be totally different. The place was exactly as it looked in the photos. We had a balcony overlooking Penn Cove that was really great, along with a sitting room, bedroom, bathroom and little "kitchen" area that we used to make French press coffee in the morning. The fireplace was also a really nice touch - the cabin got quite cold! The property was really fun - we loved the main inn building (we sat in front of the fireplace and played Scrabble and made complimentary s'mores), the tree net over by the lake area, and the coffee shop that is only open in the mornings. This was the perfect base for our two day Whidbey retreat.

Captain Whidbey Inn is, first of all historical. Over the years, the original charm has been preserved which makes this site 'funcky', but authentic. If you value that quality, then this is your place! We have visited twice before and found it to be 'historical' and original. Like many places of this ilk, it is what it is! We found it to be fun and unique, and also overpriced. Accommodations are not highend! However, the prices are high end. Take this destination for what it is--a fun and funky destination. Don't be too picky or judgemental or you may be disappointed. There is limited internet and TV, which may or may not be good, depending on your reason for visiting. The restaurant is fun, but there are also other options in the nearby community. The uniqueness of the accommodations make his place special. See the original architecture that are from days gone by. If you want to step out of the norm of today, visit with an open mind. It is special and delightful--like no other.

Overall, we enjoyed our stay at the Captain Whidbey. On the website, it makes it look like kids don't exist so we had to call to learn more and found out that we could stay with them in the lagoon building. It was lovely, overlooking a lagoon with a beautiful bridge and two rocking chairs on the porch. Be warned that it is very rustic. Everything creaks. You can hear every movement of the people above you. We spent a lot of time shushing our kids. We always try to be considerate, but the thin walls did make us feel extra careful. No a/c or tv. We expected this, so no letdown, but I just wanted to set expectations. One highlight was s'mores, where they provided various chocolate bars in addition to the standard hersheys bars. I'll tell you, once you go Reese's cups on your s'mores, you don't go back. We also loved the tree net - so relaxing to lay in a giant hammock amongst the trees. All in all, the Captain Whidbey is a fun and memorable experience. Go into it expecting an elevated summer camp-type stay, and you won't be disappointed.

We stopped in here for drinks and appetizers with our friends. They don't open until exactly 4:00 pm and not one second before. Once we got seated at the bar, we proceeded to try a number of drinks and wine which were great. We had some appetizers like a charcuterie and mussels which were nice. The bar staff is nice and attentive. We had a good time here. If you want to dine here, you better have a reservation well in advance.

I really wanted to love this place. And while there are a lot of great qualities about it, you won't have much quiet or privacy as is suggested by the website. We stayed in room 205, the "honeymoon" suite. The floors are so thin that we could hear our downstairs neighbors for hours. We could hear every word of their conversation and they were speaking in reasonable indoor voices. We just wanted a quiet weekend getaway as the website markets and it was quiet the opposite. We couldn't relax at all. When brought up to the staff, we were basically told that they couldn't do anything if the noise fell outside of "quiet hours" and the thin floors are just a reality of an old building. So, the takeaway, don't stay in one of the hotel rooms if you want a quiet and private visit. For the price they charge for the "honeymoon" suite, just get a private cabin. Because there were other aspects we did like about this place (location, food, amenities, style) we'd give it one more try but opt for a cabin.

My husband and I stayed here for one night for our anniversary on October 2nd (Monday). We checked in around 3pm and were upgraded to the captain's suite (room 4). I am so grateful for that because the view from our room was the best. The wall of old and charming windows made for an incredible experience with a view across the entire room. It is also conveniently located across from the bathrooms. The room felt so romantic and cozy. We were able to relax in the very comfortable bed with the peaceful sounds of the bay right outside. I booked the lodge for the "experience" and felt like I was on a docked ship in the bay, which made for a fun and unique stay. I didn't mind the floor creaking when you walked as it added to this experience. The communal bathrooms were a bit small but I never encountered another person utilizing them during our stay. We made reservations for the restaurant and enjoyed a delicious vegan meal! Service was also excellent! At night, we could hear the restaurant below but it was mostly muffled and again, added to the experience in my opinion. The noise was gone by 9pm. The grounds are beautiful and we enjoyed walking by the water. The espresso bar is super convenient and we both enjoyed our drinks. The area is quaint and we were able to get vegan breakfast burritos at a nearby cafe. The lodge is adorned with so much charm. We will never forget this stay!

