Daniel P.
Yelp
I expect to get a little bit of grief for only giving Captains of Industry two stars. If there was a half-star option, I'd give it 2.5, but there's not, so 2 it is.
Here's my rationale: What does it do that's really amazing, given the prices?
I've now been twice. I can't remember what I had the first time (which probably says something); this time, I had the BLT with avocado (call it a BLAT). I like a good BLT, and it's a often really good measuring-stick for cafes - if you can do the classics well, you can probably do the others well, too.
There was nothing wrong with my sandwich. But there wasn't anything special, either. There was too much bread. There wasn't much of a zing in the mayo. The bacon was good without being amazing. So, what's left? A solid, good, filling sandwich that doesn't blow one's socks off.
Their house-made ginger beer packs a punch: be warned. And it's still, not sparkling, which - in my opinion - makes it slightly less refreshing than it might want to be in a Melbourne summer.
And the ambience? Um. Maybe it's me, and I'll be lambasted for decrying something that's very Melbourne, but I just don't get it. It feels stark and slightly distant, rather than warm and welcoming.
Overall, then, is it bad? No. I just think you can do better.