Carolina Brothers Pit Barbeque

Food was delicious. Very flavorful BBQ which we loved. I ordered via DoorDash didn’t receive my corn bread since they were out but they sent a note along with a complimentary pecan pie slice which is such a nice gesture. Definitely would order again, or even dine-in next time.

I have passed by this many times while biking on the W&OD trail and it always smells delicious. So I stopped today and tried it. The brisket meat was tender and the portions with my two sides (potato salad and baked beans - I wanted more options like collards but no luck) were generous (more so with the sides than the meat, but I had plenty). I was disappointed that the meat wasn't more flavorful and the restaurant's own brand of sauces on the table were also bland to me. I do like spicy foods, and the "hot" sauce was way too mild for me. The other option was ok, but not great. Having been to Monks BBQ in Purceville, I had hoped for more. I might go back to try the pork and see if it's better. The service was friendly and I enjoyed the decor (the country music videos not so much, but maybe you will 🙂). Non- IPA beer choices were also limited.

I ordered ribs with 2 sides ( Mac cheese and green beans). Taste good and cp value not bad. Staff are nice and friendly I love to try brisket next time Environment is very country style setting and relax. Something new to try out.

Hmmm… I’m sad because I had extremely high hopes given the reviews. It was not phenomenal but was at least priced accordingly. Although edible, the signature pulled pork sandwich with Mac and cheese as well as baked beans left a bit to be desired but satisfied my hunger. I couldn’t quite put my finger on it but every dish felt like it was missing something. The sauce on the side was not a savior. I can’t speak awfully of this experience because the gentleman that took my order was very kind and the lady that plated my food was courteous. Now those oatmeal butterscotch cookies were wonderfully nostalgic and were indeed the best part of the items I ate, which added a star. I’m sorry to disagree with the other reviews but if hit with a bbq craving this wouldn’t be my first choice.

A hidden griller! Friendly staff, the Mac n cheese, baked beans (perfect kick of heat) were very good! The ribs were excellent quality and adequate flavoring (I prefer dry rub) So if I had the option I would give 5*s I highly recommend them and will be returning for sure! Thank you!

Have been coming here for over 20 years. Lately the portions got so small it’s ridiculous. The platter with two sides used to be a nice meal, now it’s more like a few bites. They did this to me a few times now, not coming back. I understand food prices went up, but for $14 this is not worth it.

Love the ambience, I had mac and cheese and potato salad for sides. The mac tasted like it was out of a box and the potato salad tasted store-bought. The ribs were good, but my issue is that although they claim to be a bbq smokehouse pit, there was no smoke ring on the brisket or ribs, both tasted like they were oven baked. If that's supposed to be East NC style bbq then you guys nailed it. My expectations came from Texas and stayed in Texas it seems.

I picked up a pulled pork sandwich and mac and cheese for lunch, and was blown away! Definitely one of the best pork BBQ sandwiches I've had in a long time, and service was so fast! The staff were also very friendly and answered all of my questions. I wish this was closer to home so I could come more often!