Two stars for the grounds and ambience ONLY. It would be more, but this place is simply outrageously overpriced. It's more of a hostel than a luxury-priced hotel (due to the SHARED BATHROOMS AND SINGLE FEMALE SHOWER FOR THE ENTIRE FLOOR). The room: It's very rustic and cute but edging towards run-down. It has a tiny sink and a full size bed that took up most of the space. It is also VERY LOUD - the walls are so thin they may as well not exist. I was woken up by SNORING in the rooms on either side of me. I thought in my daze that someone had snuck into the room with me and fallen asleep on the floor. There was a very strong smell in my room that I couldn't identify and my complaint was not really addressed. The staff: Very nice staff here!! Lovely baristas and restaurant staff. Check in was good and the front desk was friendly. Amenities: Extremely minimal in the rooms - not even individual soaps or shampoos included. There is a cute barrel sauna and a yoga studio with hot chocolate packets and water. The little cafe is cute and (ironically) pretty fairly priced with good drinks. Overall: This is not a terrible place, but for nearly $600 for two nights, you REALLY expect a higher quality experience! You feel a bit robbed overall...

The Captain Whidbey Inn is a dump. I would rate it zero stars if that was an option on this site. Do not waste your time or your money. Better to sleep in the back seat of your car. Our water view private bath lodge room cost $383 before taxes and fees. We arrived to find the worst excuse of an inn ever. I am a travel agent, and we have traveled all over the world so I have experienced wonderful and rotten. This was the worst. The lighting for the room is a floor lamp with a bulb attached at the end and no shade, a round globe beside the bed coming out of the wall and a hanging round light from the 50's. The linens are fresh from the thrift shop. Towels are thread bare. There was an extremely large tree limb lying on the property with 3 orange cones around it but it was laying there for 3 days. When we left, it was still around. Lots of kids on the property so I hope none of them got hurt. When we checked in and got our room, my husband said, "I specifically asked for second floor." Desk clerk said, "well, you got first, hahahah." I was told 3 guys from CA own the property and Columbia Hospitality manages the property. I think it is time the owners and property manager meet at the property to review what a dump they have on their hands. Or maybe, it's just a cash cow for them, and they don't care??? Prove me wrong, please.

Visited the Captain Whidbey Inn several times over the past 10 or so years and it was always a highlight on my trips to the island. Great service, wonderful people, top notch food, and Pacific Northwest nostalgia to boot. My most recent visit in October was completely void of all of that. Stopped in at 3:00pm on a Monday to have a drink at the bar. Online hours were posted but when we arrived, we're told that it actually didn't open until 4:00. Totally fine, staffing is challenging these days. Said we would be back and did some sightseeing. Came back at 4:10. No one at the front desk. Walked back to the bar where 5 employees where there chatting. Asked if they were open. Dead silence and glares for about 30 seconds before I was told 'maybe soon'. Cool cool. We'll hangout until you're ready. Hung out in the lobby for 40 minutes. Constant chatting and busy work from staff, completely ignored by every person in the hotel/inn. We finally left after an hour of no response, no engagement, and no opening. I get it. It's a tough biz. I've been in it since I was 13. But this pretentious bullshit was ridiculous. I'll never go back because I don't want to ruin the great memories of this place. I'm happy to go to Toby's, have some beers, some pull tabs, and be treated like a real person. 100% awful experience. Don't waste your time or money.

We attended soft opening of bar/restaurant for new owners before the pandemic. Not impressed. Decided to give it another try. Wow!! We ordered 3 entrees and all were delicious (Moroccan hand pies were a hit , as was pork belly and veggies (amazing flavors) and fish and chips. We ate everything, including every French fry (even cold they were crunchy and deicious!). Barrel aged cocktail offerings are inventive and tease your taste buds. Expensive, but if you like a well crafted tipple, go for it! Felicity took awesome care of us. We will be back soon!

