Carmine's

We absolutely LOVE Carmine's! The atmosphere is amazing - it's cozy, warm, and has an old school Italian charm. The service was phenomenal, and the food was delicious! The portions are HUGE - like one dish can feed an entire family! We were so full we didn't get to try the desserts- so we made another reservation to go back later this week! Highly recommend! We ate: Garlic Bread (with and without cheese), Meetballs, Chicken Parm (with and without cheese).

This place was Superb!! From the excellent service to the ambiance and the food! The portions are extremely large so be hungry when you arrive! One plate of pasta and a side of the giant meatballs fed our family of 5 for two nights!!! The mountain of calamari was worth every penny!! Highly recommend.

I don’t understand the hype. The location is great, but for a family of 4 this is not the place to go. The portions are huge, unnecessarily so. An order doesn’t need to be full pound of 1 type of pasta. The penne vodka was unlike any taste I’ve ever had, I think it literally was marinara and Alfredo mixed, inedible in all of our opinions, the chicken parm and sauce were good, but again it was too much, I would rather have smaller family style portions and more variety. Dinner for 4 was over $150 and that was with just one glass of wine.

When I booked at Atlantis I knew Italian is the best way to go for comfort on arrival. It’s located on the boulevard and nice to walk along the board walk. We ordered the red wine Cabernet & it was amazing and had the soft tannins of vanilla. Great for large group of people we order the chicken Parmesan and couldn’t move basically after eating few pieces: was amazing good food : good music and our server was lovely !

Food was delicious. Service was excellent. It is family style with very large portions. Definitely recommend eating here. We had the lasagna, shrimp scampi and lemon chicken. All of it was wonderful.

Ok spot nearby within walking distance to the coral resort. Enjoy nice views of the yachts nearby. They told us immediately as we sat down that the portion sizes are large so we knew what to expect. there was three of us and wow we couldn’t even get through a quarter of the fried zucchini fries. Pasta and muscles were alright but I wouldn’t say wow just basic garlic and butter flavour. I was disappointed with their drinks. I ordered a mojito and the flavour was so different that I couldn’t even drink it. Overall I would suggest if you have a larger family to share it may be worth it considering the size of the plates but if it’s a smaller group one plate is enough for 2-3 ppl.

We went knowing it was pricy but were told the portions were huge. Shrimp scampi ($56) was such a disappointment. It was a few shrimp only. No noodles. The garlic bread was hard and lacked flavor. The ravioli tasted like it was pre-made and lacked flavor. Even the drinks were disappointing. Worst meal of our vacation and it takes a lot to mess up pasta!

This is probably the only and the best Italian fine dining restaurant in the Atlantis on Paradise Island. The restaurant is a bit loud and too dimmed so I would prefer a bit more light and less rowdy. The food portion size is massive as a plate of pasta can feed 3-5 people; this is why it costs $50/plate of pasta. I wish they would told us about the serving size. We ended up taking the whole plate of pasta back to the hotel for not knowing the serving size. Otherwise they wee delicious.