Richard P.
Yelp
In this season when I've committed myself to having a first go at many of Central Indiana's traditional holiday experiences, I finally got myself up to Carmel to experience their beloved Christkindlmarkt.
The Carmel Christkindlmarkt was formed as a non-profit organization in 2017 with the support of the city of Carmel (which is obvious since it has a location of high visibility within the city).
It's designed as an open-air Christmas market meant to resemble the traditional German markets. It features products sourced from Germany and other German-speaking European countries. This includes foods and gifts sold from simple (by Carmel standards) wooden huts and a center ice skating rink that promotes a communal atmosphere.
To be fair, despite my fairly modest rating this is an award-winning holiday attraction having picked up prizes from USA Today and Taste of Home magazine. The Christkindlmarkt hosts workers from the Erzebirge region and also has the U.S.'s first Gluhwein Pyramid in a featured position.
The Christkindlmarket is laid out fairly simply primarily utilizing what I'd call the plaza area between the Palladium and Tarkington Theatre. All parking is free in the area, though can still be difficult to find when the crowds grow (and they do). Accessible Parking is located in the Tarkington Garage, though be warned this is a relatively small garage and a fairly tight fit. That said, it's fairly close to the festivities.
Admission to Christkindlmarkt is free, though purchasing from vendors obviously is not. Vendors range from local companies like Rose & Lois, Kit & Kaboodle, and others to very distinctly food-oriented booths focusing on German items. Additionally, if you want to skate there's a nominal fee for both getting on the ice and renting skates (you can bring your own skates, though getting on the ice still involves a fee).
Alcohol is available here - brews are mostly German but not exclusively. There's also quite a few wine alternatives. There are some collectible purchases available, as well, including city of Carmel ornaments and some beer steins.
Pets are not allowed.
The best option for avoiding a huge crowd is going shortly after the Christkindlmarkt opens. This is a place that lights up after dark and that's for sure when the crowds grow. I've now been both times and doubt I would even return at night - as a wheelchair user, I found the night experience dreadful. While it's less festive during the day, it's much more wheelchair friendly. I will note that they offer transport wheelchairs for use, though if you have one of your own I'd recommend it. These are Medline chairs - low quality, cumbersome chairs primarily designed for those who will be pushed by someone else.
Was this a bad experience? Of course not. Was it an authentic German experience? Not even close. It's an experience I'm glad I've had (twice) but it's certainly not going to become part of my holiday experiences. As a wheelchair user, I obviously don't skate and there are really no other attractions that caught my attention other than photo stops. The market booths are fine, though most are priced more like they are in Carmel than they are in Germany.
The crowd at night was a bit overwhelming to me, though I will give credit that the crowd was friendly and courteous and did seem to try to make sure things were accessible.
Things are situated fairly well and there are heating options around for those warm-up needs. Portable restroom options were decent (never ideal for wheelchairs, but they work).
If I could, I would likely rate this a 3.5 star. 3 feels low. 4 feels high. I can understand why folks would love this, though it didn't take me long to figure out it wasn't what I am searching for from a holiday experience. I prefer more substance than style, connection than commercial. I appreciated Farmhouse Flammkuchen, the beer steins, polish pottery, and Bob's Belgian Hot Chocolate.
If I lived closer, there's no doubt I'd probably visit this regularly but even living in nearby Lawrence I simply don't consider it an experience I'll go out of my way to have. We all need our own holiday experiences and I'm thrilled for those who enjoy this experience. It's simply not quite what I'm looking for and won't find its way on my regular holiday rotation.