Really wish I had read the Yelp reviews for this place instead of just the Google ones, which have clearly been manipulated to have a higher rating than is earned. My husband and I decided to stay 2 nights here to explore Whidbey Island, and I was super excited to stay at what seemed to be marketed as a unique, luxe getaway. Whoever does marketing for this place needs a raise, because the website makes it look like a 5 star wilderness retreat, when in reality it is a rundown 2 star motel with a hefty price tag. We booked the lagoon view honeymoon suite, which boasts luxury amenities like a freestanding soaking tub, premium organic King bed, cashmere goats hair carpet (which is actually disgusting), custom designer furniture, art and organic soaps, etc. Sounds and looks from the pictures like a luxe and relaxing retreat. I understood that the room, being part of an old and rustic lodge, would have its quirks, and expected parts of the experience to feel rustic and noisy, but the website MAJORLY undersells just how "rustic" it is. The room was dirty, creaky, musty, and above all else - had absolutely zero privacy. For a room you are calling a "Honeymoon Suite", privacy is important, and yet the suite is on the 2nd floor of a motel-style building with large windows looking out into the only walkway (a wobbly deck made of what seemed like rotting wood) that patrons can use to get to their rooms. And the soaking tub is DIRECTLY in front of the door, five feet away, and is the first thing you see when you glance at the room from outside. And its not as simple as just shutting the curtains for privacy if you want the bath or to sleep without being watched - this room has no air conditioning. None of them do. I understand and can get behind a rustic camping retreat having no air conditioning, but this is the kind of thing that absolutely must be advertised on the website AND in the booking confirmation, and it was not. I triple checked after the fact because I was so caught off guard. For a "Honeymoon Suite" that is costing $450 per night, air conditioning feels like a bare minimum ask, but it's ridiculous to have it be a secret until you call the front desk at 7 PM wondering why there is no air. It was easily 80-90 degrees in our room when we walked in, which would not have made for a comfortable night's sleep at all, and we were not comfortable keeping the windows open all night with how little privacy we were offered. Additionally, there is no TV, which again I could understand and accept for a unique wilderness experience if that is what had been advertised to me or what I had been charged for. But it wasn't. This inn is worth $150 per night at the absolute most. Additionally, the woman at the front desk wasn't especially friendly, but at least they let us cancel our stay on the spot when I mentioned that no air conditioning would have been a dealbreaker if the website had been transparent. We had no choice but to cancel our entire Whidbey trip, as there was nowhere left to stay on the island, and instead drove 1.5 hours late at night to Seattle, where we paid LESS money than Captain Whidbey charged for a deluxe king room in a 4 star hotel (Alexis Royal Sonesta) overlooking the ocean 2 blocks from Pike Place Market. Don't waste your money here unless you know what you're signing up for. I wish the website had been much more transparent about the condition of this property.

Captain Whidbey Inn is a beautiful destination with incredibly hospital staff and management. The restaraunt is amazing, and the staff does the best job they can to guarantee a comfortable stay.

I struggled with this because I'd say it's a 3.5 and almost solely because I just don't see the justification in price for a room vs what you actually get. The lodge is very cool; low ceilings, huge stone fireplace, cozy. The rooms are cool? In a more updated summer camp vibe way but holy smokes the floors are LOUD. We were on a bottom floor of one of the two lagoon buildings and literally anytime a person above us would even think about moving the whole floor would creak so loud it nearly sounded like they were going to come crashing on top of us. There were neat amenities that we appreciated with kids, a large lagoon area to run around and explore, and a neat tree net climbing structure. The smores in the evening were so fun too! But for a decent motel vibe with a $400/night price tag, I'm not sure we'd stay again.

I just returned from an overnight filled with disappointment. I've been a guest at the inn a few times over the years and it's been nice. But this time the cramped room with its dim lighting rendered reading impossible. It was not charming at $216 for the night. The mediocre dinner at $160 for two definitely left a bad taste in my mouth and I'd like my money back. The experience, for the most part, was awful.

