Jeb B.
Yelp
I had lunch here as a guest while I attended a meeting held at the Carolina Club. The experience was ok. The service was great due, in part, to the fact that the students had just graduated so the campus was relatively empty, but the food was "so-so." I think our waiter was grateful for the business.
I've been on an unstoppable hamburger kick so, when I saw it on the menu, I asked for one. Unfortunately, the burger had been a frozen patty only moments before it arrived on my plate. My colleagues who chose the lunch buffet and were far more richly rewarded than I. They described the Paella in glowing terms. And the soup du jour, they said, was quite tasty.
If you don't know a member and can't get in, it's not the end of the world. If, on the other hand, you do get a chance to try it, it won't be an unpleasant experience.
In short, it fits the definition of 3 stars.