Carbone's Pizza & Subs

On Sunday 9/21/2025, I ordered a large pepperoni pizza with sweet sauce and double order of wings. The wings were fried crispy with 10 being honey mustard and the other 10 garlic parm. My wings were made so well, I had to call the restaurant and thank them. Previous times we have ordered food and the customer service was lack-luster, but this time everything was great! The pizza was my favorite part! Keep Up The Good Work S. Park Carbones ❤️ (Pic of what was left of my wings😅)

First time coming here and the food was good. Ordered a steak pizza with everything seasoning crust. The order came out in a timely manner and as ordered. The pizza was hot, fresh, and full of flavor. Will be ordering again.

Just called to complain to the manager, I live 30 minutes away, pizza half folded into the crust and didn’t have extra sauce and was cut like a 3 year old did it, I simply asked the manager if there was a way I could send a picture because of the long distant drive and he said “we have to see the pizza in person” I told him about living 30 minutes away and he didn’t even seem to care. We order from here quite frequently but they just lost my business.

When done well the food is sooo good....here's the issue, when busy the quality of the food is sometimes not great and the wait times are a bit longer than expected. A few Fridays ago we ordered wings online, it was going to take an hour, no problem, it's a Friday, that's to be expected. Well, when we got there we waited an additional hour, so a total of two hours to get the wings because it seems somebody may have forgotten to drop them. They were good tho, so that makes up for the wait time. This is Wednesday we ordered a pizza around 6:15 pm, said the pizza would be ready around 7:15 pm, went to pick up the pizza and didn't get it till almost 8:00 pm. Then when we got it some pieces had nothing but sauce on them, no cheese. Other pieces had too much sauce on them and not enough cheese. The pizza tasted okay, but I know it could of been better. It's awesome that they are busy, but please don't rush the food out and let the quality of the food suffer.

Old school pizza shop in Buffalo takeout only. Was told this is the best in Buffalo. Pizza was good. If it had been more crisp it would have been better but I guess this is Buffalo style pizza. The super steak pizza is actually very, very good, friendly staff from the service

Very friendly, outstanding service and food is impeccable even being under the pressure of being extremely busy on a Sunday night we still were greeted with great service, wonderful smiles, laughter, and fantastic food. These guys are sitting in the bar. Don’t be afraid to eat here .!!!

I became fan of Carbone's when I was introduced to this place a couple of months ago. Have now been there three times. Have driven in from Orchard Park for the pizza! 1. The pizza is pure Buffalo-style. 2. You have a choice of sauces. Their original, which is a traditional sauce, and not particularly sweet. They also have their award-winning sweet sauce. It’s actually sweeter than most sweet sauces that are served on buffalo pizza, so only get it if you really like a sweet sauce. I personally like it. Although, if it was dialed back just a little bit, it would be perfect. I wonder if they would mix it with their original if you wanted them to. Going to ask them if they could to get it somewhere in the middle. Either way, I love both of their sauces. 3. The employees I’ve worked with are extremely friendly. Even the guy who makes the pizzas when I’ve been there has come up and said hello when dropping the pizza up front. 4. Pizza has become more expensive everywhere, but compared to other places, it is more reasonably priced at Carbone’s. 5. It’s great to be able to eat the pizza there if you want. The seating area is clean and has a couple of TVs. 6. Seems to do a great takeout business. Great to support a local business. Happy to support Carbone's.

Good food, prices are the higher end but that’s okay. What I don’t like is the long wait times, and seeing the employees being on their phones while I’m trying to order. But Carbones is a staple