Decided to plan a little weekend getaway for my boyfriend's birthday this year. We had never been to Whidbey Island, and I found the Captain Whidbey Inn while doing some research. We had a good experience here. The inn is extremely charming and cozy. It gave really good cabin vibes, which was fun. The inn itself is pretty small, and then there are neighboring buildings with more rooms and also some cabins you can rent for a steeper price. The front desk attendant was super friendly when we checked in. We were given our key and room number, and we headed up the extremely narrow and small staircase to the upstairs portion of the inn where all the rooms are. The room we stayed in was super small, but it was really all we needed for one night. There was a bed, nightstand, a sink and mirror (which I didn't think would be in there, so I was happy about that), some hooks for your belongings, a little bench, and I think that's about it. In the inn, all rooms share a communal bathroom, which initially I felt a little hesitant about, but it ended up being no problem at all. The bathroom was super clean and stocked with any essentials you'd need. There was also a shower in there in case you'd want it. The hand soap by the sinks smelled amazing, and there was some hand lotion to put on after washing, which was nice because of the chillier weather. When we got into our room, it felt like the temperature was below freezing. I was literally shivering and felt so uncomfortable. I was worried there wouldn't be a fix for this because the inn seems so old -- I kind of figured that the rooms might just get cold and we would have to bundle up. We went down and told the front desk attendant and she came up to help with our heater. It definitely was a bit old and took a while to kick in, but then it got super warm in our room. It ended up being a little too warm, causing a bit of uncomfortableness while trying to sleep, but I was happy it warmed up from the freezing temp. The surrounding area of the inn is super charming and fun to explore. It was a little slick, wet, and muddy on the grounds, so we weren't able to explore as much as we would've liked. I think it would be really fun to come back during the warmer weather to enjoy the area a bit more. The inn is a very close drive to Ebey's Landing, so we went and did that the morning after our stay. It was freezing out, so we couldn't stay out for long, but it was beautiful! Another place we want to go back and visit when the weather is nicer. We also ate at the Captain Whidbey Restaurant, which is conveniently located on the ground floor of the inn. I set up a reservation online ahead of time so we could ensure ourselves a seat. We had a good experience at the restaurant. Overall, we had a fun time here. I'm not sure I'd ever plan to stay longer than one night in the inn due to the tight quarters, but I'd definitely look into booking one of the cabins for a bit more room. It was one of the most unique hotels/inns I have ever stayed in!

I cannot say enough great things about this place. It was one of the most magical places to stay and spend time. The hotel staff was so kind and accommodating. We stayed in the lodge and though these rooms are historic, they were very cozy and comfortable. The entire space is kept very clean and decorated so well. We also ate at the restaurant and had a lovely experience with our waiter and our food. Would 10/10 recommend the cheese plate. Looking forward to returning in the years to come.

Just lovely! Booked at the last minute and the staff couldn't be nicer. Accommodations were unique and comfortable with awesome views. Check-in with Brittany, who hospitality was wonderful.

I can't believe this place is real-- and I mean that in the worst way possible. It's Oregon Trail x Lincoln Logs -- the collab no one asked for and no one wanted (unless, of course, you're into hostel accommodations at resort prices). The COMMUNAL BATHROOMS, tiny room, dark/dingy carpet, cot-like bed and single, dim lantern in the room make it feel like adult summer camp, but without the fun. It is the antithesis of luxury. I would caution anyone thinking that this may be a nice, relaxing way to spend a weekend to reconsider before making the same mistake that we did.

This place is just lovely for a weekend getaway. We stayed in a lagoon room for 4th of July weekend and a cabin for Labor Day weekend. The lagoon room served its purpose, and we left happy. There was a family with 4 children, and they were running around the lagoon area the entire time, so it was difficult to relax given COVID and trying to keep distance. It was interesting watching the dynamics of who would sit in the gazebo. There were plenty of lounges and chairs around the lagoon, so finding a place to relax outside of your room was never an issue. If your room doesn't have a fireplace, there are a few opportunities to have your own fire, which adds to that summer camp in the woods type of vibe. I do feel like they took proper COVID precautions. There is a protective glass shield between the receptionist in the lobby, staff were always wearing masks, etc. I felt very comfortable with all of that, and I'm very Type A and insane about COVID precautions. Staying in the cabin was definitely an elevated experience. There was a fireplace with a wood readily available, cute robes, a personal deck overlooking the water, a mini-fridge, microwave, coffee with a french press and tea in the room. It was so perfect. I wanted the Glasswing ceramic teapot and mugs. I live like 500 ft away from Glasswing, so I figured I should probably just go there more often. If it's cold, I was impressed at how effective their heating systems are in both the cabins and lagoon rooms. I appreciate the Rudy's bath products. The hand-wash and moisturizer (not Rudy's) were amazing. I was really wanted the hand-wash because you can buy it there. I did a calculation by the oz., and it is slightly pricier than Aesop. But it's local and it actually might be better. I was tempted. Maybe next time. The beds are comfortable. Ideally the pillows would have had a bit more structure and oomph, but overall I was happy. There are myriad places where you can get your damn Instagram moments. I feel like the target demographic is millennials who work in marketing for a tech company. It's true that you can easily hear activity in other lagoon rooms, and when you add children to that, well, it could be a disaster. I wonder if they'd lose any business if the lagoon rooms were adults-only like the main historic lodge. If they made it an adults-only place and marketed it that way, maybe they'd actually get more interest? The coordination between the restaurant, bar, and hotel visitors could be improved. First visit we could order food by phone, pick it up at one place, then have to get drinks at another place where there was sometimes a line. 2nd visit we couldn't order food by phone anymore and had to physically go there to place an order. Some of the food was amazing - the mussels and calms, the burger, and fish & chips are definitely worth it. Some of the food was just OK for its price-point. I feel like there is a disconnect between the hotel, where the art, bath products, etc. are sourced locally, and then the IPA at the the restaurant is Goose Island! Like... it's the PNW and we have the best beer in the world. Then you serve Goose Island? On our first visit, we showed up slightly after 3 pm and they said our room wasn't ready yet. WHAT. But it was ready in less than 10 minutes so it wasn't *that* big of an issue. And they handed us the wrong welcome packet with someone else's name, then didn't give us another one when we told them it was the wrong packet and gave it back to them. We aren't really needy, so we don't ask much of hotel staff. Not sure how that would have worked. But for us, the cabin is so perfect, and I highly recommend if you just want to get away from the city for a quick breath of fresh air. I can see coming back and staying in the Glasswing cabin again.

THIS PLACE IS NOT SAFE. DO NOT PLAN A TRIP HERE UNLESS YOU WANT YOUR BELONGINGS STOLEN!!!! We have stayed at Captain Whidbey Inn many times and loved it but this last trip was a total nightmare!!!!! As we were checking out, our car was broken into (while parked in the Inn's lot) and someone stole two purses off of the front seat of our locked car. In what was truly a crappy situation, the staff at Captain Whidbey was beyond rude, completely un-empathetic or apologetic, and truly just cold and unhelpful. Considering the theft occurred on their property, you'd think they would have been showed even the slightest bit of concern but instead this was our issue to deal with and they are now ignoring our calls. The police who showed up was only semi-helpful and it truly seemed like an inside job at the hotel. I REPEAT- THIS PLACE IS NOT SAFE. DO NOT PLAN A TRIP HERE UNLESS YOU WANT YOUR BELONGINGS STOLEN!!!!

I loved this place. Day drive from Snohomish and away from the city. You are able to take the ferry or drive up north and around. The restaurant is very nice, small menu but of quality. In the mornings they offer pastries and espresso in their little gift shop. There is a lagoon on once side and the bay on the other. Parking was available and different types of rooms offered. Be sure to review details as some rooms only have a shared bathroom option.

Awaked by a gas powered weed eater and leaf blower outside our room at 8:30 am Saturday morning. And it went on for 2 hours! Never again.

We had a great one night stay. We only had time in a busy work schedule for a two day/ one night dash from Seattle and it was made extra special as Laura upgraded our room to a suite. We had the ability to lounge with a bottle of wine and enjoy our inn provided house coats. The local trivia night at the inn was a great source of side entertainment as we saw a great bunch of locals having a great time. Thanks to the entire crew.

Imagine a retro summer camp setting with a backdrop of ocean water and fir trees. Then, add a Wes Anderson flair. You have the Captain Whidbey Inn. We were so charmed! There are so many gems to find as you stroll the grounds...a rope swing, a charming gazebo, row boats and canoes to take out on the water. Multiple hammocks dot the area so you can find peaceful moments under the trees. I would highly recommend a visit the Captain Whidbey Inn if you find yourself on this beautiful Island.

6/29/19 Whidbey Island Inn is a great little inn. The staff is very friendly from what I saw. The room I saw stationed in was above the restaurant and the room contained a sink, bed and space to put your toiletries. Be prepared to live out of your suitcase with these tiny but comfortable rooms. These rooms above restaurant have. Two bathrooms. On for women and one for men. Both bathrooms have two toilets and one shower and three sinks. The restaurant has great food and wonderful staff. I truly enjoyed the yogurt parfait. The passionfruit was delicious. I have had the juice m as my times, but never eaten the actual fruit until yesterday. Visiting the party I saw few people dancing, but watching the battle Royal of Sith vs Jedi was humorous. There were not allegiances to anyone but themselves. I was wounded in the battle, but survived where many others didn't. The mastermind behind the how starwars battle was killed at the beginning of the battle. The wedding party was very fun and the kids truly loved and appreciated it. Now on a more serious note. I upon arrival I learned that this in wasn't equipped for people with disabilities/handicapped. If they are, it wasn't in the area my aunt was staying. This place will want to work on that soon. Overall, the general manager and the staff member were very cool and down to earth. We will definitely be coming back here sometime in the future.

We drove 5 hrs to stay here for a 2 day quiet vacation and were excited about the trip. They said, since it's a historic building, the rooms have thin walls, and they give each room a white noise machine. The room next to us had a newborn baby that cried all night. When I mentioned it to the receptionist in the morning she said they don't allow babies. I said, "well there's definitely a baby staying next to us & it was crying most of the night". She said that sounded strange & would look into it. We decided to check out and head home early . The manager, Doug, came out not wearing a mask, as if we are not in Covid times. I asked him if he would be willing to discount the $350 night's bill. He looked at me and said "Really?! We normally don't allow cancellations so you're lucky we're not charging you for tonight". I decided it wasn't worth it to try to debate with Doug, as it doesn't pay to argue with a fool, so I just signed the paperwork and left. Definitely would not suggest this place to anyone I know. If they'd just apologized and tried to make it right I'd have a different opinion, but snobbery is not a good look on a place that is utilizing rustic nature vibes as their marketing plan. Pretty sure the captain would not approve.

A must visit on whidbey island I went to dinner here as a preview to their relaunch after extensive remodeling and opening their new restaurant menu. Everything was so perfect. The menu was fresh and delicious, every dish was made to order with the sort of care you can taste. The new decor is hip. It feels really great to sit in a space so rich with history, but perfectly in the now.

Spent two nights at the captain Whidbey inn. Very cool location and design, we had a very okay dinner at the restaurant. Primary issue was sleep. The buildings are so creaky that every little movement in the rooms around us woke us up not to mention the constantly clicking floor heaters. Across two nights we slept a total of 4 hours. Not the most restful or restorative trip we've taken.

This place is magical! The staff are all very friendly, the food from the restaurant was delicious, drinks were well made, the fire place was toasty, the beds were comfy and the view was fantastic! Their breakfast in the little Cafe was also great. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a relaxing fun get away!

Love love love this place! Such a quaint and beautiful find. They have figured out the Covid life relatively well. To go dinners from the adjacent restaurant. Gorgeous rooms keep the 1907 vibe. No TVs thank heavens! Robes to borrow are in the rooms and are comfy and cozy (and can be purchased for $130). Vibe is all about Penn Cove and the scenery of Whidbey. Don't miss this place!

We stayed there December 26/27 2021. We booked 3 rooms and dinner on the 26th. The rooms were lovely but due to the snow, going up the stairs was dangerous. Shouldn't someone clear and salt the steep staircases? We called for a wine opener and they wouldn't bring it to the room. Shouldn't there be one in every room? We called for a box of cleanex. They wanted us to trudge though the snow and get it from reception. Finally they agreed to bring it. Not great service. The real disappointment was the dinner. As we entered the charming main lodge there was a small fire burning in a beautiful riverrock fireplace but it couldn't warm the lobby. No way. Then we went through the dining room to the bar for a drink. It was literally freezing. Everyone servers and guests were bundled up trying to stay warm. There is another fireplace in the dining room but no fire? Why? The baseboard heaters in the dining room were barely working. Uncomfortably cold as we were seated. We ordered and waited. Our food arrived warm but we had to eat it fast because the food was getting cold by the second. I ordered The Captain Whidbey Burger medium rare. It was burned to a crisp (see photo). Very disappointing. They should have canceled everyone's reservations, closed the restaurant and directed the guests to one of the nearby restaurants and taverns. That experience ruined the stay for me. The place was totally understaffed.

One of the reasons I booked a room at Captain Whidbey was because my boyfriend and I are awful planners and decided to visit Whidbey Island for the fourth of July less than a week before the holiday. Almost every hotel in the area was booked out, but we were fortunate to find a room here at a really good rate. When we checked in, the front desk attendant was very friendly and helpful. It was a pretty quick check in process. At times during our stay, we noticed the desk attendant was not always there, so you would have the ring the bell for assistance. We never experienced a problem getting in contact with them. The room is small. Really small. There's room for two people, a suitcase, and that's about it. Definitely not a room you can do cartwheels or yoga in, if that's what you're into. There's a small sink in the corner, and the restroom is shared. Yes, you'll have to exit your room and walk down the hallway to a shared bathroom and a single shower. The walls are paper thin. An elderly couple was in the room next to us, and we could hear everything they said... and one of them coughing up a lung all night. It was also really hot, so we had to use a coat hanger to prop open the window, which was right above the kitchen. The food in the restaurant below was really good, but pretty pricey. It was difficult to find a staff member in the morning to order food from. The view is wonderful though. Overall, it was a pretty good experience. It's a charming place and has history to it, but I probably wouldn't stay here again because I was bothered by the paper thin walls.

Exceptional service and a beautiful backdrop for a wedding ceremony and short weekend stay, even on a drizzly winter day. We reached out to the Captain Whidbey Inn with six weeks' notice after changing our wedding plans no fewer than three times (!) throughout 2020. The events manager, Ali, was stellar and guided us through the process of pulling together our plans and vision. The Inn was very COVID conscious in the midst of evolving guidelines and did everything to make our day feel special. Ali even created a simple ceremony design using elements from around the Inn when we wanted to dress up the gazebo. Cozy and awesome, and the Edit Cabin was a great place for getting ready on the day-of and relaxing after the ceremony. Make sure to stop by the bar - their mixed drinks are on point! Our only regret is that we couldn't celebrate our reception there - it's a memorable spot for Whidbey locals and out-of-town guests alike!

Aesthetically this place is a gem. The details and thought that went into the remodel are great. However, if you are staying in the rooms by the lagoon, be prepared to be woken up by your elderly neighbors at 6 in the morning chatting about HGTV and how silly those Queer Eye gays can be. The walls are paper thin, and though the inn provides guidelines for when to keep quiet, why would anyone expect baby boomers to follow any sort of rules? The world was created for them, didn't the rest of us get the memo? The restaurant is cute, but grossly overpriced. The food was mediocre and doesn't sit well. If you wanna leave broke ($200 for 2 people) and gaseous enough to play Dutch oven with your cabin mate, then this place is for you! The lamb chop was flavorless and drowning in what was supposed to be babaganoush but instead was a flavorless, gelatinous blob. The pork shoulder was dry and the potato wedges that came with it could be used as hockey pucks. When asked if we were interested in dessert we quickly declined, not interested in what fresh sweet hell would follow. Advice to the inn: get a new head chef. The food was horrible. And invest in sound proofing the rooms. No one wants to hear Barbara and Betty chat about their home improvement programs while laying in bed, queefing out last night's disappointments.

There's so much good going for the Whidbey Inn but also some insurmountable obstacles to provide a great experience to customers. First the good: the location is AMAZING and setting is tranquil. Super cute old log cabin lodge. The OK: service and food were about in line with expectations, every time we went to the front desk, we were greeted with smiles and solutions. The food was imaginative but not executed well - lack of seasoning and generally overcooked. High prices were not in line with what was delivered to table and there was ZERO offer to correct mistakes or compensate in some way. The BAD: the rooms - we were initially supposed to be in one of the private cabins but they called last minute to tell us they weren't ready yet - given the time frame of their call versus the length of time they had our reservation (6 months) AND what was substituted, the experience was POOR. The replacement room, while "newly renovated" suffered from two issues: extreme lack of privacy and the noise from surrounding rooms was excessive. we literally we woken one morning to the downstairs room singing "Climb every mountain" from Sound of Music. Cute but super annoying when you want to sleep. I won't be returning due to the service and room issues but perhaps if they turn things around and invest in those two items they may earn my business back in some way.

Best restaurant on Whidbey island. Almost everything made from local produce, from scratch. Awesome curated cocktails and wine list. Super cool space (and best bar I've seen in a while!). We had great service and a very special time. So cool!

True Pacific Northwest luxury. The Captain Whidbey Inn is the perfect get-away from Seattle. Two hours away, you can feel like you're on a full blown vacation. There are cabins if you want privacy (all individually designed and gorgeous), or a traditional lodge on a pretty lagoon if you want a lovely forest room OR, have a unique social experience in the Historic Lodge with gorgeous views, shared bathroom and an old-school log cabin feel. I loved the Historic Lodge but all that vintage charm does not come with sound proofing so bring your earplugs (or just book all twelve rooms for an extended family/friend gathering and feel like the Waltons :-). This place is gorgeous, views abound, the restaurant and bar are friendly and welcoming. We'll definitely be back.

Sometimes I travel for work and it's how I got to stay at this Inn. It's also because of my company's wonderful executive secretary that cares about her people. I was fine staying at your regular chain hotel but she insisted on me staying here because like I said she cares. This place is quite peaceful. I mean you're surrounded by some big ass trees called madronas. Which the cabin is also built with the same tree. Which is kinda weird because the tree tends to hold the fire real well when burning. Any who, you're also between a lagoon and Pen Cove. The rain hitting the trees and leaves, c'mon now. I'm telling you, light some good bud and just sit by the lagoon and chiill. I stayed by the lagoon and didn't share a bathroom. There's rocking chairs but I preferred hanging out at the gazebo by the lagoon. They've got plenty of chairs and even a fire pit down there! The heat in the room was so nice to walk in to! Not too hot or cold. The big glass door in front of my bed was amazing. Nature was my TV because no rooms has any TV. Well at least mine didn't and that's okay. I just had a really chill time here after I got finished with work.

A dream come true. In 1994 we visited Whidbey Island and drove past Capitan Whidbey's Inn. Its been on my bucket list since then and in 2021 we finally made it. Well worth the wait! The grounds are stunning, I felt so relaxed walking around. Enjoying their patio and visiting with other guests. Check in and out was easy. When you check in they personally take you out to the porch and direct you to your rooms. Walking thru the gardens to our room with the most majestic view on the planet was surreal. Every minute there was perfection. We hung out with other guests on the patio over looking Penn Cove on "Love letters and Champagne" night, enjoyed a take out dinner in our room #201, laid in bed watching the tides come in and out. All the Whidbey crew is fantastic and they attract the wonderful guests, we made 2 new best friends even! Super dog friendly. We will return!

Had dinner here and it was absolutely lovely! Rustic and cozy with a gorgeous view of the water and all around well maintained grounds. We had the Brussels sprouts topped with goat cheese and honey, sauteed mushrooms and Penn Cove measles which were soooo scrumptious! Definitely recommend the mezcal cocktail as well. Great quick service too definitely stop by if you're in town!

Although the setting is outstanding, we were disappointed with the food. The bread was salty. The butter had sea salt added so the combination was just way too salty. The clam chowder is very rich but also very thin, more like consistency found in oyster stew not chowder. The Caesar salad was supposed to have White anchovies but didn't. We asked about it and to their credit they brought us some. The Burrato salad was good. Service was friendly and accommodating while a bit slow, but not so slow that it was a major factor. I think they were just understaffed. The deck was pretty busy tonight and they were working hard to keep everyone happy.